2 ms·
> Nuclear is not really suitable for load-following, at least not the installed capacity. That's not quite the case. You can load-follow with nuclear, but it r
by cyberax 4y ago
> Nuclear is not really suitable for load-following, at least not the installed capacity.
That's not quite the case. You can load-follow with nuclear, but it requires reactors to be designed for that. France does this, for example.
You also can simply keep reactors working at a constant level and just dump excess power into their cooling system. This is not as bad as it sounds, because fuel is just about ~5% of the total cost of the produced nuclear energy.
Most nuclear power plants do not do this because they don't need to do it.
- pydry 4y ago>This is not as bad as it sounds, because fuel is just about ~5% of the total cost of the produced nuclear energy. Therein lies the problem. Capital costs dominate nuclear plant costs and they are high. If you load followed such that you kept the reactor at an average of, say, 50% nameplate capacity that would lead to a levelized cost per MWh of about 2x$168 = $336. (LCOE listed here is $168: https://www.reuters.com/breakingviews/green-surge-is-circuit-breaker-nuclear-revival-2023-01-04/ https://www.reuters.com/breakingviews/green-surge-is-circuit...) For reference, Bhadla solar park sells a MWh for roughly $30, so even if you charged $300 to store and retrieve it you could still provide cheaper electricity than a load following nuclear power plant running at 50% of nameplate.
- cyberax 4y agoI question your estimation of the capital cost. LCOE for most nuclear power plants is way below that: https://www.oecd-nea.org/lcoe/ https://www.oecd-nea.org/lcoe/ For the US it's $33 per MWh, so doubling it still gives reasonable cost. As for wind, it simply can not compete right now for guaranteed capacity. The adequacy rating for most wind power plants is around 10%, so you need 10x overbuild to even compete.
- pfdietz 4y agoMany of the entries in that table (LTO) are for 20 year life extensiom of existing plants, not new plants.
- cyberax 4y agoAnd so what? Modern nuclear reactors are licensed for 60 years and are expected to last 80-100 years with maintenance (reactor vessel annealing, mainly). This is exactly a point in favor of nuclear.
- btreecat 4y agoSo where's the "solar spills" or "wind contamination?" One of these solutions is encumbered by problems of safety, the other capacity. It's easier to scale up capacity than it is to scale safety. If I had to make long term bets, radioactive materials will continue to be radioactive, green capture, storage and transmission will get cheaper and more reliable. Speaking of transmission, that's another huge problem. You can't go plopping powerplants just anywhere, and power generation needs to be somewhat close to those consuming it. Distributed collection and storage helps reduce challenges around transmission infrastructure in low density or hard to travel areas. Consider Puerto Rico, their investments in solar have skyrocketed, especially with the need to rebuild so much infrastructure. They had nuclear, and they were cleaning up contamination for decades after shutting it down. Also part of the issue with power there is transmission. You don't get the efficiency out of tiny boilers to make them cost effective for these folks. I think you're pushing a bit hard for a tech that has a lot of problems and while it could play a role in our future, it's unlikely to be a dominant force.
- cyberax 4y ago> So where's the "solar spills" or "wind contamination?" At the factories that produce silicon and composites for the windblades. > One of these solutions is encumbered by problems of safety, the other capacity. It's easier to scale up capacity than it is to scale safety. So far, no large country has managed to move to 100% carbon-free renewable generation. And I'm not seeing this changing. > Distributed collection and storage helps reduce challenges around transmission infrastructure in low density or hard to travel areas. If we're talking about Europe, they are facing the problem of Dunkelflaute - long periods of no wind, no sun, and low temperatures in the middle of the winter. A worst-case once-in-century scenario would require around a _month_ of storage. So far no technology is even close to that.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]