4 ms·
>contain "knowledge" or "intelligence" or "meaning" when in reality, it's just a very fancy Markov chain These are not mutually exclusive. If you have a Markov
by charcircuit 4y ago
>contain "knowledge" or "intelligence" or "meaning" when in reality, it's just a very fancy Markov chain
These are not mutually exclusive. If you have a Markov chain that 100% of the time outputs "A cat is an animal", then it has knowledge that a cat is an animal.
- version_five 4y ago$ yes "a cat is an animal" Does `yes` also have "knowledge"?
- zacgarby 4y agono, but `$ yes "a cat is an animal"` does (if you know how to interpret it)
- maxbond 4y agoIf it requires interpretation, than it is the "yes+human" system that has the knowledge. What really happened here is that a human wrote down, "a cat is an animal," and then another human read it, understood it, and believed it. And so the knowledge moved from one human to another. `yes` was only a conduit for that information to travel through.
- charcircuit 4y ago>was only a conduit If something was a conduit for knowledge wouldn't it make sense that it would have at some point contained the knowledge? The knowledge is stored into it by one human and extracted by another human.
- maxbond 4y agoAbsolutely you can store knowledge in text. You can store quite a bit of knowledge in a book for instance, but the book doesn't have any beliefs and doesn't know anything. Whether a sufficiently complex Markov chain or ANN can have beliefs, I don't know but I'm skeptical that these ANNs do in particular. It's ability to produce text containing true statements isn't sufficient evidence to conclude that it has beliefs, and it's easy to find cases where it contradicts itself (eg, if you play around with the wording you can find a prompt where it tells you that solving the trolley problem is a matter of harming the fewest people but proposes a solution that harms the most people). I take that as an indication it's primarily regurgitating text and rearranging the prompt rather than applying knowledge (which, to be clear, is useful for a number of tasks).
- tifik 4y agoI think you are operating with a different definition of "knowledge" that the parent does.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoThe heart of the issue is always the same: is a perfect simulation actually the same thing as what it simulates. I would argue that yes especially when the definition of knowledge or intelligence is already so fuzzy but some people will probably always disagree.
- archgoon 4y ago[dead]
- stametseater 4y agoKnowledge is awareness of information. "Awareness" is a quagmire because a lot of people believe that 'true' awareness requires possessing a sort of soul which machines can't possess. I think the important part is information, the matter of 'awareness' can simply be ignored as a philosophical/religious disagreement which will never be resolved. What's important is: Does the system contain information? Can it reliably convey that information? In which ways can it manipulate that information?
- maxbond 4y ago"Awareness of information" describes belief. Knowledge is justified, true belief (you can believe things you don't actually know/don't have justification for, and you can be made aware of information you don't believe). If you're dismissive of philosophy and then ask epistemological questions, you'll miss out on a lot of good pondering people have done on the subject, and end up reinventing some of it without encountering the criticism of those ideas.
- stametseater 4y ago1. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/knowledge https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/knowledge 2. "Belief" isn't any less of a quagmire than "awareness." Materialists and dualists will never agree on whether machines can have 'belief' or 'awareness', so discussions between the two will always be fruitless.
- dsr_ 4y agoIt does not. It has a language output that you find pleasing.