3 ms·
> The bias problem is also relatively easy to solve No, its not. > (Midjourney has already made massive improvements) Maybe. But it hasn't come anywhere clos
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> The bias problem is also relatively easy to solve
No, its not.
> (Midjourney has already made massive improvements)
Maybe. But it hasn't come anywhere close to solving it even in its domain, which is probably the least concerning domain of AI bias, and not necessarily transferrable.
Actual ML systems that are deployed in production by governments in important roles have massive bias problems, as do SOTA LLMs (including, very much, GPT-4.)
> The AI ethics people have had shockingly little to say on copyright/job loss issues.
The AI ethics people have a lot to say about the first (well “ethics of sourcing without consent” is probably more to the point than copyright, copyright is a component, but that’s more legal than ethical).
They have some to say about the second (well, again “job loss” is the wrong framing; “skill devaluation” is probably more on point), but that’s frankly not an AI issue, its an economic system issue and effects all technological change the same way. Solving capitalism is mostly out of scope for AI ethics. EDIT: Specifically, increasing material output for labor input ought to be, in and of itself (and leaving aside ethical questions of how you do that, which the sourcing issue addresses) a good thing; if there are material losers in that, it is because the economic system to distribute output well, which is not an ethical issue of the system which enables the productivity gain but an ethical issue of the economic system.
> Large organisations systemically overestimated the risks from bias
No, they didn’t. Those aren’t even really risks any more, they are massive current costs of existing adoptions.
> and underestimated the actual AI risks that society actually cares about.
That society (as weighted by social power) doesn’t care about the kinds of bias problems AI manifests is exactly why it is an ethical issue.
> I think the answer is also simple, because accused of racism, will cost any executive in a large company their job.
The large companies that have supplied systems which manifestly suffer from racial and other class biases and which are, in fact, being used in production to implement government policy around the world have not lost their jobs, and neither have the government officials procuring them and responsible for the programs they are deployed in, so this is clearly false.
- ipaddr 4y agoIn general if no one cares does it make it an ethical issue? No one cares if you kill an ant. No one cares if you kill during a war. If what we value vs what we do becomes out of sync an ethical issue arises We haven't been able to remove biase in society. We just added more layers. The more you try to hide the truth to remove baise you start creating your own. The closer we come to accepting the truth the closer we get to solving bias by addressing it not erasing it. AI ethics should cover economic issues brought on by AI. The already discuss sociological issues
- dragonwriter 4y ago> In general if no one cares does it make it an ethical issue? There is a big difference between “no one cares” and “society (weighted by social power) doesn’t care”. Entrenching and reinforcing bias against the already socially weak is something that society, weighted by social power, does not care about, but it is precisely that that makes it an important ethical issue. > AI ethics should cover economic issues brought on by AI. Capitalism’s failure to distribute economic gains well is not a issue brought on by AI, and there is already a much larger body of ethical philosophy directed at that problem with whose work anything the much smaller number of AI ethicists would direct at the problem would be redundant. This is not a problem that remains because of inadequate attention by an appropriate set of ethicists, but, again, because it is one that society, weighted by social power, very much does not care about. Social power in capitalism is, in fact, very much concentrated in those for whom this problem is a benefit, and it is concentrated there as a direct result of this problem.