3 ms·
I've read the whole article twice now and, at the end of the day, it doesn't seem to actually explain anything at all. It explains how standard (complex) quant
by crazygringo 4y ago
I've read the whole article twice now and, at the end of the day, it doesn't seem to actually explain anything at all.
It explains how standard (complex) quantum theory comes up with the right answers, but how you can also just rewrite the equations as a less-elegant "real" quantum theory that involes no complex numbers, that also comes up with the right answers.
Which makes perfect sense, of course, because all of the rules of complex math are written in terms of real numbers at the end of the day. When CPU's are calculating math operations, it's not like any complex/imaginary bits or bytes are involved.
But then the article describes an experimental setup where the results are somehow only consistent with standard/complex QM, and are inconsistent with real QM.
But it totally neglects to say how or why. The entire premise behind real QM is that the complex stuff can just be rewritten as real. But this article seems to provide zero explanation, analogy, or intuition whatsoever as to why there's a case where this would ever not be possible. At no point does the article define what it even means to not be reducible to real math.
So I can't tell what any of this is supposed to mean at all?
- cubefox 4y agoIn philosophy of science and mathematics there is actually a famous argument by Hartry Field to the effect that Physics doesn't need to posit the existence of any numbers at all, not even natural numbers: https://academic.oup.com/book/26363 https://academic.oup.com/book/26363 As far as I know (I haven't read the book) he argues for this by logically reconstructing part of Newtonian Mechanics without any numbers (without assuming the Peano axioms) and suggesting that in principle similar things could be done for other theories. Now it would be very surprising if Quantum mechanics would even require the existence of imaginary numbers, since these seem to be much less basic than natural or real numbers. Anyway, I agree that popular articles haven't made it clear what the relevant physicists mean with their thesis. And as a non-physicist it is hard to read the original source.
- jessriedel 4y agoYou definitely can do quantum mechanics fine without complex numbers. A good article would explain why it becomes much simpler/elegant with them, but apparently this isn't one. Clickbait title.
- Strilanc 4y ago> So I can't tell what any of this is supposed to mean at all? Quantum mechanics is defined by three axioms: 1. States are unit vectors. Vectors whose 2-norm is 1. 2. Operations preserve the 2-norm. They are described by unitary matrices. 3. Systems are combined using the tensor product. If system A has state u and system B has state v, then the combined system (A, B) has state u⊗v. If you apply operation x to system A and operation y to system B, the operation on the combined system is x⊗y. What this paper proved is that, if you use these axioms but limit yourself to unit vectors and unitary matrices with real entries, you cannot explain some experiments. This is surprising because a complex number can be thought of as just a pair of real numbers. For example, in numpy, you can turn any complex ndarray into a real ndarray by making an ndarray with one additional index of length 2, like this: def complex_to_real(complex_ndarray): real_ndarray = np.zeroes(shape=(*complex_ndarray.shape, 2), dtype=np.float64) real_ndarray[..., 0] = np.real(complex_ndarray) real_ndarray[..., 1] = np.imag(complex_ndarray) return real_ndarray These real ndarrays can represent all states and operations that the complex ndarrays could. So how could they possibly fail to explain any experiment? The problem is axiom (3), where systems are combined using the tensor product. The issue is that complex_to_real(A ⊗ B) has one more index than A⊗B, but complex_to_real(A)⊗complex_to_real(B) has two additional indices because you gained one real-vs-imaginary index from A and also one from B. The tensor product doesn't understand that these indices should be merged, instead of concatenated. Using complex numbers tweaks the definition of the tensor product so that it does merge these indices. The experiment is basically a way of checking that you contracted those extra indices instead of keeping them both. So really this result is not about complex numbers vs real numbers. It's about how the states of quantum systems are combined. If you want to use real numbers, you can't use the normal tensor product; you have to use a modified one that understands every system has a special real-vs-imaginary index and that when combining systems you must contract these indices together. Complex numbers just happen to have a tensor product that packages this contract-one-index functionality nicely.