6 ms·
Saturn's Interior After the Cassini Grand Finale
- fwlr 4y agoThe part about Saturn’s deep rotation is very interesting. Voyager in the 80s measured Saturn’s rotation (based on radio signals) at 10h39m, while Cassini itself before the Grand Finale measured Saturn’s rotation (again based on radio signals) at 10h45m. Now with the Grand Finale data, Cassini has measured the “deep” (core) rotation at 10h33m. All the measurements are regarded as correct. The explanation for the 6 minute disagreement between Cassini in 2004-05 (10h45m) and Voyager in 1980-81 (10h39m) was proposed to be slippage between Saturn’s magnetic field and Saturn’s core causing the magnetic field to be slowing down (and presumably speeding up) over time. The explanation for the difference between Cassini’s radio measurements of magnetic field rotation (10h45m) and Cassini’s Grand Finale measurements of core rotation (10h33m) is that Saturn likely has pretty extreme differential rotation: the core rotates once every 10 hours and 33 minutes, and the concentric layers of its atmosphere rotate progressively slower. I’m guessing the core is throwing out a steady magnetic field but there is enough magnetically charged material in the slower-rotating layers to drag on that magnetic field. Likely that there’s some grand cycle going on: as the magnetic field rotation is slowed by charged atmosphere drag, the core begins to exert more force on the atmosphere through magnetism in addition to friction, speeding the atmosphere’s rotation back up. Because of the massive amounts of material involved, there is a massive amount of inertia, and the system overshoots equilibrium. It’s getting very speculative and well outside my layman’s expertise but I think this would predict there are periods during the cycle where the atmosphere of Saturn actually rotates faster than the core does! I think it’s also possible that the cycle goes from “significantly slower than core” to “slightly slower than core” and back? At this point I am well into fantastical sci-fi scenarios but I can also imagine the differential rotation being too strongly determined by friction and other non-magnetic forces, so all of this charged drag is concentrating certain types of material (highly affected by the magnetic field, relatively free to move) into a thin shell some distance from the core, and that shell expands and contracts in diameter as it tries to find the specific height in the atmosphere that is currently rotating at the same speed as the magnetic field is. So like a marble inside a balloon, and the balloon is expanding and contracting, except there’s a bunch of gas inside and outside the balloon obscuring all of this from our sight. (Would love astrophysicists to chime in)
- 23B1 4y agoWhat a lovely comment! Is there a term that describes the sort of oscillation you're talking about, by the way? Wherein object A is embedded 'within' object B?
- fwlr 4y agoI don’t know of a good term, no. “Differential rotation” is the broader concept but almost all of the information there is about bodies of fluids, with not much treatment of discrete objects. Even a single discrete object inside a body of fluid is hard to find information on; “object A inside shell B, all in a fluid C” is probably asking too much. Hopefully someone does, though! This is probably one of those cases where if you know the right term you can access a whole hidden field of literature on the topic.
- akiselev 4y agoWould fluid-structure interaction [1] with encapsulated systems fit the bill? It’s a subset of continuum mechanics which is probably the best field to model the layers of atmosphere as a mix of solid and fluid continuums and oscillatory systems are a defining feature of the field: > Fluid–structure interaction (FSI) is the interaction of some movable or deformable structure with an internal or surrounding fluid flow. Fluid–structure interactions can be stable or oscillatory. In oscillatory interactions, the strain induced in the solid structure causes it to move such that the source of strain is reduced, and the structure returns to its former state only for the process to repeat. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fluid–structure_interaction https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fluid–structure_interaction
- tough 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Differential_rotation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Differential_rotation
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dtgriscom 4y ago
- lostgame 4y agoThere was, in the 2000's, a SEGA Saturn emulator called 'Cassini'. I now know why, lol.
- leidenfrost 4y agoSometimes I wish we could see photos of the interior of a gas giant, even if those photos end up being a gray screen because of all the clouds
- vba616 4y agoThere are conditions where humans just cannot perceive what is going on. There's a story from (I just looked it up) 1944, before it was widely known the gas giants have no surfaces, about humans who modify themselves to explore Jupiter. Before the characters undergo the transformation, they see Jupiter as a terrifying wasteland of never-ending storms - and after, nobody comes back. If I remember correctly, the story is about a man and his dog who go through the process and then, when it is complete, Jupiter appears as a paradise and they realize that the reason people don't come back is because it's a better life once they become Jovians. “Four men, two by two, had gone into the howling maelstrom that was Jupiter and had not returned. They had walked into the keening gale – or rather, they had loped, bellies low against the ground, wet sides gleaming in the rain. For they did not go in the shape of men.” The end is: "'They would turn me back into a dog,' said Towser. 'And me,' said Fowler, 'back into a man.'" I hadn't realized how much that story affected me, because my reaction to colonizing Mars, for years, really, has been that it's pointless to try until it's practical to become Martians. Otherwise you might as well live in a cave anywhere. But I didn't link it consciously.
- WalterBright 4y agoI've thought for a long time that the only way to colonize the solar system would be to genetically adapt humans to the conditions. They'd still need life support, but not as much. For example, shifting the band of tolerance for gravity, temperature, gas pressure, etc.
- GolfPopper 4y agoI've had sort of the opposite thought (not that there's anything resembling a singular "right answer" on topics like this): we shouldn't try to colonize Mars until after we've terraformed it. Scientific outposts would be fine, but much like Antarctica, no one ought to be in a position where they have to live in caves or cans their entire life.
- EGreg 4y agoWhat happened to Cassini, maan?
- throwaway_ab 4y agoI kind of like the idea that these gas giants have more rocky planet mass in their cores than all the rocky planets in the solar system combined. Hard to tell, this paper describes the core as mixed with the gases and in fact it may extend out to 1/2 the planet's radius in a fuzzy sort of way. So these cores are not like massive Earths sitting inside with clearly defined boundaries but rather various gradients with fuzzy boundaries as they mix into the rest of the plant's atmosphere. I wonder if Jupiter's core has a similar structure.
- sph 4y agoHow can the core be mixed with the gases? I suppose it means the boundary is a massive and eternal dust storm. That's the only way I imagine solids and gases to "mix".
- wffurr 4y agoAt the pressures in Saturn’s core, the hydrogen and helium aren’t gases anymore, but liquids. Imagine a rock and liquid hydrogen slurry.
- Sharlin 4y agoAt the pressures and temperatures we’re not talking about either gases or liquids but a supercritical fluid and even more exotic phases, including liquid metallic hydrogen which is thought to be an excellent solvent.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 4y agoIt's rocky in the sense that it has elements heavier than hydrogen and helium, but not in the sense that it's solid. Temperature within the cores reaches 40k Celsius, so everything is molten.
- Sharlin 4y agoYes, based on Juno’s observations it has become more likely that Jupiter’s core is also "fuzzy", having been slowly dissolving into the surrounding metallic hydrogen sea since the planet’s formation and may even have completely dissolved and mixed by now.
- throwaway_ab 4y agoAt these rotation speeds (10h33m/45m) how much of the planets diameter is due to rotation forces pushing the matter outwards. I guess the solution would require a comparison to a hypothetical Saturn that has no rotation. If that's even possible.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> the solution would require a comparison to a hypothetical Saturn that has no rotation. If that's even possible. Possible. But not probable. For one, you’d need a complete cancellation of angular momentum during formation, which is unlikely. Also, without a dynamo, even at that distance from the sun, the lighter gases would wash away.
- kijin 4y agoSaturn's equatorial radius is 60,268km, and its polar radius is 54,364km -- nearly 10% smaller. The equatorial radius would have been smaller without the rapid rotation, and the polar radius larger, so at least we have lower and upper limits as to the size of a non-rotating Saturn. Getting a more accurate estimate would require calculating the effect of gravity vs. centrifugal force on the density of the various gaseous layers. As long as you limit the calculation to the current state of Saturn (as if it had just stopped) and not try to extrapolate over its entire age of 4.6B years, the result is unlikely to be more than a couple of percentage points different from the current average radius.
- 360macky 4y agoThe Grand Finale simulation of Cassini falling into Saturn is one of the most beautiful videos I've seen on the internet: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=68vxYRAony8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=68vxYRAony8
- snthpy 4y agoThank you. That was majestic!
- mstade 4y agoWow – stunning! Thank you!
- Sharlin 4y agoDirected by Erik Wernquist, also known as the creator of the stunningly beautiful and poignant CGI short film "Wanderers": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YH3c1QZzRK4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YH3c1QZzRK4
- albert_e 4y agoVery soon it would be possible to create such content with much lesser talent I suppose? - Moving Carl Sagan's Voice - deepfake audio synthesis - Stunning visuals - Generative AI trained on NASA archives and sci-fi movie footage - Awe-Inspiring Narrative - GPT trained on Sagan, Ray Bradbury, etc Once we are there -- I wonder what becomes the new frontier for creative output that makes us say "AI cannot do THIS -- it takes a human"
- MichaelZuo 4y agoIf someone could get high quality stuff from all these tools, combine it well, and compose the whole video to a similar quality, I would say they would be equally talented. Even if they spent a fraction of the time on it.
- Sharlin 4y agoIt's not unlikely that soon after that happens, the human era as we understand will end. In one way or another.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- OldGuyInTheClub 4y agoAs a one-time chemist, I look at the magnetic fields and abundant hydrogen and wonder if there's any way to do magnetic resonance measurements at the planetary scale to look at the innards of a Saturn or a Jupiter. Yes, I know there are a million reasons that it won't work but still...
- roomey 4y agoSo there isn't a rocky core spinning really fast, which makes sense as friction would have surely spent that as heat? Instead they speak about a mixed core extending to half the radius. Can anyone explain what differential rotation means, with reference to the harmonics listed in the paper? Thank you!
- mikub 4y agoIf you want to learn more about the Cassini mission and also learn SQL, there is the fantastic book called "A curious Moon". Which teaches SQL with the original Cassini/Huygens data from the Enceladus flyby.