3 ms·
That's one reason, but there are several other common issues. At high volume mtu bottlenecks, the routers dropping packets are likely to limit how many ICMPs t
by toast0 4y ago
That's one reason, but there are several other common issues.
At high volume mtu bottlenecks, the routers dropping packets are likely to limit how many ICMPs they send; otherwise they'll run out of CPU. This wouldn't be terrible if ICMPs weren't so commonly dropped.
Some bottlenecked routers don't have globally routable IP addresses, and may not be able to send ICMP at all. This can happen inside long haul networks, where there may be tunneling that reduces the effective MTU. This seems less common today, but I dunno? One 'recent' advance is that some PPPoE networks use 'mini jumbo' frames, with an ethernet MTU of 1508, so that the PPP mtu is 1500; that may be happening on other layers with tunnels too.
- citrin_ru 4y agoYes, unfortunately it is not hard to find routers without globally routable IP on a loopback or interfaces (whatever is used as the source for ICMP unreach in a given configuration) but if they have any IP at all, even a private IP, PMTUD still may work as long as ICMP messages with private source IP are not blocked by a firewall. But when a packet is dropped inside a carrier network (and not on its edges) because of a MTA mismatch it looks like a gross misconfiguration to me.