4 ms·
> For the record, I don't write Rust, because GCC has no Rust support yet. More specifically, I don't use LLVM-Specific languages due to LLVM's license and stan
by eru 4y ago
> For the record, I don't write Rust, because GCC has no Rust support yet. More specifically, I don't use LLVM-Specific languages due to LLVM's license and stance against GCC.
As far as I can tell, GCC is licensed under GPLv3 these days. LLVM is under a variation of the Apache License.
https://www.apache.org/licenses/GPL-compatibility.html https://www.apache.org/licenses/GPL-compatibility.html suggests that you can use code under Apache License in a project that's under GPLv3.
So someone could take legally LLVM, change the Readme and slap a GPLv3 license on it, and have the same license as GCC? (Assuming that the exceptions that LLVM's license has aren't a problem.)
Would that fix your issues? Or what is your specific problem?
- Thiez 4y agoWhat would be the point of that? Upstream will never accept GPL licensed patches and your fork is also available under the Apache license from the original source (except the readme changes that nobody cares about).
- eru 4y agoThe point is that this way you can get an LLVM that's licensed the same way as GCC. This whole exercise has a point, if and only if there's a point to insisting that GCC's license is fine, but LLVM's license ain't. It's just a reduction. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reduction_(complexity) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reduction_(complexity) If you don't have any problem with the license of LLVM in the first place, the reduction is obviously useless to you.
- Thiez 4y agoI thought the point of having something GPL licensed would be that you actually get to enjoy/enforce the copyleft clauses of the GPL. By just relicensing an existing non-copyleft project and not following up with any significant development you only get the illusion of a copyleft project. If you are happy with this license mirage you are essentially saying you only care about the GPL name and not about copyleft. It's just nerdy virtue signalling.
- eru 4y agoAnyone (sub-) licensing LLVM from you would be bound by the GPL.