3 ms·
> Before too long, we will not delegate decisions to AI systems because they perform better. Rather, we will delegate decisions to AI systems because they c
by Animats 4y ago
> Before too long, we will not delegate decisions to AI systems because they perform better. Rather, we will delegate decisions to AI systems because they can get away with everything that we can’t.
Here's Frontier Airlines announcing proudly to investors that they will do exactly that.[1] See page 44.
Today: Call center. Avenue for customer negotiation.
Tomorrow: Chatbot efficiently answers questions, reduces contacts and removes negotiation.
[1] https://ir.flyfrontier.com/static-files/c7e0a34d-3659-49cc-8069-e85aff126b87 https://ir.flyfrontier.com/static-files/c7e0a34d-3659-49cc-8...
- nanidin 4y agoThis is the infuriating part of dealing with Amazon customer service these days. Anything that doesn’t fit into the box of what the chatbot will do is met with “I understand your frustration, …” and it’s like, no, there is no understanding here! Just like call center trees have escapes to real service by pressing 0 ad nauseum or swearing loudly, these AI service agents will have ways to get to real people and they’ll be documented in the usual places.
- Joeri 4y agoHow many times have you read about someone locked out of their <insert major tech company> account and having no recourse except taking it to HN and hoping a human on the inside reaches out? Imagine if that was every corporation, and some of them had zero humans on the inside.
- nanidin 4y agoIt is not a good future, and at least in Amazon’s case jeff@amazon.com works as an escalation route. My gmail account with the same username got banned in 2007ish in the middle of college, I definitely feel the pain of no recourse. I lost everything - calendars, todo lists, email and had no way to get the underlying data or do anything about it. My hope is that at the end of the day a corporation is made of people (legally, this is why they have 1st amendment rights in the USA) and this will prevent the scenario you imagine because the money of those people will be at risk.
- Lio 4y agoWhilst it's interesting to imagine every company being run by the most aggressively rent seeking MBA-like AI, I don't think that will ever be the entire market. I would guess it all comes down to risk. The future won't be uniform, it'll be poorly defused, just like then present. People will make a value judgement on the types of corporations they want to deal with. The sort of company that no has employees will by necessity have to be very cheap compared to those that provide interactive human service. Dealing with AI firms will be like dealing with an anonymous Chinese eBay seller. You'll effectively have no legal recourse as such and they won't discuss things but complaining might get you a replacement item or a full refund. If it doesn't the product will have to be cheap enough to write off as a bad buy. Let's hope cheap AI powered corps don't suck all the profit out of the market and we loose all firms capable of providing real services. Or we end up paying for human service that's been quietly outsourced to AI much like we do for many big name manufactured goods.
- nanidin 4y agoThe Chinese eBay seller brought to mind the concept of the Chinese Room[0] and how it is a reflection of current LLM’s. Perhaps also influenced by a recent read of Blindsight. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room
- TheOtherHobbes 4y agoWhy would "the markets" provide that option? AI corporations will be phenomenally successful predatory value-extractions machines. Shareholders will vastly prefer them over more humane corporate structures. This already happens. It's why PayPal, YouTube, Amazon, and the rest can shut down small-fry business accounts with no come-back. They're monopolies and they don't care. Because they don't need to. The next stage will be shareholders using AI to make their investment choices. This will - automatically, with no recourse - drive money towards AI corporations while starving human-run businesses of investment. Essentially AI is just an amplifier of existing economic and political trends - a programmable automated economic predator. Because many of those trends are dysfunctional and insane, we're going to have a lot to deal with.
- 4y ago