5 ms·
The /r/fuckcars folks are being a little dishonest here. As another commenter mentioned, this is like asking a vegan for steak recommendations at a restaurant.
by echelon 4y ago
The /r/fuckcars folks are being a little dishonest here. As another commenter mentioned, this is like asking a vegan for steak recommendations at a restaurant.
Subaru Sambar (kei truck) towing capacity: 1,300 lbs
Ford F-150 towing capacity: 5,000 to 11,300 lbs
Ford F-250 Shelby edition towing capacity: 24,200 pounds
And that's just one additional dimension where these vehicles significantly differ.
These vehicles are utilitarian workhorses great for contracting, construction, farming (eg. hauling livestock), towing (eg. other cars, trailers, mobile BBQ, etc.), boating, leisure [1], etc.
I live in an urban area close enough to the forest, lakes, and pastures to see all of these uses frequently.
The electric version will power job sites, camp sites, and help with disaster recovery. It's going to sell like hot cakes.
[1] https://www.f150forum.com/f34/how-pull-jeep-out-mud-130086/#post1317551 https://www.f150forum.com/f34/how-pull-jeep-out-mud-130086/#...
- porphyra 4y agoThe point isn't that the smaller truck is an equally capable vehicle. The point is to make fun of people who don't need a truck but are getting an overkill vehicle as a status symbol, all the while people who actually need to transport goods can still get a lot done with a tiny kei truck.
- chrisco255 4y agoIf everyone has one, it's not a status symbol. The article talks about using the Kei truck as a replacement for a UTV/Side-by-Side, not for a daily truck. These /r/fuckcars people have never done real work in their lives and are just larping. 1100 pound tow capacity couldn't even tow most empty trailers.
- kalleboo 4y ago> If everyone has one, it's not a status symbol iPhones somehow manage to be a status symbol even with 50% of the US population owning one
- chrisco255 4y agoReally, iPhones are status symbols, in 2023? Do people turn their head to look at you as you walk down the street, because you own an iPhone?
- kalleboo 4y agoKids are bullied and excluded for not having "blue bubbles" and men are told "swipe left if you have green bubbles" on tinder.
- GiorgioG 4y agoWhen did “need” become a requirement for having things? Who gave you or anyone else the authority to decide what other people “need”? I don’t think people “need” motorcycles, private planes, vacation homes, more than a few million dollars in the bank, etc. But who am I to tell people what they should have? Live and let live.
- mcv 4y agoThe problem is that they're not letting others live. Those oversized cars are a lot more dangerous, and they pollute more, they take up more space.
- GiorgioG 4y agoMy F150 pollutes much less than my wife’s car simply by virtue of me working from home while she commutes every day. Taking up more space is not an issue for people who don’t live in big cities. Trucks are not more inherently dangerous than any other vehicle just because of their size. If that were the case let’s outlaw semis, delivery trucks and anything larger than a VW Golf (a car I had & loved in my youth.) You folks need to get it out of your heads that one size fits all and everyone needs to have the same values and make the same choices as you. Everything has risks and trade offs.
- mcv 4y ago> My F150 pollutes much less than my wife’s car simply by virtue of me working from home while she commutes every day. Awesome, but that's not about the car, it's about working from home. > Taking up more space is not an issue for people who don’t live in big cities. But it is for those who do. And still for a lot of people outside big cities. > Trucks are not more inherently dangerous than any other vehicle just because of their size. If that were the case let’s outlaw semis, delivery trucks and anything larger than a VW Golf (a car I had & loved in my youth.) It's not just the size, also other factors about the design, but there's a reason why commercial driving licenses exist. They should probably be required for all trucks. > You folks need to get it out of your heads that one size fits all and everyone needs to have the same values and make the same choices as you. It doesn't have to fit all, but it does have to fit the environment, or at least take it into consideration.
- libraryatnight 4y agoI know a lot of people with those ridiculous big trucks, and 2 of them use them for utility, one has a boat and one has a 5th wheel. The others just...have them. So until there's zero people driving them for vanity or aggression reasons, it doesn't feel dishonest at all. Your response feels like a typical US response to social ills - turn a blind eye to a problem because a) the thing causing the problem is fun/popular/profitable b) there's a handful of hyper specific potentially valid reasons for the thing that have nothing to do with the people causing the problem (most of the giant trucks in my area can't even haul anything because of the vanity lifts and various "upgrades" - they would make the argument you are as to why they should be allowed but they would not support anything that would restrict them to those purposes).
- chrisco255 4y agoI know a lot of people who drive big trucks, and all of them regularly use them for: hauling building materials, towing RVs, towing boats, towing four wheelers/dirt bikes/UTVs/snowmobiles, pulling utility trailers (for trash pickup, job site cleanup, lumber & metal, piping, furniture, landscaping, tree service, etc), tailgating parties, hunting, mudding, off-roading, barbecuing (towing a smoker), etc. Literally don't know one person that drives a truck "for vanity" and I gotta know at least a few hundred truck owners. I drive a F350. It will tow a mountain. I pull a fifth wheel with it. People are often surprised to hear that it gets 20 miles per gallon when it's not towing anything. While I love the truck, I miss my old Tacoma. The Tacoma was a smoother ride and far more practical for urban navigation. But Tacomas have a bout a fifth or even less as much tow capacity as an F350. Big trucks aren't causing social ills for anyone except people that have nothing better to do but complain about other people enjoying their own lives.
- throwworhtthrow 4y ago> Big trucks aren't causing social ills for anyone except people that have nothing better to do but complain about other people enjoying their own lives. "These Stupid Trucks are Literally Killing Us" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35202168 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35202168
- alexvoda 4y agoAnd just how many of the F-150 owners have anything tow-able, let alone of that tonnage?
- hedora 4y agoRAM 1500: Towing capacity up hill. Zero. The transmission overheats after 3-4 hours going uphill with no load. They made it too heavy for the powertrain! It’s also depressingly easy to trigger the overload light on the dashboard by doing things like buying bricks at Home Depot. Seriously, WTF? Do we need a 2500 class to replace our old pre-fuel-injection GMC 1500? It had better fuel economy and was also lower to the ground. It could even handle mountain freeways! (The newer GMC was even worse than the Ram, FWIW.) I’d definitely look into one of these little japanese trucks if I could get a new one and have it serviced. Bonus points if it is an EV.
- chrisco255 4y agoSorry to hear that. The modern Ford PowerDiesels are amazing though. Mine has towed 20K+ pounds through a 10% grade in the Grand Tetons without breaking a sweat.
- quadrifoliate 4y ago> The /r/fuckcars folks are being a little dishonest here. As another commenter mentioned, this is like asking a vegan for steak recommendations at a restaurant. The subreddit is specifically named 'fuck cars'. How exactly are they being dishonest? This is more like r/vegan showing how a vegan meal is better than a steak meal along some dimension, say, environmental impact. > I live in an urban area close enough to the forest, lakes, and pastures to see all of these uses frequently. In fact I would say that you are the one being somewhat dishonest by (implicitly) claiming both the benefits of being able to use it as a utilitarian workhorse, and in an urban area. If the trucks have the majority of their utility as contracting, construction, or towing, they should require being licensed as a commercial driver, and potentially be banned from being operated on city roads due to the danger they pose to smaller vehicles and pedestrians. Think of the argument from that subreddit (and me) this way -- if you are driving a huge farm tractor, you cannot also bring said tractor into the city center. Not all heavy machinery needs to be allowed everywhere. Obviously you might not agree, but I think the argument is fundamentally honest.
- echelon 4y ago> How exactly are they being dishonest? They're comparing on a single dimension and laughing at F-150 owners. > This is more like r/vegan showing how a vegan meal is better than a steak meal along some dimension, say, environmental impact. Not when evaluating a purchasing decision, overall utility, or customer demographics and needs. I'm showing that morally opposed parties inject themselves and their biases orthogonally. > In fact I would say that you are the one being somewhat dishonest by (implicitly) claiming both the benefits of being able to use it as a utilitarian workhorse, and in an urban area. Have you ever been to a city that's half an hour to the woods? Or perhaps somewhere it's typical to find people owning acres of their own land right next to a major metropolitan? Not everything is SF or NYC. If you want to tax an externality, do so. Many state gas taxes tax vehicle weight via the proxy of gas mileage. Right now it's the heavy EVs doing the damage that are slipping through the taxation cracks. > they should require being licensed as a commercial driver Okay, now we're getting into yucking other people's yums. Some people own boats and full hog smokers, like getting muddy on the weekends and going fishing. There are millions of these folks in America. If you want to regulate what you perceive as a negative externality, we should do it evenly against everything. Tax and regulate broadly and fairly. Consider sex. It spreads disease and causes all sorts of relationship drama. Kids can be a nightmare. Think about all the lost productivity! Who's paying for that? (I'm joking, of course!) In the scheme of things, these vehicles are much more good than bad. They sell like crazy, satisfy their consumers, get a lot of productive work done, and on the weekends are spent as leisure devices - getting folks muddy and smelly with beers and fish and sun. A good diversion for hard workers. > potentially be banned from being operated on city roads due to the danger they pose to smaller vehicles and pedestrians You can vote for that in your own district, and maybe that's correct, but other places and populations will feel differently about how they live their own lives. > if you are driving a huge farm tractor, you cannot also bring said tractor into the city center. Not all heavy machinery needs to be allowed everywhere. On the spectrum of farm tractor to kei car, the F-150 is tightly clustered in the middle with the rest of the "street legal" vehicles.
- pastacacioepepe 4y agoStill don't need such a tall and long front bumper for any of those uses.
- wpm 4y agoThe vast majority of big-ass truck owners never haul anything, let alone something heavier than 1,300lbs.
- chrisco255 4y agoThe vast majority of large truck owners definitely do. 1300 pounds is nothing, and your ignorance is telling. Most people doing real work with trucks are hauling heavy duty construction trailers, or otherwise, but even if you wanted to move furniture you'd quickly exceed 1300 pounds. Even a tiny 4'x 8' U-Haul is 850 pounds empty: https://www.uhaul.com/Trailers/4x8-Cargo-Trailer-Rental/UV/ https://www.uhaul.com/Trailers/4x8-Cargo-Trailer-Rental/UV/
- dyno12345 4y ago"75 percent of truck owners use their truck for towing one time a year or less" https://www.thedrive.com/news/26907/you-dont-need-a-full-size-pickup-truck-you-need-a-cowboy-costume https://www.thedrive.com/news/26907/you-dont-need-a-full-siz...
- chrisco255 4y agoThanks for the useless hit piece, if you can find the scientific data, I'll evaluate it, but when I click into the links on the article, I'm unable to find it. So we're clear: because surveys are incredibly difficult to do in a scientific way and there's a dozen ways to ask a question that can skew results, there's a hundred ways a journalist can misinterpret the results of that question, and there's a thousand ways you could incorrectly slice the demographics such that your survey skews completely out of sync with the target subject. We want to know what large truck owners are doing with their trucks. We don't care about small truck owners not towing things because small trucks aren't considered to be excessive and truck beds are useful things on their own. Show me the data. Not the spin.
- bombcar 4y agoI think many users here would have a heart attack and die to realize how many semis on the road are entirely empty (deadheading) and how many are filled way below capacity. Most truck owners I know use their truck as a truck quite often. But that’s more rural; maybe everyone in a city commutes in an F150 for absolutely no reason at all.
- mcv 4y agoA 24,000 pound barbecue? What does that look like? I'm pretty sure most people who own these oversized pickup trucks never use that towing capacity. Maybe some do, and if they were the only ones using them, nobody would have a problem with it.