5 ms·
I’ve also noticed that “”’s stopped working as expected there recently. Sample query: “lowes pet bedding”. The quotation marks do something; they remove some
by hedora 4y ago
I’ve also noticed that “”’s stopped working as expected there recently.
Sample query: “lowes pet bedding”. The quotation marks do something; they remove some results from tractor supply and home depot. However, many results don’t contain the word “lowes” or “bedding”. For example:
https://animalcare.lacounty.gov/licensing/ https://animalcare.lacounty.gov/licensing/
And, none contain the exact phrase. Google does the expected thing (return one result). Annoyingly, the last time I checked, the situation was reversed, and Google search is now useless for other reasons.
Thirty seven spam results surround the one organic google search result for the query. For the love of all that is good and proper, thirty seven?!? Who thought that was a good number?
That result page would make 90’s era pay-for-placement search engines blush!
- explorer83 4y agoYeah I feel all search engines have had declining quality for some time now. Not sure if it's unintended consequence of fighting bots. Or unintended consequence of trying to remove some content from the results. I'm assuming it's unintentional.
- ImPostingOnHN 4y agoit's intentional as a result of them making money off showing you bad results (ads) after all, you aren't paying them
- andai 4y agoIn a recent Google, the first non-ad result was accessible only after scrolling through two pages (phone height) of ads. At least they're marked "Sponsored"...
- weswilson 4y agoI feel like this is a big reason for people wanting to using ChatGPT (LLM's in general) for search results. Search engine quality has declined due to ads/sponsored results and the adversarial nature of SEO driving the signal-to-noise ratio into the ground. So now people are using ChatGPT to lookup the information they'd normally use a search engine for but don't want to wade through the tens of sponsored posts to get to something useful. The idea of LLM's taking over search is pretty gloomy to me, because it destroys the discoverability of unique information. Sites that have expert information often leads you down the rabbit hole and introduces you to new information. With LLM's you will get 'mean reverted' results and won't be introduced to that information that sparks curiosity. On the other hand, it's pretty hard to find those nuggets with search engines these days. Years ago, you'd be able to just Google for the answer. Now you have to go to specific sites to search those knowledge bases.
- AnthonyMouse 4y agoIt's hard to see how removing the ability for the user to be more specific could be a result of fighting bots. That shouldn't have to add anything spammy to the search results, it should only remove things that would otherwise be there. I have to assume it's something along the lines of, they found that a lot of people would put things in quotes when they didn't actually want an exact match, and so changed what it did to better serve the wider audience. But there is no excuse for doing this without replacing it with some other way to specify exact match for the people who know how to RTFM.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pndy 4y agoFrom my experiences nowadays it feels like it's all about pumping SEO positioning with very little actual content you look for. If I try to look for IT related stuff I'm getting trapped around these obnoxious blogs and "sites" that shamelessly rip off someone else's content. Then, for a while looking for anything related to Windows was filling top most results with Microsoft forums, with threads that have all these generic "have you tried turning it off and on again" diagnostic solutions.
- Svip 4y agoThe quotation marks work for me: https://duckduckgo.com/?t=ffab&q=%22lowes+pet+bedding%22&atb=v101-1&ia=web https://duckduckgo.com/?t=ffab&q=%22lowes+pet+bedding%22&atb... I notice in your HN post, you're using fancy quotation marks; I assume you're not using the same while searching DDG.
- nickcox 4y agoDoesn't work for me. Like the GP, I get results unrelated to Lowes, bedding or even pets.
- Svip 4y agoOut of curiosity, I noticed (as I mentioned in a reply to your sibling) I could produce unrelated results by fiddling with the region; does changing region do anything for you?
- nickcox 4y agoJust tried to test it out and I'm now seeing correct results when I set the region to 'US' and an empty list of results when using my own region. This is not at all what I was seeing earlier. Perhaps they're A/B testing or something?
- alex_smart 4y agoThat isn't how the quote feature is supposed to work. I just tried putting the individual keywords in quotes ("lowes" "pet" "bedding") and it works exactly like you would expect.
- nickcox 4y agoHow is it supposed to work? I expect to see only those results that contain an exact match on the entire phrase between the quotes but perhaps I've misunderstood?
- pndy 4y agoDDG for more than a year when there's nothing to show for the phrase, it dumps some unrelated stuff but somehow tied to my location.
- kingofpandora 4y agoThis post is now a search result, so it seems to be working (i.e catching sites with the exact phrase).
- Animats 4y agoI tried graphics card -"nvidia" graphics card -"radeon" on DuckDuckGo, Google, and Bing. Google is currently the only one which appeared to exclude the requested term. Bing and DuckDuckGo not only didn't exclude it, they highlighted it in results.
- phpisthebest 4y agoSince DDG is (or was last I knew) primary using bing under the hood i wonder if this is less a DDG Change and more a Bing Change?
- skinkestek 4y agoReported it a number of times to DDG a few years ago, then just gave up because they clearly don't care. Stuck with DDG until Kagi though since Google is almost equally bad at this, equally non responsive when we report it[1] since Google has managed to fight their way from product I loved to use and company I'd love to work at down to products I actively avoid and company I went to one interview with and didn't care to follow through :-/ [1]: except the nifty trick someone mentioned about throwing you out of your current experiment and into another so it sometimes seems they have fixed it in 15 minutes)
- atkailash 4y ago[dead]