3 ms·
Technology companies seem to have a chronic problem with consent. And when regulation drops in, they do everything they can to cry, complain, deceive, work-arou
by ryandrake 4y ago
Technology companies seem to have a chronic problem with consent. And when regulation drops in, they do everything they can to cry, complain, deceive, work-around, weasel-out, ignore, and fight against consent. If the web was a nightclub, Silicon Valley would be the creepy guy that hits on every woman with "Do you want to dance with me? [Yes] [Ask Me Again In Five Minutes]."
It's embarrassing how out of control the industry is, how toothless regulators are, and how outraged companies are when something finally forces them to simply ask users permission to do things.
- dheera 4y agoWhile I agree with the consent issue, I think consent to use cookies isn't the problem. I already set my browser to not store cookies by default, and make exceptions for a few websites I need to log into. For me, consent is enforced at the browser level, not the website level. So I don't really care whether I hit "accept" or "decline". Their cookies aren't going to be stored either way. In fact it's even more ridiculous and annoying that they need to store a goddamn cookie or fingerprint me to remember that I declined, which of course doesn't get stored on my end, and results in the stupid dialog box appearing every time I visit the site. You know where I really hate tech companies and consent? Asking for phone numbers for SMS confirmations. No thanks. You don't need my phone number to do business with me. Just the other day a goddamn restaurant needed a phone number to order food in person at the restaurant via their abomination of a QR code at the table and a mobile webpage ordering system.
- olivierduval 4y agoWatch out, cookie consent is more than just cookies: it's about keeping and exploitable your personal datas! When you accept cookies, you accept that the provider can use and sell your datas... so even if you automatically erase the cookie, it's only the tip of the iceberg GDPR is way larger than just cookies...
- Rygian 4y agoWhen you instruct your browser to accept cookies for the few websites you log into, your browser is unable to limit acceptance only to the cookies that are strictly mandatory for proper functioning. Instead, your browser will accept any cookie, including unnecessary ones, because it can't tell the difference. Therefore, you cannot enforce consent at the browser level.
- closeparen 4y agoSession cookies and user accounts are obviously not necessary for the proper functioning of discussion boards - 4chan is one of the most popular in the world. Shall we haul the Hacker News admins off to jail? I'm not trying to be cheeky here. Who can say what the "necessary" and "proper" functioning of a given website is? You can always imagine a similar-but-different website. I think usually people are talking about ad-related stuff, but then why not regulate that in particular?
- gspencley 4y agoPart of the problem is that most of their end users don't care. I'm not saying that they shouldn't care, or that there aren't people (like you and me) who care. But when your business model, for logical reasons, tries to please the most amount of people without trying to please everyone then there is a disincentive to prioritize things like privacy. The cookie banners that came about after GDPR didn't help the culture around privacy and security. All they did was piss off the great masses of end users to the point where some browsers (ex: Brave) now have specialized pop-up blockers just to stop annoying users with something that was [ironically] put in place to safeguard the privacy and rights of the masses who didn't actually ask for that. When I talk about privacy and security, most people tell me to my face that they prefer convenience and don't care at all, one tiny little bit, about their data or privacy. And so now we're starting to regulate and consider "digital rights", using the strong arm of the law to force companies to care. I'm not saying that we shouldn't. I have very low trust when it comes to tech companies and online services, particularly in the field of data security and PII. I wish that companies would be held liable for data breaches. But my point is that a huge part of the problem is that there seems to be a major disconnect between what the government is trying to force companies to do (a government that is supposed represent the will of the people) and what the actual people (customers) are telling the companies that they want. Changing culture is a near impossible feat, but I think this is more of a cultural problem than a lack of legislation problem.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- yafbum 4y agoUser indifference is not the problem behind dark patterns. Some of these UIs are clearly designed to discourage people who do care, by making non-essential cookie rejection more expensive in terms of user time (one more click, obfuscation, hiding behind a "manage settings" button, walls of legalese...). I'm pretty sure there are orders of magnitude fewer users who want to manage detailed cookie settings at a super granular level, but somehow, as a user who would rather just reject all non-essential cookies, I see a lot of "cookie settings management UI" that I have to "save", when all I could've done with is a "reject all" button. This isn't a user problem.
- yafbum 4y agoThis is an ecosystem problem, not a tech company problem. You see these dark pattern pop-ups on every website, including media sites, mail order, big brands, local shops... The tech companies are thinking about their bottom line, but they're also responding to their customers (advertisers, publishers, merchants). It is embarrassing indeed. The systemic nature of the problem is a good argument for increased regulation.
- munificent 4y agoYou can think of every business as harnessing some sort of "natural resource" and generating value from it by transforming to something more usable and/or selling it. At its core, almost every business is: 1. Acquire resource. 2. Transform or make it into something more usable. 3. Sell it to customers. All businesses are directly incentivized to have as wide and efficient of a pipe for sucking up the raw materials they build products out of. Fishing boats want to use the biggest nets regardless of bycatch. Mines want to level the whole mountain regardless of what lives on it. Farmers want crop growing on every square inch of the field regardless of biodiversity. You get the idea. This is not out of any deliberate malice, it's just an emergent property of how the system works. If you have a bunch of companies making widgets out of blobstuff, the company that can get the most blobstuff the cheapest wins. And, as purchasers of widgets, we benefit from the system and tacitly support it by participating. For ad-driven tech companies, the natural resource they acquire is human attention. They are structurally incentivized to acquire as much as they can, as cheaply as they can, for as long as they can. One of the "obstacles" to harvesting human attention which can be then sold to advertisers is that those pesky humans would prefer to place their attention elsewhere. Given that, tech companies are always going to be pushing the boundaries of consent. It's not a strictly zero-sum game, because sometimes humans actually do want to consume ads. But as the amount of attention being sucked up by companies increases and as people get reasonably more and more covetous of their own attention, that game gets less non-zero over time.
- jacquesm 4y ago> This is not out of any deliberate malice Having seen quite a few instances of deliberate malice I beg to differ. It is out of deliberate malice, though there may be a couple of cases where it is an emergent thing. The vast majority of these companies are aware of it, won't change their ways and have a hundred different ways to rationalize their illegal behavior.
- munificent 4y agoYou and I may have different definitions of "malice". I define malice as deliberately harming someone without attaining an equal or greater benefit in return. Malice is setting someone's car on fire. Stealing someone's car is selfish and immoral, but not malicious in my definition.