4 ms·

>>https://inflecthealth.medium.com/im-an-er-doctor-here-s-what-i-found-when-i-asked-chatgpt-to-diagnose-my-patients-7829c375a9da https://inflecthealth.medium.co

>>https://inflecthealth.medium.com/im-an-er-doctor-here-s-what-i-found-when-i-asked-chatgpt-to-diagnose-my-patients-7829c375a9da https://inflecthealth.medium.com/im-an-er-doctor-here-s-what... Took a look at this article you linked to and I came to the conclusion I almost always come to when professionals critique GPT. - He's holding GPT to too-high a standard and not recognizing the criticisms and misses of GPT also could apply to many medical professionals in his field. - He is not taking into account that GPT can be quickly trained with new data and address all of the mistakes that he pointed out. So is GPT ready to be an ER trauma doctor? No it's not, but it isn't far from augmenting some of the skills, knowledge, and diagnosis capabilities that an ER doctor may have.

rvnx 4y ago
Counter-example, GPT beating real doctors: https://twitter.com/peakcooper/status/1639716822680236032 https://twitter.com/peakcooper/status/1639716822680236032
- TuringTest 4y ago
  That's like saying that a Google search beat real doctors, because the results surfaced a recent study they didn't hear about. That doesn't make Google better than doctors at diagnosing.
  - rvnx 4y ago
    Yes, there are plenty of such cases but also many where Google gives correct answers and doctors are wrong unfortunately :/ It's very difficult to find a good doctor. Many people are stuck and suffering without diagnosis because of real-life accessibility to good healthcare. I'm talking about having practical access to a good, affordable, available AND knowledgeable doctor. You get access to doctors which have time, and are near you, and in your budget, and they may not know your disease. This is precisely where language models can help to sort and rank the information that is on the internet (if digested by a professional it's even better, but even raw, there is some value to it).
    - TuringTest 4y ago
      That's the reason why a doctor with Google is better than a doctor without Google. That doesn't mean that Google or ChatGPT without a doctor is a good idea.

rvnx 4y ago

Counter-example, GPT beating real doctors: https://twitter.com/peakcooper/status/1639716822680236032 https://twitter.com/peakcooper/status/1639716822680236032

TuringTest 4y ago
That's like saying that a Google search beat real doctors, because the results surfaced a recent study they didn't hear about. That doesn't make Google better than doctors at diagnosing.
- rvnx 4y ago
  Yes, there are plenty of such cases but also many where Google gives correct answers and doctors are wrong unfortunately :/ It's very difficult to find a good doctor. Many people are stuck and suffering without diagnosis because of real-life accessibility to good healthcare. I'm talking about having practical access to a good, affordable, available AND knowledgeable doctor. You get access to doctors which have time, and are near you, and in your budget, and they may not know your disease. This is precisely where language models can help to sort and rank the information that is on the internet (if digested by a professional it's even better, but even raw, there is some value to it).
  - TuringTest 4y ago
    That's the reason why a doctor with Google is better than a doctor without Google. That doesn't mean that Google or ChatGPT without a doctor is a good idea.