9 ms·
Adobe confirms: no Flash for Chrome on Android
- ryandvm 15y agoThank God.
- hahaiamatwork 15y agoWhy? Can you present a coherent argument against enabling flash that isn't just "I don't want to use it so nobody else should be allowed to"?
- estel 15y agoIsn't there an extent to which forced deprecation of software like Flash might hasten the uptake of newer technologies like HTML5? Fortunately iOS already did most of this on its own. But reduced support can always encourage more websites to move to HTML5.
- SquareWheel 15y agoAs much as I'd like to see HTML5 pushed for interactive content, it's not there yet. I can tell whenever Youtube gives me the HTML player because everything breaks. Apple's webplayer is even worse. I think the only good experience I've had with an HTML5 video player is on The Verge, and half the comments complain about it so it probably just works well on Chrome. I think Flash still has a place in the current web, while we work on getting HTML up to snuff.
- recursive 15y agoFunny you should mention it. While we're talking anecdotes, youtube's flash player is more likely to crash my browser than the html one.
- huggyface 15y agoFortunately iOS already did most of this on its own. By pushing everyone to apps? iOS is no shepherd in the movement to standardized, cross-platform solutions. It is probably the greatest setback the open web has faced in over a decade.
- ugh 15y agoKind of hard to believe, given that iOS was and still is the only mobile OS with a browser that does not suck. Even Android has only been catching up. iOS and Android have been an unambiguous blessing for the open web on mobile devices. I don't even understand what you want Apple to do. Not allow third party developers to make native apps for iOS? Apple did that and nobody liked it. I can't imagine that you think this is a realistic solution.
- huggyface 15y agoKind of hard to believe, given that iOS was and still is the only mobile OS with a browser that does not suck. Yeah, I see John Gruber likes to say that. It is, so to speak, horse shit. I apologize for the language but it's all that satisfactorily delivers my opinion on that. Have you ever actually used the Android browser?
- ugh 15y agoYes, and it sucked. I have been quite happy with the browser that comes with ICS, so I would say there's parity now. But nice job ignoring the actual point I was making.
- huggyface 15y agoThe point you were making was that the iOS browser is so superior to its competitors that it demonstrated Apple's commitment to the web. Only the Android browser doesn't actually suck. I've never, ever heard someone actually describe why it sucks, they just repeat that going meme and smile and nod at each other. Yet despite all of its CSS chrome, many mobile dev projects abandon the effort and switch to an app after facing the less sexy, but deadly deficiencies in the iOS browser. People are sure the iOS browser is great because they never actually use it. Instead they use apps.
- hahaiamatwork 15y agoI agree, but as another poster said, the technology simply isn't there. I haven't tested an iPhone 4S yet, but I did develop some javascript canvas based animations for some time, and the performance was extremely poor. The old benchmark I used was http://themaninblue.com/writing/perspective/2010/03/22/ http://themaninblue.com/writing/perspective/2010/03/22/ I believe, and I have yet to see HTML outperform flash on it.
- estel 15y agoI agree too (though I can't remember the last time I myself had to use Flash on my phone); but it doesn't feel like an entirely unreasonable argument for not supporting Flash.
- cmf028 15y agoHardware acceleration for Canvas and SVG makes a huge difference in this case. Firefox 4+ (Windows Vista/7), IE9+ (Windows Vista/7), Chrome(I forget which version)+ (All Windows, Mac Soon), and Safari 5+ (OSX) all support hardware acceleration of Canvas. Opera development builds support hardware acceleration too. Chrome Beta on Android supports hardware acceleration of Canvas. iPhone 4S also supports hardware acceleration of Canvas. Hardware accelerated Canvas completely destroys Flash on the Desktop. A lot has changed in `~2 years Not to mention that modern JS engines outperform even statically typed AS3 code. Of course, if you don't have a supported graphics card for your computer, you won't get hardware acceleration. However, I imagine this won't be a problem on Mobile once Android 4.0 eclipses other versions of Android since Hardware acceleration is a standard Android 4.0 feature.
- mberning 15y agoCoherent argument? Sucks battery Poor usability on touch interfaces Memory hog Buggy, leads to browser crashes
- Turing_Machine 15y agoLet's not forget the security hole of the week.
- talmand 15y agoThen I guess we should stop using a good chunk of internet capable software, such as browsers.
- mberning 15y agoWrong. We should limit the number of attack vectors as much as possible. Flash has a horrific security track record. Firefox and Chrome are pretty solid.
- talmand 15y agoFunny, almost all of my software that connects to the internet gets security updates. Granted the browsers may be more solid on security than Flash is, but still, reducing attack vectors does include security updates.
- ThomPete 15y agoPoor usability? What does that even mean in this context? Flash allow you to create any kind of interface and experience you want.
- Zirro 15y ago"Flash allow you to create any kind of interface and experience you want." Exactly, and that's the problem. It means that it behaves the way the author wants it to, ignoring the users preferences. That is poor usability. I have lots of small annoyances with Flash, take for example the inability to auto-scroll across it (at least in Firefox on OS X). This would not be the case with normal content.
- narkee 15y agoReplace Flash with IE6 and I think you'll get a clearer understanding of where people are coming from.
- hahaiamatwork 15y agoMy argument isn't 'Flash is great'. It's 'Flash works and I see no need to break a bunch of websites when the replacements are not yet up to the task'
- nachteilig 15y agoTo be honest, after I had used iPhone for a while I preferred the flash-less web so much that I also disabled the plugin on my computer. I haven't really missed it at all, and the web experience has been much better for me.
- nyellin 15y agoFlash is a proprietary standard with one major implementation, HTML 5 is an open standard supported by multiple vendors. Accessibility (i.e. for the blind) used to be an issue, but Wikipedia claims that has mostly been fixed: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_HTML5_and_Flash#Accessibility_issues_and_search_engines http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_HTML5_and_Flash#A...
- Jimmie 15y agoFlash may be owned but it is released as open source. The language is completely open, there is an open source compiler and an open source VM. HTML5, as it is, is a pain in the butt because of multiple vendors supporting subsets of it. I still have to fall back to flash to play mp3s in Firefox. HTML5 will be great someday, but it's not today and probably not soon.
- ryandvm 15y agoBecause half the Flash "enabled" pages I load on my Android phone end up crashed, lagging, or completely borking the touch controls. About the only thing Flash ever works for on my phone are simple ads or video players (with unresponsive playback controls). That said, not wanting to use something is certainly a fine reason to not want it installed. For example, I don't want to use closed media formats. I also don't want others to use closed media formats because I believe it to be detrimental to long term archival and sharing.
- ugh 15y agoDidn't Adobe already say that they will no longer develop Flash for mobile devices – so isn't this kind of self-evident?
- ZeroGravitas 15y agotwo nitpicks: one, they're still supporting you developing mobile apps with Flash. two, they seemed to be hinting that their partners (i.e. Google in this case) would be allowed to take over development if they wished to. It seems Google don't want to (can't link directly to the relevant answer but search this page for Flash): http://code.google.com/intl/fr/chrome/mobile/docs/faq.html http://code.google.com/intl/fr/chrome/mobile/docs/faq.html
- ootachi 15y agoGoogle could have implemented it. Firefox Mobile Nightly (which is essentially a completely different browser from the currently-shipping Firefox Mobile), for example, implements the necessary support to run Flash on Ice Cream Sandwich and on Gingerbread and below. It's just a matter of exposing the plugin hooks.
- EnderMB 15y agoI have a Galaxy Nexus, and I know this will be an unpopular opinion, but I find Flash works pretty well on the device. Granted, I only use it for video content on sites like the BBC, but the underlying functionality is fine. I don't think Flash has a future on mobile devices, but HTML5-based solutions aren't up to scratch for general use yet, so I don't think Adobe should throw in the towel just yet.
- huggyface 15y agoSame experience -- Flash works close to perfectly on my Galaxy S II. This isn't a technology move, however, but rather is a revenue move: Adobe makes no money from Flash, but instead makes money from authoring tools. The lack of an iOS target is killing the authoring tools on the Flash side (who would build a new site or delivery mechanism using Flash when you know it cuts out a huge portion of the market?). So Adobe is refocusing on HTML5 tools. Even though Flash is useful today, Google doesn't want to inherit the cost and risk of developing it on mobile so....no more Flash.
- 51Cards 15y agoAgreed as well. I often make use of Flash on both my tablet and my Nexus One. The times I notice it most is when I'm using the new Firefox Mobile and I have to copy the URL and paste it into the stock browser to get to flash content. That tedious process makes me realize I do it a lot more than I expected I would. I am very very disappointed by this decision.
- 15y ago
- mcav 15y agoThis should be old hat at this point. Flash is done on mobile. (Had it ever begun?)
- starwed 15y agoAnytime there was a post about firefox mobile on /r/reddit, folk came out of the woodwork saying they would never even consider using it until it supported flash. (Which, interestingly, it now does.) I have no fucking idea what people find attractive about mobile flash (maybe games?) but it certainly seems to be a thing.
- untog 15y agoI have no fucking idea what people find attractive about mobile flash Being able to watch video?
- Karunamon 15y agoA massive percentage of the internet's video consumption (YouTube and related sites) is already served by HTML5.
- Jimmie 15y agoYou are wrong. Html5 for Youtube is still an opt-in trial, unless you are on a platform without flash. As for related sites, while most I frequent seem to keep their files in .mp4 format rather than .flv the players are all flash based. Probably because it's easier to serve ads.
- justincormack 15y agoYes but mobile is a platform without flash, and is a large amount of youtube views. Not sure if you can opt in to flash youtube on Android.
- pcwalton 15y agoRestaurant sites. For Mobile Firefox our main test case for Flash is dairyqueen.com.
- casca 15y agoHats off to Apple. They managed to take a technology that was entrenched as a standard and kill it simply by refusing to support it on their mobile platform. For years people have been complaining about the lack of IOS flash support, but the true impact has been to hasten the move to HTML5 and to kill a proprietary, bloated, bug-filled technology.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- tjogin 15y agoI honestly don't think Apple set out to kill flash. They just chose to not support Flash, like they also don't support a bunch of other browser plugins. All of them, in fact. Had others not made such a big fuss about it, Apple's mobile devices would simply silently not support Flash. But everybody made such a big stink about it so they had to vocally explain their motivations for not supporting Flash specifically, making Apple some kind of Flash opponent.
- arcdrag 15y agoHas it been hastened considerably? It has been 3 years now since the controversy began...or centuries in internet time.
- pornel 15y agoApple couldn't make it without help of Adobe. For years (even after iPhone shipped) Adobe only had "Flash Lite" to offer, and allowed it to lag many versions behind desktop version (e.g. Opera on Wii had trouble when YouTube started dropping support for Flash 7 and Adobe simply didn't have anything more modern available in "Devices SDK").
- xtc 15y agoI find it disappointing that Adobe has complete control over the Flash/mobile-media market in this regard. Flash is great in all, but leaving up the choice to Adobe seems counter-intuitive, especially when the browser will most likely be widely used.
- j45 15y agoThe flash format is open source now. It happened a few years ago. Anyone can build their own flash player, even for mobile. What folks are commenting on is Adobes not releasing an official player for the mobile. Desktop isn't going anywhere because it plays AIR/Flex apps which also have been open sourced.
- j45 15y agoCan't wait for Adobe's HTML5 authoring tools to come out with their HTML5 acquisitions. Until then, HTML5 is still becoming more performant when building immersive environments in it, which Flash already kind of does in mobile. Guess we'll have a few years of toughing it out until then.
- mvip 15y agoFlash is the new Internet Explorer. I remember a point in time when it was painful to use browsers other than IE, because so many developers took the easy way out and only supported IE (and their managers didn't know/care). Those days are of course over (well, mostly at least). Flash is, or at least used to be, the easy way out. People used it because it was easier than HTML5. Hence, when a company asks for a quote on an interactive site they often went for the Flash-version because it was cheaper (and not fully knowing the drawbacks). Apple forced a change in the market. All of the sudden, these people who ordered the new project in Flash realized that they couldn't view the content on their shiny new toy. You might argue the ability of using Flash as an option. I see the fact that both Apple (and now Google) have actively taken a stance against Flash as something good for the society as a whole. It's a step towards better, and more open standards. This isn't to say that Flash is completely useless. Not too long ago, it wasn't even possible to do interactive things with HTML. At that point, Flash was the only option. Luckily, those days are over.
- nextparadigms 15y ago> You might argue the ability of using Flash as an option. I see the fact that both Apple (and now Google have) actively taken a stance against Flash as something good for the society as a whole. It's a step towards better, and more open standards. If only Apple took the same stance regarding video codecs, too, and embrace WebM. But the truth is they support what is convenient for them at the time. If it also happens to help the society in the long term - great. But it's not their main priority.
- mvip 15y agoYeah, you're right. Apple isn't only killing Flash because it is good for the society. They're doing it because the user experience would suffer. That isn't the case with video codecs unfortunately, but it would have been great if Apple did embrace WebM, but I don't see that happening in a near future.
- tomkin 15y ago> People who used it because it was easier than HTML5. Having developed both HTML5 and Flash applications, your use of the word was shows a bit of ignorance when it comes to Flash. It is still easier in Flash to do a high-velocity, interactive site that works across multiple browsers. If you think differently, you're not actually doing the work. Armchair critics of Flash just regurgitate what they perceive is truth – HTML5's abilities are on par with Flash. But it isn't true. To be clear, my support is with HTML5, not Flash. But as someone who works with both daily, I'd be pretty biased if I went around telling people that HTML5 is a trouble-free alternative to Flash. That would be a pretty big lie. > Luckily, those days are over. They are far from over. People cite YouTube HTML5 player without considering how vlogs are actually recorded, processed and uploaded through Flash. As the viewer, it's a nice luxury to say it can all be done through HTML5, but as a producer of content you'd have a different opinion. We all know about Web Audio API[1] and Capture API[2]. No need to mention how they are X years away. They aren't here today. [1] http://www.w3.org/TR/audioproc/ http://www.w3.org/TR/audioproc/ [2] http://www.w3.org/TR/2010/WD-capture-api-20100401/ http://www.w3.org/TR/2010/WD-capture-api-20100401/
- poppysan 15y agoI will be sad to see no flash support. I mostly use it for gaming on my tablet and galaxy s II and have had absolutely no issues. My mom got a transformer for Christmas and has been able to play all of her Facebook games (90% of her internet usage). It is really a bad move that directly affects ppl like my mom and other casual gamers.
- jseims 15y agoAs someone who works with both Flash and HTML5, this news makes me sad. Flash just works for much better. There are no cross-browser issues (except those that don't support it at all -- thanks, Apple). And ActionScript is a better language for building complex apps than JavaScript.
- Karunamon 15y agoThe main problem with Flash is that it's completely proprietary, and therefore, as 4chan would say, OH EXPLOITABLE. Worse is the fact that Adobe has been sitting with their thumbs wedged in their arses for months, in some cases, while known vulnerabilities were being exploited in the wild. It's hard to imagine a better argument for moving away from closed technologies like this.