2 ms·
Interesting. So we can tell from the last example that humans are perfectly good at doing this reasoning in theory and that therefore the trouble is actually in
by roenxi 4y ago
Interesting. So we can tell from the last example that humans are perfectly good at doing this reasoning in theory and that therefore the trouble is actually in interpreting what the question is asking.
Put another way, if the question could be beamed into someone's head they'd get it right. The flaw is in the part of the mind that loads the words into their brain and not the reasoning after that.
- mlajtos 4y agoI think it shows that we suck at generalization. Even though the task is the same, we are not able to see the same pattern in an arbitrary framing of the same problem. Beaming directly might help.
- travisjungroth 4y agoI don’t think this is the most accurate way to describe it. It’s considering the mind as separate from the brain. There’s also no true version of the problem to “beam” into the brain. That would just be a third version. Our brains aren’t purely general purpose problem solvers. There are parts of the brain that are specifically related to facial recognition versus all images. We’re better at recognizing differences in faces versus buildings. There seems to be a similar “hardware acceleration” for problems about people following rules (can’t remember the source for this). People generally do better on problems if you can frame them as who is breaking a rule, who is lying, etc. I think the last example would still be easier to solve on average even if it was a rule unfamiliar to people.