2 ms·
The degree to which a human has to be creative is very minimal. As SCOTUS said in Feist v. Rural: > "the requisite level of creativity is extremely low; even
by kube-system 4y ago
The degree to which a human has to be creative is very minimal. As SCOTUS said in Feist v. Rural:
> "the requisite level of creativity is extremely low; even a slight amount will suffice"
Literally throwing paint at a canvas is enough to suffice.
Arranging the prerequisite conditions and coaxing a monkey into taking a selfie is probably enough as well (as long as you don't hire PETA's dumb lawyers who want to argue for assignment of the copyright to the monkey)
There's not really enough information to determine whether this author would qualify. We don't know how much editing he did if any, nor have we seen these specific cases tested in a court yet.
- layer8 4y agoI think it needs to be evaluated relative to the volume of the work. If you take a novel in the public domain and just change a few sentences, I don’t think you can claim copyright for the modified novel.
- kube-system 4y agoThat’s true, but the output of something like chatGPT isn’t an existing work. The author’s prompt caused it to be created. I think it will ultimately hinge on whether courts find the totality of the process to be creative enough to constitute a “modicum of creativity” My prediction is that courts will eventually rule that something like writing a prompt is enough. I think too much would be upended to rule otherwise.
- somenameforme 4y agoThe courts are going to always be obsessed with one practical scenario. I take e.g. Harry Potter, put it through an LLM with the prompting of essentially writing the exact same thing with slightly different characters, locations, and phrasings. And then put it up for sale (or free download), making no secret of the fact that it's essentially the same book. If an LLM reaches a sufficient capability that this can be achieved while maintaining a roughly comparable level of readability, then you'd have just completely legalized 'piracy by proxy'. And the same would come to every single medium from movies to software. This is going to make it an extremely difficult question to answer. I expect what it come down to is determinism. LLMs are completely deterministic - same model + same input + same seed = same output. And so any seller will be obligated to retain any model composition/data, and any copyright holder of an input training item will have a copyright claim on any output item. In other words, you can only train on stuff you already have the copyright to, or rights to.