3 ms·
All that tracking data will be sent back to the mothership. First, Apple will deny that there's data collection. Then they will say they're keeping the data pri
by Animats 4y ago
All that tracking data will be sent back to the mothership. First, Apple will deny that there's data collection. Then they will say they're keeping the data private. Then they will say it's being only being used for "anonymous tracking". Then it will come out it's being sold for marketing purposes.
"It will even offer "All Day People Discovery," which will track the user's proximity to others, drawing distinctions between work colleagues and friends."
That could be really useful for tracking down illegal immigrants, gays, and politicians meeting with lobbyists.
- andrewbarba 4y agoIt will, most definitely, be end to end encrypted along with the rest of user data in the iCloud ecosystem.
- smoldesu 4y agoUnless you live in China*. * https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208351 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208351
- handsclean 4y agoiCloud user data that’s not end-to-end encrypted: name, home address, work address, who you talk to and when, where you go and when, what you buy and when… iCloud user data that’s not end-to-end encrypted unless you find and change multiple different settings that few people know about: files, photos, notes, texts, full copies of laptop’s and phone’s storage… I’d take a bet that 99% of the time Apple or a local regime wants to read iCloud user data, they can.
- kaba0 4y agoI’m almost sure that billing informations are required by law in plenty jurisdictions to be stored, where you go and when is a feature for Find My, what you buy and when is again, first point. What if I tell you that literally any physical supermarket will also have this data?
- smoldesu 4y agoThat's kinda the problem. This "required by law" bit obviously conflicts with their "privacy is a human right" shtick. Just look through their transparency page[0], where Apple confirms that device and account data is turned over by the thousands annually. Despotic nations like China get 93% of device access requests granted. Apple doesn't even have control over Chinese iCloud servers, their allegiance to the government directly prevents them from protecting their users. > What if I tell you that literally any physical supermarket will also have this data? Great, now we're comparing iPhone privacy to a supermarket. Wasn't Apple supposed to care about this stuff? [0] https://www.apple.com/legal/transparency/ https://www.apple.com/legal/transparency/
- kaba0 4y agoWe are talking about China, that straight up just replaced Google with their own thing. You are either doing business with China at their own rules, or you don’t do anything. Apple has different iCloud settings for the rest of the world, and while it does suck for Chinese people, the alternative would be some domestic OS with much much more involved privacy violations. Also, why should a company be above local law? Sure it sucks when the local law is bad and apple should not make the job easier, but if they do lawfully request some data then I don’t see why Apple should not fulfill it.
- smoldesu 4y ago> or you don’t do anything. This was the ethical abstention that the rest of FAANG pursued. At least, the ones who didn't have vested manufacturing contracts in the China mainland. Let them replace it with their own thing, it's a better alternative than compromising every iPhone "just in case". It's not only about domestic security, it's about how it devalues the meaning of Apple's privacy worldwide. > Also, why should a company be above local law? Because their principles of privacy and security supersede their interest in moneymaking? If the local law is unjust, you don't do business there. That's what Microsoft, Google, Netflix and > I don’t see why Apple should not fulfill it. Your phone shouldn't have a backdoor in the first place. Letting Apple have this much vertical authority over their platform is why we're here now, trying to decide if America's largest corporation is right for sleeping with the enemy. It's obviously wrong (as you note), but we're also helpless to resist it (as you also note). The best path of recourse is legislation that dilutes Apple's absolute authority and forces them to play ball with the industry. It's attractive to legislators, regulators, and the common people.
- ajdude 4y ago>All that tracking data will be sent back to the mothership. First, Apple will deny that there's data collection. Then they will say they're keeping the data private. Then they will say it's being only being used for "anonymous tracking". Then it will come out it's being sold for marketing purposes. Do we have any records of Apple doing this previously?
- Teever 4y agoIts basically the MO of the entire tech industry since internet connectivity became ubiquitous.
- r00fus 4y agoYou’re not answering the question are you?
- Animats 4y agoYes.[1][2][3] [1] https://fossbytes.com/apple-data-collection-explained/ https://fossbytes.com/apple-data-collection-explained/ [2] https://www.wired.com/story/apple-privacy-data-collection/ https://www.wired.com/story/apple-privacy-data-collection/ [3] https://www.theregister.com/2022/11/14/apple_data_collection_lawsuit/ https://www.theregister.com/2022/11/14/apple_data_collection...
- microtherion 4y ago"Now that we’ve established that Apple collects and uses your data to serve ads, does it sell your data too? Turns out the answer is No, Apple doesn’t sell your data to third-party advertisers." Thanks for providing your own refutations. Now stop lying.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 4y agoA lot of people seem to define “selling your data” to mean “selling ads that are measured with your data”. If it’s “selling your data” when FB does that, the same is true when it’s Apple.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- misssocrates 4y agoWouldn't it be useful for tracking down any human being?
- tenpies 4y ago> Then it will come out it's being sold for marketing purposes You forgot the last part: then we'll learn Apple has been granting near-automatic access to any three-letter agency that wants to read your journal.
- ksec 4y ago>All that tracking data will be sent back to the mothership. First, Apple will deny that there's data collection. Then they will say they're keeping the data private. Then they will say it's being only being used for "anonymous tracking". Then it will come out it's being sold for marketing purposes. Well I dont disagree with most of the points, considering I was the first few on HN to rally about their so called privacy stand / fundamental human right, but >Then it will come out it's being sold for marketing purposes I seriously seriously doubt. As much as I like to shit on Apple, I think the worst they do is to hold all the Data for themselves and build an Advertising platform. Unless that is what you mean by being sold for marketing purposes, which is what most of HN thinks during 2017 - 2022. And that is a generalisation of US / Free World only. They might very likely hand those Data to some government.