3 ms·
I have a rock that keeps away tigers in my town. No one in the town I’ve lived in work my rock has ever been attacked by tigers. Would you like to buy my magica
by vlovich123 4y ago
I have a rock that keeps away tigers in my town. No one in the town I’ve lived in work my rock has ever been attacked by tigers. Would you like to buy my magical rock?
Seriously, plenty of other countries have avoided the opioid/fentanyl problem without the death penalty. Doesn’t that imply there’s something different? Perhaps extreme lobbying by opioid manufacturers for doctors to overprescribe them and turning the other way to pill mills? Given the opioid epidemic was driven by legal opioids and the black market grew to supply people who could no longer afford the legal supply, I think that suggests Singapore’s death penalty policy has nothing to do here.
Moreover, I suspect like all places, Singaporians don’t have that much difficulty accessing illicit drugs. Do you think this 1kg represents the totality of the illicit drug trade in Singapore? Heck. If anything the death penalty should be the cause of record profits for black market drug distributors - where there’s more risk you can charge more money because there’s less competition willing to take that risk. That increases prices to a point but it’s not going to price it out of complete reach (otherwise you have no customers).
- blueyoda 4y ago> "I have a rock that keeps away tigers in my town. No one in the town I’ve lived in work my rock has ever been attacked by tigers. Would you like to buy my magical rock?" I'm not sure if the "correlation != causation" argument works here. They have serious laws to prevent drug smuggling, and all the data shows that it is working. Logic suggests deterrent against serious crime => less serious crime > "Moreover, I suspect like all places, Singaporians don’t have that much difficulty accessing illicit drugs." "I suspect" is not a valid source. "Singapore has one of the lowest rates of drug abuse in the world: 30 opiates abusers per 100,000 people" (source: The Washington Post) Perhaps the law serving as a deterrent against heinous crimes works?
- shkkmo 4y ago> Perhaps the law serving as a deterrent against heinous crimes works? That's not what evidence about the death penalty shows.
- blueyoda 4y agoSo how did Singapore go from a staggering rate of opium addiction to one of the lowest in the world? Would they have gotten here with laws lenient on substance abuse? I'm curious about the evidence you speak of.
- jones6ofMont 4y ago[dead]
- vlovich123 4y agoGiven that Singapore ranks very low on human rights and press freedom, where is this data being sourced and how do we know it’s accurate? If I kill anyone with a moderate amount of drugs and jail and charge huge fines to those with a small amount, and I curtail press freedoms heavily, how do we know that they’ve actually tackled the drug problem instead of pushing it into the shadows? Also, for what it’s worth Singapore itself reported an increase in drug smuggling even as hangings increased [1]. So maybe there isn’t a correlation there. It all seems like wishful thinking to justify inhumane policies. As another poster pointed out, it’s extremely suspicious that the penalized under drug policies seems to have a racial used tinge to it. Kind of how in America black people outnumber white people significantly for drug crimes even though by all metrics it seems like drug use rates are quite similar. Did America’s strict drug laws create a better society than countries that tried more empathetic approaches with legalization and trying to help drug addicts get back on their feet? I think there’s a reason America’s laws are liberalizing with respect to drugs. There’s an understanding that draconian laws harm more than they help (if they even help at all). [1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-singapore-law-drugs-idUSKCN1UQ197 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-singapore-law-drugs-idUSK...
- blueyoda 4y ago> "Given that Singapore ranks very low on human rights and press freedom" And yet Singapore is in the top 5 nations for highest GDP per capita (nominal). They also have one of the lowest rates of drug addiction. Surely they are doing something right. Which one would most people rather have - a prosperous life, or freedom to smoke weed? I choose the former. > "anyone with a moderate amount of drugs" But why do they have drugs to begin with? Nobody forced them to smoke weed. How does society benefit from the legalization of recreational drugs, which have negative effects on health? I highly recommend reading the history of Singapore's drug addiction crisis. > "As another poster pointed out, it’s extremely suspicious that the penalized under drug policies seems to have a racial used tinge to it." A cause for concern indeed. This should be investigated. > "Did America’s strict drug laws create a better society than countries that tried more empathetic approaches with legalization and trying to help drug addicts get back on their feet?" Unlike Singapore, America has for-profit prisons, so it's unlikely helping addicts get back on their feet is even a priority for this nation to begin with.
- lazylizard 4y agoand the risks and difficulties and higher prices result in the vast majority of the population not dabbling in drugs. thats good enough of an outcome.
- Gud 4y ago1) the vast majority are not dabbling with drugs in liberal countries where they are widely available(much of Europe) 2) Why is it so important to you that I don’t smoke pot? Why do you feel the need to terrorize me with the police