3 ms·
You also can't explain why progress for the sake of progress is a good thing.
by _heimdall 4y ago
You also can't explain why progress for the sake of progress is a good thing.
- nickpp 4y agoYou'll have to take that up with Mother Nature and its evolution & natural selection. She's the one who imprinted "progress" in our genes and I do not think we are far enough from our origins to overwrite that.
- ben_w 4y agoWhat evolution optimises for isn't what you'd call "good" if it came up in any other context. It's as much why covid happened as it is why we happened.
- _heimdall 4y agoComparing natural selection and human invention is a drastic over simplification. Meaningful change due to natural selection takes place over thousands of years of random genetic mutations and changing environmental conditions. Change due to human invention is happening on the scale of years or decades and is the result of us making decisions just because we can. Would you really like to compare the evolutionary change from species that walk on four legs eventually becoming bipedal to the change caused by industrialization or nuclear technology? The level of impact humans have managed to have on the world around us is massively different from any other species we're aware of. No other species appears to sit around making decisions that reshape large portions of the environment in a single generation. "Progress" in that sense is not genetically ingrained in us, it can't be if we're the first species to do this.
- loa_in_ 4y agoNature doesn't pursue progress. It fosters any (at least some) that might appear but it doesn't actively pursue it. If it did, there would be instinctual drive to seek out ionising radiation proportionally to the amount of offspring for particular species. To iterate as fast as possible and get any edge in selection.
- JohnFen 4y agoEvolution and natural selection have nothing to do with "progress".
- AnimalMuppet 4y ago"Progress for the sake of progress is the ideology of the cancer cell" - Edward Abbey.
- nickpp 4y ago... and is also the ideology of every single species on Earth from bacteria to higher mammals and humans (we're not special). And it applies within species and across species. The evolutionary equilibrium can only appear from matched competitors which implies that each advancement (or its counter) gets eventually distributed around which means - AI for all.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoYour reply makes sense for balance within humanity. It doesn't for balance between humanity and all other species, which is odd, given how your post started out.
- loa_in_ 4y agoNature doesn't pursue progress, but fosters any that appears. Sometimes. I think that's a major difference.
- blibble 4y ago> .. and is also the ideology of every single species on Earth from bacteria to higher mammals and humans (we're not special). we ARE special we are the only form of life on Earth that has (at least in some places) chosen to not expand ourselves at the expense of everything else some humans value the natural world, unpolluted waters, general quality of life over having as many children as possible