3 ms·
> The United States does not do anything other than what serves it's own interests. That's a common belief, especially among people outside the U.S. But I thin
by rayiner 4y ago
> The United States does not do anything other than what serves it's own interests.
That's a common belief, especially among people outside the U.S. But I think it's totally wrong. I don't think you can look at the Iraq or Afghanistan wars, our our support in Ukraine, and say that's serving America's interests. George W. Bush and Hilary Clinton exemplify a bipartisan coalition, cut from the same cloth, that believes in liberal democracy and individualistic human rights as a religion, and who think America is justified in using war to promote that religion around the world.
- dmreedy 4y agoA "bipartisan coalition cut from the same cloth" does not sound very "bi", nor very "partisan" to me, beyond the absolute barest colloquial use of the term to describe the fact that there are two choices of the flag you can raise in order to functionally participate. What you are describing to me sounds a lot more like a single powerbase with a few disagreements of narcissism amongst its participants, with a dramatic hegemonic control over the broader citizenship. The self interests of this neoliberal consensus include empire-building, and have since the cold war that spawned and shaped it. A program to spread that hegemony broader and broader to preserve the flow of resources into the imperial center. I'm trying not to assign morality here per se; just give I think a better model with, I think, more explanatory power.
- rayiner 4y agoI disagree with your characterization because I don't think it's accurate. I come from a country where the government has "hegemonic control over the broader citizenship." That's not what's happening in America. It's much more akin to different infighting sects of the same evangelical religion. I also disagree that your model has "more explanatory power." We spent $6 trillion going to war in Iraq and Afghanistan, and we certainly didn't get $6 trillion in oil. We opened up trade with China, gave them our technology, and put them on a path to leapfrogging ahead of us. Your theory is that America is an empire trying to direct "the flow of resources into the imperial center"--but if that's the case then our imperial leaders are extremely incompetent. What happened in Iraq and China makes much more sense under my model. It was an attempt at converting those countries into our religion of liberal democracy, human rights, and capitalism.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- onetimeusename 4y agoI don't think even the US believes in democracy. For example, in Afghanistan there were 68 parliamentary seats reserved specifically for women. That is very undemocratic and naturally the US doesn't talk about that or the corruption it tolerated from people it propped up, and the anti-democratic measures it put in place in Afghanistan to achieve a desired outcome. The public was misled about the success of the Afghani government but expected to pay for it all. It seems Ukraine is not hugely different if we believe recent reports. I am sure some people in power profited very handsomely while everyone else paid. It's not very different from how the US is run either actually.