5 ms·
I was really hoping that he would have presented an argument for why we shouldn't be worried about massive unemployment, but he didn't. All he did was point to
by JohnFen 4y ago
I was really hoping that he would have presented an argument for why we shouldn't be worried about massive unemployment, but he didn't. All he did was point to a prior era, at something that is very different from AI, and say "look, that didn't cause massive unemployment!"
Such apples-and-oranges comparisons are not reassuring.
I keep actively looking for why this concern shouldn't be concerning and coming up empty.
- binarybits 4y agoMy argument that it won't cause mass unemployment is that most jobs in the economy are not jobs AI can automate because (1) they involve physical work that current robots can't do (like plumbers or any of the building trades), or (2) they involve interaction with other human beings (child care workers, nurses, baristas, waiters, etc.). To the extent jobs are eliminated in AI-adjacent sectors, people will need to shift to these other jobs that AI can't do.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoI mean not necessarily. You don't need to shift the job to AI before you fire people, you just need to think you can. In many cases in a highly technical & inhuman sense you'll cut hidden inefficiencies by shifting more of the work to the remaining workers, who will be more miserable as a result. We've seen this a lot of different ways to varying extents. There aren't robots making fast food. But there are demand prediction and just in time scheduling systems that allow fast food businesses to run shifts with fewer employees. Nothing "replaced" those workers, but they don't work there anymore, the service is worse, the remaining workers are overworked and lack consistency in their scheduling. Examples like this are all over most industries over the last 10-15 years. We'll see more of it and in novel ways. The AI won't replace your job, you just won't have a job anymore because of the AI. Should you care about the difference? Depends on how much stock you own vs how much you need to work, I think. As white collar professionals we're insulated from a lot of this or at least think we are. It's going to suck shit for most everyone else though.
- gumballindie 4y ago> As white collar professionals we're insulated from a lot of this or at least think we are. How tho? Ai is coming precisely for white collar and knowledge jobs.
- tyingq 4y agoOn #2, there is some indirect effect. AI being able to shift long-haul trucking to self-driving, for example. That would eventually affect not just truck drivers, but all the hotels, truck stops, and restaurants along the way.
- jklinger410 4y ago> they involve physical work that current robots can't do Matter of time > people will need to shift to these other jobs that AI can't do America will not help them do so. Carnage will ensue.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tempsy 4y agoUh that’s not reassuring to people who don’t want to become a waiter. Blue collar jobs are generally safe, especially skilled ones, but lots of entry and mid-level “white collar” work is at risk.
- voiper1 4y agoOK, so this wave of LLMs doesn't eliminate blue collar or the service industry. That leaves "just" removing white collar jobs, which is estimated at 43% of US jobs!! https://www.dpeaflcio.org/factsheets/the-professional-and-technical-workforce-by-the-numbers https://www.dpeaflcio.org/factsheets/the-professional-and-te... (It seemingly includes nurses and teachers, which may need to be removed)
- suby 4y agoFurthermore, the jobs not impacted will be squeezed by increased competition from displaced workers driving salary down. We are going to face massive social disruption because of AI, there is no escaping this.
- IanCal 4y agoFor context as well, the peak of unemployment in the US during the great depression was about 26% (figures I see vary but all fall under this number).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bradjohnson 4y agoMost automation of physical jobs didn't happen by dropping a robot into the same situation as a human, but by adapting the environment for automation. I think the essay spends too much time positing that since most times robots can't be dropped into existing situations, there is no threat of automation for these industries. That might be true for things that can't be changed rapidly (such as how plumbing works in residential housing built over the last hundred years), but for many things it is reasonable to expect capitalists to shift the environment in which that job is done to allow for scalable automation. E.g. Grocery store cashiers haven't been replaced by humanoid robots, but they have been significantly offset by computers and scales and by making the customer do the manual steps of scanning and bagging via self-checkout.
- JohnFen 4y ago> people will need to shift to these other jobs that AI can't do. And why do think that there will be enough of these other jobs for everybody? The funny thing is that when automation caused a large loss of blue-collar jobs, the answer was "just retrain for white-collar jobs". Now that it looks like there's a real threat to white-collar jobs, the answer is "just retrain for blue-collar jobs?" Something is very wrong here.
- binarybits 4y agoI discussed this in the final section: "The level of employment across the economy is ultimately driven by macroeconomic factors: If consumers spend more money, then businesses will respond by hiring more workers. The last three years have illustrated how powerful this can be: In the wake of the pandemic, Congress and the Fed worked a little too hard to boost the economy, producing a super-tight labor market and rising inflation. If AI starts replacing workers in the coming years, that will put downward pressure on wages and prices while growing the economic pie. That will give the Fed more leeway to cut interest rates and give Congress more room to raise spending or cut taxes. As long as Congress and the Fed are doing their jobs, there’s no reason for the total number of jobs, economy-wide, to decrease."
- JohnFen 4y ago> If consumers spend more money, then businesses will respond by hiring more workers. No, they won't unless there's no other option. If AI works out as proponents are dreaming it will, there will be another option. Also, if there's a large amount of unemployment, how will people spend more money?
- bradjohnson 4y ago>If consumers spend more money, then businesses will respond by hiring more workers. That is not how economics works...
- PeterisP 4y agoIf consumers spend more money, then economies of scale increase, which makes it more attractive for companies to increase supply with extra capital investment in automation instead of more labor.
- mywittyname 4y agoI think the fallacy is thinking here is that the number of workers will go to zero. In reality, the productivity improvements will reduce overall costs, and either the field gets easier to break into, reducing wages, or incumbents are able to squeeze out other workers and keep more profits for themselves. There's billions in tech investments flowing into medicine, construction, and hospitality from people hoping to make worker more efficient and aiming to capture a fraction of the wages from those efficiency gains. There's a very real possibility that jobs get replaced by things like, The Home Depot App, which can diagnose an issue, find order the necessary parts from the store, and walk people through all the steps to fix the problem. Again, it doesn't have to completely eliminate jobs, shift how money flows around the market. IMHO, the revolution won't be televised. It will be like self-service machines at the grocery, restaurants, hotels, etc. We just slowly get used to using kiosks and apps to do more and more things for ourselves.
- Beaver117 4y agoCue the wave of replies. Um, akshually, its not sentient yet. It's just predicting the next word. Doesnt matter that it can automate most jobs since its not sentient. We just need to stop sentient AI
- chucky_z 4y agoOne of my family members has permanently lost their job in transcription. It's not that they've lost their job either, essentially the entire field across all specialities (including legal and medical) just doesn't exist anymore as of ~this year (2023). There are still some 'editor' positions, however they don't pay very well and I'd imagine they won't be around long either.
- nikanj 4y agoI’m sorry your family member lost their job, that’s always rough. That being said, the field of transcription is nowhere near dead. Bighand does transcription and dictation solutions and their annual revenue is over 70 million.
- klyrs 4y agoDo they employ humans to do the transcription? A look at their jobs page has zero such openings. This points to consolidation of an entire industry into the pockets of a small number of individuals. That's no comfort to the legions of recently-unemployed.
- nikanj 4y agoThe legal offices employ humans, Bighand provides tools to enable said work. If there was no transcription happening, dictation tools would not be selling for tens of millions per year
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- PeterisP 4y agoOne thing we've seen for transcriptions in medical field (which may also be relevant in legal and others) is a need for a qualified specialist (i.e. the doctor who dictated the thing or did the patient interview) to review and sign-off the final transcription. Currently a transcriptionist does the bulk of the work, and the doctor reviews it; however, with better tools, the doctor would just use the dictation tool directly and review the automated output directly, cutting the 'transcription office' out entirely.
- causality0 4y agoTo me there is a single defining difference between this and every prior revolution: in the past it was the poor people whose jobs disappeared. Now it's the middle class and potentially upper middle class. I anticipate it not actually affecting all that many more people than prior revolutions, but expect it to be far noisier since the people whose skills are becoming irrelevant have much more power and influence than in the past.
- wmeredith 4y ago> in the past it was the poor people whose jobs disappeared I'm not sure that's true. When the industrial revolution displaced factory workers making stuff by hand, they were a new middle class that had moved off subsistence farms to work in the city.
- JohnFen 4y ago> in the past it was the poor people whose jobs disappeared. Now it's the middle class and potentially upper middle class. This is not true in the US. In the past, it was lower and middle class jobs that disappeared. Now the threat is to lower, middle, and upper-class jobs.
- mywittyname 4y agoThe upper class people will profit from the lost jobs. Just like they've always grabbed the lion's share of productivity improvements. The VP of Widgets is going to push an AI Initiative that will save money and increase revenue for the company, and as a result, they will get a nice bonus and a promotion of the Chief Widget Officer. Then maybe segue that into a "consultancy" where they overcharge other companies to advise them to do the same.
- PeterisP 4y agoThere's really no such thing as upper-class jobs; upper class is pretty much defined by not needing a job - the capitalists, landlords, CEO, investors and "heirs"; unlike the upper end of middle class which consists of professionals like lawyers, doctors and (recently) software developers which may have high incomes but aren't upper class because they do need to continuously work for that.
- ericmcer 4y agoI think we will be fine because corporations tend to scale based on their profits more than their actual needs. I think this phenomenon is caused by tiers of management getting budgets and quotas. AI will make industries more profitable but managers have a talent for burning whatever budget they are allocated, more profits will mean higher budgets which means more employees and services consumed. Look at huge tech companies, how did FB become a 75k employee company that runs a social media site with ads on it? I do fear for people who are a one to one replacement in low margin industries like fast food.
- gremlinsinc 4y agoOne company will create an ai that can do anything, from your taxes, to drone delivery, if you want to do your own taxes it can create any interface you want on the fly: QuickBooks, fresh books, etc... need a CRM, blog, or ERP? it can be all those things, need a fantasy getaway? put your vr on and it can give you that too. ie one software with unlimited scope that's constantly reiterating new versions of itself, self improving in near real time. The software company that creates this will be the last software company, and probably the last unicorn so to speak. That's why there's an arms race now, because whoever gets AGI first could be good or bad and everybody thinks they can do it better and safer, but let's fire our ethics team because they slow us down... The team who's first will reach such growth, nobody will ever be able to catch them. Disclaimer: I'm working on my own ai platform too