5 ms·
The New York Times just stole our column. Should we sue?
- meepmorp 15y agoI'm sure that's fair use, and not theft, because the Gray Lady doesn't do such things, and you're vile for even suggesting it. But seriously, yes, sue. And offer to settle if Bill Keller prints a front page apology that makes note of the disconnect between his self-righteousness on the topic of copyright violation and his paper's (apparent) willingness to engage in it when it suits them.
- AndyNemmity 15y agoSarcasm isn't needed here. This place has been great because people say what they mean. You said "I'm sure that's fair use, and not theft, because the Gray Lady doesn't do such things, and you're vile for even suggesting it." Which could have easily been, "I don't think that's fair use, and believe it's theft." The rest I don't even know how to unparse because it's not particularly useful. Are you saying everyone does it? Are you saying the New York Times vilifies anyone who argues they don't? Are you saying other people vilify others that don't? Sarcasm is a way to say very little, and just be cynical with no justification. It's not adding anything to the discussion.
- meepmorp 15y agoOh, eat a dick you, pretentious scold. Your comment wasn't even meant to add something to the discussion, just gratify your ego, and worse, is dishonest in the way it does so.
- donohoe 15y agoUm. Slight over-reaction. They might be right, I'm not sure. They're certainly enjoying their moment in the sun to bring out this huge major offense against the Times. Its Jason Balir all over again isn't it!? OMG! From what I can tell: 1. The NYT didn't run the story "Death and Football" on their site 2. They provided a link to a bad scan of the PDF of "Death and Football" 3. The story, "Death and Football", is not easily accessible anywhere else (if at all?) 4. The point of the main Times story by Nocera directly related to the article 5. The only offense so far is: the PDF was hosted on Times servers The only thing you can argue against is #5 and I think you could make a valid "fair use" argument based on the some of the other points. The PDF provided context. And again, if the "fair use" argument doesn't hold up I think any story about this "theft: would take 3 paragraphs and not 30 or so... Disclaimer: I'm a former Times employee (developer)
- sk5t 15y agoApologist much? The NYT posted the PDF on their own servers, not merely a link. The quality of the scan is immaterial. An entire article, without commentary or any other contribution, is exactly what fair use isn't. While _we_ may take an enlightened approach to republishing out-of-print materials, the thrust of the Phoenix's response is that the NYT hypocritically opposes reasonable approaches to copyright.
- donohoe 15y agoApologist much? Apologist: a person who makes a defense in speech or writing of a belief, idea, etc. Yes, I guess so. I think rprasad said it best: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3569201 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3569201 To quote: This is the textbook definition of "fair use": providing a copy of an out-of-print, otherwise unavailable news article, for the purposes of supplementing a published news article. (Fair use is a multi-factor test with no fixed requirements...it's basically whatever use is "fair" in the context of the actual use.)
- jacques_chester 15y ago> The only offense so far is: the PDF was hosted on Times servers This is the entire offence. We're not talking about lifting a few paragraphs here, it's a pixel-perfect reproduction of a document with multiple overlapping copyrights, none of which the Times had permission to use.
- donohoe 15y agoMy point was that the one thing you can take issue with is very likely "fair use". I also believe that if the author has a legitimate claim it doesn't take 30 paragraphs to make a case. Did you read it through? It took me a few reads to figure out the specifics of what he was talking about. I'm guessing that the view by people here is that the NYTimes took an the Article and published it standalone, by itself, as they would one of their owns, without attribution. That wasn't the case. The NYT wrote an article, referenced the one in the PDF, and provided a copy of the PDF (of an old black/white scan) as context/background.
- rprasad 15y agoLong story short: The original story was actually written by a freelancer that sold the story to a newspaper which The Phoenix gobbled up. The freelancer may have retained the copyrights to the story, except for the serial publication rights actually exercised by the original newspaper (but in either case, not the Phoenix). The Phoenix did not keep records or archives of its stories, and did not even know this story still existed...until the NY Times posted a copy of it. The NY Times had no ability to get permission from the original copyright holder because no one knew who that was. They republished the original article as an appendix/supplementary item to another article published in the physical paper (available online at http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/04/opinion/nocera-the-cost-of-football-glory.html?_r=1&ref=joenocera http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/04/opinion/nocera-the-cost-of...). This is the textbook definition of "fair use": providing a copy of an out-of-print, otherwise unavailable news article, for the purposes of supplementing a published news article. (Fair use is a multi-factor test with no fixed requirements...it's basically whatever use is "fair" in the context of the actual use.)
- danso 15y agoI think that's a good illustration of the quandaries of SOPA: the problem of figuring out these nuances of ownership without disrupting the flow of information. It's easy for a publication to determine whether they themselves are complying with fair use. Not so much with Google and it's automated high scale systems
- jacques_chester 15y agoOn what basis is it the textbook case? I'm not a copyright lawyer (or a lawyer of any kind), but here's the relevant section of the USC: 1. the purpose and character of the use, including whether such use is of a commercial nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes; 2. the nature of the copyrighted work; 3. the amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole; and 4. the effect of the use upon the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work. Note in particular item 3. Mind you, the list is not exhaustive and judges are able to give their own interpretation on questions of substantiality. But very small units of copyrighted material (a few hundred words from a book, a 1 second sample from a 4 minute song) can break fair use. So I don't see how copying the entire work passes the substantiality test. Furthermore, the NYT could have tracked down the source. They got the copy from Booth, Booth wrote it for the Real Paper, and a bit of legwork of the kind journalists are meant to be good at would have revealed that the Real News had been subsumed by the Phoenix. Even if it's not a slam dunk, it's still a blinding act of inconsistency. (Again: IANAL, TINLA).
- waqf 15y agoI applaud the angle the Phoenix chose to take: using this as a platform to petition for copyright reform.
- SoftwareMaven 15y agoFurther proof that when media says "content is valuable and must be protected", what the really mean is "My content is valuable and must be protected. I don't give a damn about yours."
- spacemanaki 15y agoJust in case anyone else glossed over them, all the links in the first few paragraphs are worth reading. A lot of pretty poorly articulated arguments lacking nuance, and a feeble half-defense of SOPA/PIPA that I didn't expect from the NYT, although I guess I could have known better, being the old gray lady...