5 ms·
I recall reading that other branches of the military would take recruits and in boot camp when they weren't meeting the fitness standards they would get assigne
by duxup 4y ago
I recall reading that other branches of the military would take recruits and in boot camp when they weren't meeting the fitness standards they would get assigned to a group of other similar folks and they'd work on that ... and then later rejoin a group in boot camp after they slimmed down / were more fit.
Seemed like a good / practical idea.
- zdragnar 4y agoIt's a necessary idea. The pool of people willing to join and fit enough to get through boot camp has shrunk enough that the military has been missing their recruiting goals.
- nickelpro 4y agoThe recruiting goals are inflated due to low retention, retention is low due to low morale but also because of high employment rates. When it's easy to get a civilian gig less people stay in, especially among technical rates/MOS's. The problem isn't as simple as "America too fat".
- the_only_law 4y agoAny insight into why morale is low? I have a lot of immediate family in the military with current and past experiences across all the main branches except the Navy and the “Space Force”. I talk to some of them pretty often and so I’ve developed my own theories, but I’d be curious to hear others.
- jimmygrapes 4y agoAnecdotally, I know and speak to dozens of Veterans a week and multiples more of young people in the target range, and the general consensus is "what are we fighting/training for, and why would I want to risk anything for an evil/corrupt/racist country". The idea that "America Bad" (however true or not) has permeated nearly everywhere in some form or another.
- autoexec 4y agoIn fairness, America has earned a lot of it's "America Bad" reputation by acting in deplorable ways and failing to protect and care for its people. When I was young I was fed a lot of stories about what America was, mostly in contrast to the USSR and other communist countries. I was told about horrible things those evil other nations did to their people or failed to do for them which would never happen in the USA and how proud I should be that we were better than that, but over the course of my life I've seen more and more of those very same things happening right here. It's even worse for the folks looking at how our military has been used. I've met people who told me they were more than willing to defend their country, but were not at all willing to go to the other side of the planet and defend an oil field, or topple a democratically elected leader so that we could install someone more favorable to being exploited. I don't think there's been a single year of my life where we haven't had US servicemen overseas killing people for one reason or another, but damned if I could even tell you what it was for or where it took place for all but the ones most widely reported/televised. The US absolutely could do with better PR, and sometimes people are unfairly critical, but it's hard to blame folks feeling disillusioned given our record and even our current/recent behavior leaves a lot of room for improvement.
- inkcapmushroom 4y agoThere could be a number of reasons contributing to it. The veil of "America fighting for its freedoms" has fallen a long time ago. Veterans are tragically neglected in the USA, with huge homeless veteran populations, huge suicide rates, and a notoriously terrible medical system for them in the VA. Maybe more opportunities are becoming available for historically neglected populations so they don't need to turn to the military as the only way out of a situation or place. From talking to veterans directly, some I've talked to are adamant that none of their kids should join the military as they don't see it as worth it. I know families with histories of military service where that has ended with the newer generations so maybe that's also a factor.
- Der_Einzige 4y agoLiterally every veteran I've talked to with VA medical says its really good. Most of the people with VA problems were like Vietnam veterans who have zero documentation of their claims that they got hit with agent orange. Most complaints I see about the VA are about refusals to render service, rather than bad service given.
- Arrath 4y agoVA quality is very much a regional thing. A friend of mine (Iraq vet) has the worst experience with the VA offices in Southern California VA offices, they regularly fuck up his prescription refills and refuse to issue him extra/backup scrips so he often has gaps in his medication regimen that debilitate him until the refill comes in. He moved back up to Oregon last year, solely for access to more functional VA offices. Another friend keeps his residence in Arizona and regularly travels back for appointments, again to avoid dealing with CA VA.
- ARandumGuy 4y agoOne has to imagine the poor perception of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan have also harmed recruitment. Few people want to sign up when they think they'll just be shipped halfway across the world to die for the interests of an oil company.
- logicalmonster 4y ago> high employment rates For what little it's worth, I never trust this statistic because the unemployment rate calculation doesn't count certain types of people: such as those who've given up looking for work. Given the weird times and general malaise of society, this might be a non-trivial variable right now. I could be wrong about this, but it remains a possibility that we're not getting the right picture of what's happening.
- ghaff 4y agoThere are other unemployment measures you can go by if you don't like the one that "everyone" quotes.
- TheCoelacanth 4y agoPeople always bring this up, but there are a myriad of different metrics that include all kinds of different groups, like people who want work but have given up on finding work or people who are working less but than they want to. All of those measures are highly correlated with each other and move nearly in lockstep with each other.
- autoexec 4y agoYeah, considering how poorly the US treats their service members and veterans, even if I were eligible for service and thought I'd do well in that kind of environment it'd be very hard not to feel like a sucker. When we demonstrate over and over again that we can't be bothered to take care of the people who are willing to put their lives on the line for our country's interests how can we expect anyone to sign up?
- logicalmonster 4y agoLack of fitness is the big national health problem, but the first part of the equation is the real stickler. A fat person who is forced to run and do pushups with a controlled diet can always lose weight: but an unwilling person will never join the military voluntarily. Why are so many people unwilling to join? It's sort of crazy that the military is having trouble recruiting in down economic times: they're the one entity that is always able to hire lots of people regardless of how the economic climate is doing. IMO, the pool of people who would want to join the military would greatly expand if other things were done: > The brass is doubling down on "woke messaging" for recruitment. You may or may not agree with this personally, but there's zero doubt that this is in conflict with the ideals of the kinds of people who traditionally want to join the military. > The country's leadership seems to be dead set on, at the very least, a proxy war with Russia. Potentially risking your life to protect your family from real danger is one thing, but few sane people want to seek out unnecessary war for the benefit of the military industrial complex. > Whether you think the Covid vaccines are good or bad risk-management assessments, there's no doubt that a significant fraction of the country do not see it that way and will not put themselves in a position to potentially take it. Many people don't think it's necessary and don't trust it, but the administration can't seem to let go of the other group of people they're simping for: Big Pharma. PS: I welcome downvotes if you tell me why my analysis is incorrect, not simply because you disagree with it.
- ghaff 4y agoI didn't downvote you but it seems as if there are more obvious explanations such as low unemployment and higher salaries for low-skill jobs--making signing up for the military with all that implies a less desirable option for a lot of people who now have better alternatives. And "woke messaging"? A proxy war with Russia that US troops are not involved in--certainly relative to the US military situation overseas in the past couple of decades? And lots of private companies required COVID shots to remain employed. So, yes, those seem like largely irrelevant reasons.
- logicalmonster 4y ago> And "woke messaging"? To fully explore this idea, I'd have to say some things that are verbotten on HN, but suffice it to say that there's a big difference between the policy of "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" and going full on into LGBTQPIA+ that the current military appears to be going on. This kind of thing may have an impression on the kinds of young men that might want to join the military. (as a very small supporting data point on this, look at men's declining entry to colleges). Again, you don't have to agree or disagree with it, I'm only pointing out factors in the conversation that might not get brought up otherwise. These are factors to a non-trivial part of the population. > A proxy war with Russia that US troops are not involved in--certainly relative to the US military situation overseas in the past couple of decades? The wars of recent decades are a big factor, but I can say that this push against Russia also isn't helping. My opinion is that people want to defend their homes, but don't want to risk getting exploded in some unnecessary conflict. > And lots of private companies required COVID shots to remain employed. And many people hated this and sought out companies that didn't require them. You don't have to agree with refusing the vaccine, but I hope you understand that many people absolutely didn't want it and the military's insistence on injecting people with this doesn't help among some people. > So, yes, those seem like largely irrelevant reasons. I strongly disagree with your analysis, but thank you for your polite and honest thoughts at least.
- nickelpro 4y agoBy far the funniest version of this is people who enlist in the US Navy and can't swim. They spend effectively all of boot camp going to the pool while instructors shout at them to float, as if that is somehow going to teach them to tread water.
- duxup 4y agoI think a pretty large % of people can't swim.
- coldtea 4y agoA "pretty large" number of people does not work in the navy.
- replygirl 4y agoTechnically true. The Oromo are a large people, making up 35% of Ethiopia's 115 million citizens; Ethiopia does not have a navy. sorry this was funnier before your edit
- stevekemp 4y agoTraditionally many sailors couldn't swim, so it almost fits! In the UK most children are taught to swim, and in many European countries the same. I'm often surprised to learn that Americans swim less frequently, but I guess it's just another one of those culture and facilities differences.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoMaybe this is a warning sign that the wellbeing of society is falling off a cliff, even though GDP is growing. This is not sustainable
- rcme 4y agoWhat's unsustainable about it?
- lm28469 4y agoFat = unhealthy = more stress on the health care system Fat = lower fertility Fat = largest contributor in the 3 top leading cause of deaths in the US &c. imho it's a symptom of a larger thing, like stress induced over eating in animals. It's a slow suicide, an healthy individual should be able to see it for what it is and act on it, society should be able to see it for what it is and help these individuals, seems like we're doing the complete opposite, mostly for profit
- rcme 4y agoNone of those things are inherently unsustainable. In fact, a smaller population that dies earlier is actually more sustainable than a large, long-living population.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoA dwindling population eventually reaches 0
- rcme 4y agohttps://xkcd.com/605/ https://xkcd.com/605/ It seems more likely that an equilibrium would be reached before the population reaches 0.
- lm28469 4y agoUnsustainable as in "humanity will be wiped out ? Clearly no Unsustainable as in people are shadows of what they could be, people die way earlier than they should, &c ? Definitely Outliers excluded, the difference between an active/fit 60 years old and someone who's been fat their whole life at the same age is night and day. One has years/decades of healthy life to go, the other has one foot in the grave If it was an experiment on animals we would have pulled the plug 30 years ago
- jandrewrogers 4y agoYes, there are both fitness and fatness hurdles, or at least there were a few decades ago. If you were reasonably fit but quite fat, you would go through Army Basic Training but be on a restricted diet. People would lose 30-40 pounds in six weeks, so it was effective. If you were sufficiently unfit that you could not exercise, that was when they sent you to remedial training before you could join Basic Training.
- jasonladuke0311 4y agoYep. In the Marine Corps when I went through boot camp they called it Physical Conditioning Platoon (PCP), colloquially “Pork Chop Platoon”
- scruple 4y agoYeah, remedial training blocks (fail to meet the standard, you move to a different phase of training for 3 weeks and try again) weren't uncommon in the military, at least not when I served (granted that's north of 20 years ago now).