8 ms·
How did the chess pieces get their names?
- mbroncano 4y agoAt least for Spanish, a majority of the maps are utterly wrong.
- Luc 4y agoI don't see how 4 (or more) out of 6 would be wrong. Are you from Spain? Perhaps there's variations in the Spanish speaking world? https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piezas_de_ajedrez https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piezas_de_ajedrez
- joseda-hg 4y agoThe only ones that I might consider off, but not straight up wrong are: Elephant -> Alfil * (The words originates from arabic for elephant, but it means specifically this piece of chess) Lady -> Reina/Dama * (You could use either, but the article lists them separately and doesn't recognize Queen, which is the more common of the two)
- School-Cotton 4y agoSimilarly, “rook” only means the chess piece in English, but England is labeled as having it mean chariot. So the “alfil” example is consistent.
- Ichthypresbyter 4y agoIt's also a species of bird (Corvus frugilegus) but the two senses are unrelated.
- sltkr 4y ago> Lady -> Reina/Dama * (You could use either, but the article lists them separately and doesn't recognize Queen, which is the more common of the two) I think the reason is that the article follows the FIDE rules rather than colloquial use. I was about the comment something similar about Dutch, where the word for Queen (“Koningin”) is also more common than the official FIDE-term Lady (“Dame”). I suspect the reason for this choice is that the FIDE also establishes an official chess notation where each piece has a single letter abbreviation. In Dutch this presents the problem that “Koning” (King) is a prefix of “Koningin” (Queen), so it makes sense to abbreviate king with K, but it's not clear what letter to assign to the Queen. It makes sense then to switch to “Dame” and use the letter D for this piece. I think the same thing applies to Romance languages where the words for King and Queen derive from the Latin words Rex and Regina (Roi and Reine in French, Rey and Reina in Spanish, etc.), all of which start with the letter 'R'. Then switching to Lady (dame/dama) for the Queen makes sense just to create a unique letter.
- sunjester 4y agoWhile attempting to read the article I was constantly battered by advertising. I could not complete the article.
- garciansmith 4y agoAs usual, uBlock Origin with Firefox solves these issues. Although even with uBlock turned off Firefox's built-in tracking protection kills all ads except or one (for a book published by the website).
- Larrikin 4y agoI'm guessing the only people on Hacker News who still see ads are the people in the ad industry and iOS users that hate Safari and are prevented from getting proper ad blocking in other browsers.
- Idiot_in_Vain 4y agoHow do you get an ad blocker in Safari on iOS?
- carl_dr 4y agoBy searching the App Store for “ad blocker for safari”. There are loads.
- School-Cotton 4y agoWhy would you think so? I’m in none of those categories and still see ads.
- sundarurfriend 4y agoBy choice? Or are you in some other kind of constrained environment?
- teo_zero 4y agoI don't have any ad-blocker installed and only see 2 ads at the very beginning of the article. Not ideal but far from constantly battering. Using Chrome on Android.
- wodenokoto 4y ago> In the Chinese example, Mandarin and Cantonese speakers can read and understand the same text, even though they use different words for the same concepts. Written mandarin is different from written Cantonese and the differences are more than simplified vs traditional characters
- z2 4y agoYeah, not a good example. Written vernacular mandarin started in the Ming dynasty and more or less was forcefully promoted in the Qing and later Republic of China as _the_ way to write Chinese, meaning other dialects lost out on developing a common written vernacular form. In this example most Cantonese speakers learned mandarin grammar and vocabulary, at least to read and write it. But did written Chinese not exist before then? Before, the literate people in East Asia used Classical Chinese, which was essentially a similar forced standardization from the dominant vernacular 2000 years ago, very similar to Europe's use of Latin. Issac Newton could read and write Latin because he learned it, not because English naturally gets written as Latin!
- School-Cotton 4y agoWritten Cantonese exists, but most Cantonese-speakers write in standard written Chinese (which is what you’re calling “written Mandarin” here), and pronounce the characters in Cantonese, regardless of whether they can speak Mandarin.
- SeanLuke 4y ago100% correct. Cantonese speakers write in Chinese just as Mandarin speakers do (though they pronounce the characters differently). Written Cantonese, as it were, is cobbled together from certain Chinese characters and, of all things, a few English letters: perhaps mostly used nowadays to portray Cantonese dialogue in comic books.
- heywhatupboys 4y ago> Written mandarin is different from written Cantonese and the differences are more than simplified vs traditional characters I understand that this is a heartfelt wish of contemporary cultural independence, but it is simply not true for 99 %+ of Cantonese speakers year 2023.
- dubrocks 4y agoAuthor doesn’t know what he’s talking about. The knight is a knight because its L-shaped movement represents a flanking maneuver, which cavalry is good at.
- bee_rider 4y agoMost of them seemed pretty reasonable, but yeah the knight bit was a bit off odd. > From the very beginning of chaturanga, this piece—originally called asva, Sanskrit for “horse”—has firmly maintained its equine association. Of course, this is likely because it is the only piece that is able to jump over the heads of the other pieces. Of course, the common battle tactic of flanking via leaping your horse over the other side’s lines. A very real and widespread thing that occurred in every culture that had chess.
- stewbrew 4y agoBut in many countries, it isn't a knight.
- roesel 4y agoI sure hope the knight is not called "calvary" in that many countries as suggested by the legend in the second map. Unless there is a connection between the knight's movements and crucifixion?
- robopsychology 4y agoHahahaha good spot. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cavalry https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cavalry Vs https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calvary https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calvary
- jagged-chisel 4y agoMy seventh grade teacher pronounced these inversely and the whole class got them “wrong” on a spelling test.
- fakedang 4y agoIn Hindi, Persian and Arabic variations of the game, the bishop piece was referred to as a "camel". I don't know where the author got this concept of "second elephant".
- kgwgk 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alfil https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alfil "It was used in standard chess before being replaced by the bishop in the 15th and 16th centuries. [...] The alfil is a very old piece, appearing in some very early chess variants, such as Tamerlane chess and shatranj. It was originally called an elephant, hastīn or gāja in Sanskrit. [...] When chess spread to China, the piece became the elephant in xiangqi. [...] When chess came to Persia from India, the Sanskrit name was translated to pil, and when chess came to the Muslims from Persia, the move had not changed, and then the name changed into Arabic to fil, the already existing cognate to pil which comes from the Akkadian language and ultimately from the Egyptian language. The name thus became fil and then alfil (prefixing the Arabic definite article, al)."
- fakedang 4y agoFairy chess doesn't count though.
- kgwgk 4y ago"It was used in standard chess before being replaced by the bishop in the 15th and 16th centuries." The bishop is a modern European invention. > In Hindi, Persian and Arabic variations of the game, the bishop piece was... There was no bishop in traditional Hindi, Persian and Arabic variations. There was an elephant though. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bishop_(chess)#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bishop_(chess)#History "The bishop's predecessor in medieval chess, shatranj (originally chaturanga), was the alfil, meaning "elephant", which could leap two squares along any diagonal, and could jump over an intervening piece."
- teo_zero 4y ago
- yakubin 4y agoThere is some in-country variation that's ignored in this article. In Poland, names of pieces will vary based on family you come from (as this game is usually learnt at kindergarten age from your parents/grandparents). For example, in my family we refer to the knight as "koń" (horse) rather than "skoczek" (jumper), and instead of using the more Polish-sounding "goniec" for the bishop we use "laufer" borrowed from German. Also, even though the official (as in: approved by some chess institutions in the country) name for the queen is "hetman", I'd say 90%+ Poles say "królowa" (literally queen).
- wirrbel 4y agoGerman here, next to Springer (jumper) for the bishop in my family “Ross” or “rössl” was used.
- stewbrew 4y agoThat would be a horse, which is seemingly used in some other countries.
- INTPenis 4y agoSpringare is an old word for horse in Swedish. In medieval parlance they would say "bring me my springare" instead of horse.
- benjaminsuch 4y agoSpringer is used for the knight, Läufer is used for the Bishop.
- wirrbel 4y agoOops, of course that is what I meant
- Zickzack 4y ago>[] I'd say 90%+ Poles say "królowa" (literally queen). I thought "królowa" is reserved for Mary, Queen of Poles.
- seanhunter 4y agoThe story I heard about the Queen was that she started off being able to move a single square in each direction[1], but the upgrade to let her move the full diagonals, ranks and files was done as a tribute to Queen Isabella of Spain. Here’s a source for this although it’s not where I heard it https://medium.com/exploring-history/did-spains-queen-isabella-change-the-game-of-chess-bf3af6ce5059 https://medium.com/exploring-history/did-spains-queen-isabel... [1] Including maybe jumping like a knight but I may have imagined it
- GolfPopper 4y agoNo discussion of chess piece names would be complete without mentioning Uel Aramcheck's Forbidden Chess Pieces: The Prophet, who is aware of the hands which move the pieces. The Crows, placed on the board after the final turn. And many more: https://twitter.com/thepatanoiac/status/439992435205083136?lang=en https://twitter.com/thepatanoiac/status/439992435205083136?l...
- paulddraper 4y agoHa ha. On an only slightly more series note, "fairy chess" has a number of alternative chess pieces: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fairy_chess https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fairy_chess Amazon = queen + knight Chancellor = rook + knight Crowned Rook = rook + king Camel = knight that moves 1,3 Grasshopper = queen, but must jump over a piece and lands immediately past it Nightrider = knight, but moves unlimited in the same direction and many, many more
- Freedom2 4y agoHa ha. This is a great link to wiki - I thoroughly enjoyed reading it. Thank you!
- GreenWatermelon 4y ago> Chancellor = rook + knight I believe this piece goes by the name "Knook" in some online circles.
- crazygringo 4y agoOh man. I have never wanted accompanying illustrations for anything more.
- mcv 4y agoThat tweet is unfortunately invisible to me.
- tangus 4y agoI suspect every time the article says "why's that so? nobody knows!", somebody actually knows and they would have found out if they had researched a little...
- meese712 4y agoWhat is a knight? Did they mean horsey?
- Idiot_in_Vain 4y agoYou must be from England :)
- SeanLuke 4y agoStrange he mentions Chinese but not Chinese Chess (Elephant Chess). In Chinese Chess, more or less all the original names have been retained, whereas they have changed radically in Western chess as discussed. Chinese chess pieces (and their rough positional but not power equivalents in western chess) are: the General (king), the Advisor (queen), the Elephant (bishop), the Horse (knight), the Chariot (rook), the Soldier (pawn), and famously the Cannon. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xiangqi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xiangqi
- forgotmypw17 4y agohttps://archive.is/KXW8u https://archive.is/KXW8u
- at_a_remove 4y agoSo, contrary to the "reasonably educated people play chess" trope, I do not play chess and was quite ignorant of it. During a programming job interview, I was presented with what is apparently a sample problem of moving around a piece. I had to ask how the piece "moved" but didn't get the name. Although the problem was easy, I still remember the interviewer flinching slightly each time I called it "the horsey piece."
- cabirum 4y agoA small nitpick: the rook from the original game was a mythical bird of prey called Rukh/Roc. The chess piece was a bird. It became a tower later. So, the theory is birds were often used as figureheads on boats, that's why it is called a boat in Turkey/Russia. Also the other, outdated name (but still in use) for a rook in Russian is "Тура"/Tura, which is of course a (siege) tower.
- kgwgk 4y ago> the rook from the original game was a mythical bird of prey called Rukh/Roc. The chess piece was a bird. That doesn't seem to be the mainstream explanation: the original piece in the game would be a chariot -thought the connection with the name rukh is not clear- and the alternative bird representation would have been an Arab innovation. ---- OF RUKHS AND ROOKS, CAMELS AND CASTLES https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Remke-Kruk/publication/259791395_Of_Rukhs_and_Rooks_Camels_and_Castles/links/619a6fde07be5f31b7a6ccd1/Of-Rukhs-and-Rooks-Camels-and-Castles.pdf https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Remke-Kruk/publication/...
- paulddraper 4y agoHuh. Of course, a rook is a species of bird.
- riffraff 4y agoBut an unrelated one, the roc of eastern mythology was a giant bird of prey told to be able to carry away elephants. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roc_(mythology) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roc_(mythology) I can't be sure the rooks in your area don't do that, but I guess they don't.
- paulddraper 4y agoI'm not sure either
- suzzer99 4y agoFWIW I've found Atlas Obscura to be flat out wrong on some stuff.
- throwaway8338 4y agoIn Norwegian the knight is called "springer", as mentioned in the article, but many call it "hest" ("horse") too. They are both valid names. The translation of "springer" is a bit imprecise. Instead of simply "jumper", it describes a "human or animal that can jump". A horse fits that description well "Springer" is actually sometimes used to describe a knight's horse instead of the most common word. So "springer" has connections to both horse and knight.
- smcin 4y agoCan you cite some example articles? It's a for-profit Series-B startup [0] in an ever-worsening digital publishing market [1] and article sourcing is paid writers not peer-reviewed crowdsourced, so I expect parts might be worse than Wikipedia, and certainly have very selective coverage. But at first glance I didn't see any glaring errors. Also I expect they won't have an openly exposed peer-review editing process, so if an article turns out to be bad they might delete or hide it (but I can't find any such). [0]: https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/atlas-obscura https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/atlas-obscura [1]: 1/2023 "Atlas Obscura wants to be profitable before raising funds in a tricky media market" https://digiday.com/media/atlas-obscura-wants-to-be-profitable-before-raising-funds-in-a-tricky-media-market/ https://digiday.com/media/atlas-obscura-wants-to-be-profitab...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- suzzer99 4y agohttps://www.atlasobscura.com/places/tikal-howler-monkeys https://www.atlasobscura.com/places/tikal-howler-monkeys > According to the sacred book of creation myths, the Popol Vuh, primates were a life form that had arisen during one of the many earlier experimental periods of creation by the gods. > According to the myth, the gods were ultimately disappointed with the result, which they found to be too frivolous and rebellious and thus strove to perfect and shape the form of some of the monkeys. Maybe "flat out wrong" was too harsh. But I don't think this is exactly right. The earlier attempt were men made out of wood, who almost all drowned in a great flood. The few survivors turned into monkeys. The second attempt at man was made out of maize, and those survived to become humans. But I don't think there's anything about the gods being displeased because the first creation were monkeys. Monkeys from what I understand were more of a byproduct.
- nojonestownpls 4y ago> the piece not only acquired a new, female identity but also greater powers. There's w0ke media for you. Changing existing characters into "strong female leads", making them OP for no reason... Unacceptable! (/s)
- paulddraper 4y agoSort of. The piece is the second ranked member of the court. In the East, that's the vizir. In the West, that's the queen. The game reflected the culture that surrounded it. (E.g. elephant -> bishop)
- tintedfireglass 4y agoIn the Indian version it's called raja(king) mantri/senapati(queen) camel(bishop) elephant(rook) horse(knight) soldier (pawn)
- Rant423 4y agoWhile is true that the Queen is technically called Donna (=Woman, Lady) in italian, most of people call the piece Regina (=Queen)
- pagade 4y ago> While it may seem logical that the king has a queen by his side, that’s not how things started out. In the Indian original, this piece was the king’s “counselor” (mantri in Sanskrit). The Arabs used wazir (“vizier,” i.e., the ruler’s minister/secretary), which was Latinized to farzia, which became the French vierge (“virgin”). Just the other day I was wondering what a stupid name for the Queen's piece. Not at all logical. It's battlefield and not wedding/ceremony for queen to be by-his-side. Vazir is popular piece name in India as well.
- xchip 4y agoHas this been written by an AI? All what it says about Spanish names is wrong.