3 ms·
Let me guess without reading, based on what I know of Gladwell: 1. Learn to write pretty well. 2. Come up with a hypothesis. 3. Collect data. 4. Throw out a
by mattmaroon 18y ago
Let me guess without reading, based on what I know of Gladwell:
1. Learn to write pretty well.
2. Come up with a hypothesis.
3. Collect data.
4. Throw out all data that disagrees with your hypothesis, even if it is the overwhelming majority.
5. Write book/article about the data you kept.
- nadim 18y agoSome supporting evidence would be helpful. I'm not familiar with his writing or criticism of it.
- stillmotion 18y agoRead the Tipping Point. You'll understand him within the first chapter.
- alaskamiller 18y ago1. coin catchy phrase 2. write book 3. create a demand for books based on pseudo-intellectualism 4. make sure it appears in every airport gift shop 5. ... 6. profit! i kid, i kid, i own and read all his books.
- ivankirigin 18y agoIs there really a question whether there is something between 4 & 6?
- maryrosecook 18y agoGladwell is successful because he relays a great anecdote. Anecdotes lend themselves well to re-telling, thus his books are popularised by word of mouth. "Man, I read this great piece by this guy called Gladwell about a policeman who could ready body language so well he held fire when facing off a kid with a gun."
- yters 18y agoAnd isn't that precisely the scenario outlined in Tipping point? That's pretty cool - a book that proves its own point. It also reminds me of people who get rich selling self help books.
- unalone 18y ago4 is the one I have trouble with. Where is there disproof of what he's saying? The Tipping Point made a very good case for Gladwell's theory. Blink wasn't as cohesive, but - again - I didn't see anything wrong with the theory itself.
- mattmaroon 18y agoIf you want an example, read an article of his that's freely available called Big and Bad, and then look at NTSB safety stats. His article poses that SUVs are less safe because they are less maneuverable, and therefore more prone to accidents. His "proof" is that a Chevy TrailBlazer didn't handle nearly as well as a Porsche that costs 2x as much on a test track. Fortunately for SUV owners, actual data does show that they're safer. They don't really handle much worse than sedans in their price class, and they do have lower instances of fatalities in accidents. They make up nearly a half of the top 20 safest cars, while they are nowhere near half of the total models sold. Gladwell actually even shows the safety stats of a few hand picked sedans and SUVs, but doesn't bother showing the entirety of the data available, which proves the exact opposite of his thesis.
- unalone 18y agoI'll check that story out. Thanks!
- Prrometheus 18y agoIf by "data" you mean "anecdotes", then you are spot-on.