2 ms·
In philosophy of science and mathematics there is actually a famous argument by Hartry Field to the effect that Physics doesn't need to posit the existence of a
by cubefox 4y ago
In philosophy of science and mathematics there is actually a famous argument by Hartry Field to the effect that Physics doesn't need to posit the existence of any numbers at all, not even natural numbers:
https://academic.oup.com/book/26363 https://academic.oup.com/book/26363
As far as I know (I haven't read the book) he argues for this by logically reconstructing part of Newtonian Mechanics without any numbers (without assuming the Peano axioms) and suggesting that in principle similar things could be done for other theories.
Now it would be very surprising if Quantum mechanics would even require the existence of imaginary numbers, since these seem to be much less basic than natural or real numbers.
Anyway, I agree that popular articles haven't made it clear what the relevant physicists mean with their thesis. And as a non-physicist it is hard to read the original source.