3 ms·
The whole field of virology seems totally messed up not just this one organization. These accusations are hardly a surprise given the bizarre behavior and cultu
by revelio 4y ago
The whole field of virology seems totally messed up not just this one organization. These accusations are hardly a surprise given the bizarre behavior and culture of deception that seems to pervade the field. So many virologists were willing to sign that notorious Daszak open letter that was blatantly pseudo-scientific and the result of a genuine conspiracy. Where were the objectors?
The article has quotes like this:
many flu scientists hesitated to share newly sequenced influenza genomes, concerned that rivals would skim the most interesting data and publish a paper first
and
Indonesia stopped sharing H5N1 samples with the world in 2007 over concerns that foreign scientists were describing a virus from Indonesia without proper credit
The whole point of giving these people government funding is because they claim it'll let them focus exclusively on noble humanitarian goals, yet here they are acting like tabloid journalists.
and
GISAID has many stalwart supporters. “I’ve known Peter for a number of years, and his push for ‘equitable sharing’ has helped the database, scientists, and the health of humans and animals around the world,” says virologist Ron Fouchier of Erasmus Medical Center, who co-chairs GISAID’s Scientific Advisory Council
Equitable sharing seems to be about what you'd expect [1],
Should data sharing in epidemics and pandemics primarily advance utility, or should it advance equity as well?
Can anything they say be trusted? How many screwed up public health institutions are out there exactly? Why do we fund these people??
[1] https://bmcmedethics.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12910-021-00701-8 https://bmcmedethics.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s129...
- RobotToaster 4y agoThe whole field of medical research seems pretty messed up, given the perverse incentives the grant system and privatised pharmaceutical industry create.