3 ms·
> It was changed to a license that is completely open except insofar as it blocked Amazon from profiting from it. It didn’t just block Amazon, and even if it d
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> It was changed to a license that is completely open except insofar as it blocked Amazon from profiting from it.
It didn’t just block Amazon, and even if it did, selectively blocking a single downstream commercial user would make it not open source.
The freedom of third-party competitive commercial downstream use is a guarantee against effective vendor lock in, and it is one of the important reasons to choose open source solutions.
Does that make it hard to monetize development of software by just rent-seeking in the “we don’t want to expend the effort to host our own things” SaaS market with a hosted implementation? Yes, but, too bad.
- pydry 4y ago>It didn’t just block Amazon No, I guess it also blocked google, oracle, etc. from monetizing their work without sharing the proceeds from the quite considerable profits they make (something they seem happy to do). Didnt block anybody else though, as you well know. Any regular user of Elastic faced 0 additional restrictions. >Does that make it hard to monetize development of software No. As Amazon demonstrates the software can still be monetized by the most powerful rent seeking players in the market like Amazon. Does it make it hard for the companies not running monopolistic rent machines that actually build open source? Yes. MUCH harder. It would have killed elastic. >too bad. Yes, too bad for open source. You can be anti open source if you like (it has made a lot of people mad, not just MSFT and Amazon) but don't try to dress it up.