5 ms·
> Some argued that if the death penalty is eliminated, prosecutors will lose what little leverage they have to get murder suspects to cooperate with police. Th
by tialaramex 4y ago
> Some argued that if the death penalty is eliminated, prosecutors will lose what little leverage they have to get murder suspects to cooperate with police.
This seems like a trivially testable hypothesis. Civilized countries outlawed the death penalty for murder a long time ago, do their murder suspects in fact simply refuse to cooperate with police since death isn't a possible penalty? I would assume the answer is "No".
Many European countries don't even have life-without-parole as a possible sentence. All criminals in those countries can in principle be paroled, it's just that if you're an unrepentant murdering nazi, the parole decision is really easy, "Hmm, do we want this nazi to kill a bunch more people as he's repeatedly insisted he will if given a chance? No".
- abeppu 4y agoEven if it does remove a bit of leverage ... IIUC generally this kind of deal hinges on the state's discretion over whether to pursue a greater or lesser charge or ask for a greater or lesser sentence, and so we're talking about the state's ability to threaten and coerce someone who has not yet been convicted of anything through discretionary prosecution. Maybe that's leverage they shouldn't have?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- notch898c 4y ago[flagged]
- rcme 4y agoThey have fewer children killers so maybe that’s working.
- zamalek 4y agoIt also has a lot to do with avoiding lusting for revenge, instead focusing on rehabilitation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incarceration_in_Norway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incarceration_in_Norway I have been met with so many blank stares when explaining this concept to Americans, "but they killed children!" Sure, if it's revenge you want then help them understand and regret their actions; death is the easy way out.
- notch898c 4y ago[flagged]
- zamalek 4y agoI would defer to the justice system that is renowned for facilitating a country with not only the lowest crime rate in the world, but also the lowest recidivism rate. If playstation is part of the treatment, then so be it. What does your solution bring to the plate, apart from crime universities that produce hardened criminals?
- notch898c 4y agoIf you want my solution, here's roughly what I would do: Victimless crime: basically no penalty for this, most of it should be eliminated as crime. Maybe a small fine or education at the worst. Non-violent crime: Goal is restitution. Income or benefits are deducted to make the victim whole, probably with punitive damages to the victim as well. Basically no jail except in willful attempt to avoid restitution to victim, and perhaps not even then. Violent crime: Most cases rehabilitation, plus restitution to victims. Prison is close to Norway type system for violence not resulting in dismemberment/death/permanent brain damage. First instance of brutal violent crime to one victim: Norway type rehabilitation. Repeated rape, repeated murder conviction, repeated molestation of children, repeated brutal life-disabling violence: Trial, exhaustive appeals, bullet to the head. Mass murder of innocents: Trial, exhaustive appeals, then a bullet to the head.
- mazlix 4y agohttps://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/mass-shootings-by-country https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/mass-shoo... Can't find data on child killings but norway tops the chart of mass-shootings.
- wizofaus 4y agoIt's hard to think of any way in which that statistic is actually meaningful. I don't think anybody would reasonably argue based on a single event that the average Norwegian is more at risk of death via mass shooting compared to the average American, for a start. When you have only one data point pretty much any statistical comparison seems fairly pointless.
- notch898c 4y agoAbove I was told "results are what matter" (articbull) while advocating in support of the Norwegian treatment of mass killers. The results are in and Norway is one of the worst places in the first world for per capita mass shootings, even worse than the US. I can only conclude they are sadistic, malicious actors if they actually think this is the comparatively desirable result.
- wizofaus 4y agoAnd yet if you took any significant time period that doesn't include the Breivik shooting Norway's results are just fine. I'd even think if you looked at the last 50 or 75 years (assuming we have good enough data) they'd be better than the US's. And certainly if you included Norway along with other countries with similar policies on dealing with violent criminals. Which I don't even really think necessarily proves anything much on its own, but at least it's a meaningful data point.
- arcticbull 4y agoThe common failure mode is to index broad policy on single instances of failure. You're never, ever, no matter what, going to stop all instances. Trying to design a policy that eliminates all instances can actually increase the number of instances. You can't craft good policy that way. Rehabilitation, low recidivism, etc are far more important than revenge in optimizing the global situation. It's better this one killer serve out a sentence on their PS2, away from society, than creating 10 killers in the first place and executing them to satisfy bloodlust.
- notch898c 4y ago[flagged]
- arcticbull 4y agoIf it prevents the creation of even 2 other killers then I would not. Bloodlust doesn't make good policy. America has plenty of mass killings in states with the death penalty. Results are what matters. Kudos to penal systems that actually understand that instead of kowtowing to public pressure.
- slibhb 4y agoThe idea that the US has lots of mass shooting because of the death penalty (or the reverse for Norway) seems unlikely.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tadfisher 4y agoThat's precisely the point.
- notch898c 4y agoNorway overhauled their prison system in the late 90s, and their per capita mass shootings since then far outweigh the US. They're at like 20x the US for 2009-2015. Even if you do the total rehabilitative 20 years or so of data they're at least 4x worse than the US in per capita mass shooting. https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/mass-shootings-by-country https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/mass-shoo...
- plagiarist 4y agoYes, if you want to reduce recidivism and overall crime it turns out you have to treat criminals like humans. If you want criminals to continue doing crimes after release but have the satisfaction of knowing they were tortured and miserable, like eaten alive by bugs, you do what the USA does.
- notch898c 4y ago[flagged]
- autoexec 4y agoI don't really have a problem with this. If anything I'd argue that he should have been put away for more than 21 years since he'd certainly still be a risk to the public, but as it turns out after the 21 years they just extend his time anyway as long as he is still deemed a danger to society and that seems perfectly reasonable. I suspect he'll always be deemed a danger to society, but if turns out that there's some reason why that changes then why shouldn't he be released? I also don't care if he spends his time locked up playing video games. I hope that as long as he's locked up he is well treated and somehow lives an otherwise happy life. If I'd done what he did I'd never find peace. Some people just can't be allowed to be around the rest of us, because if we let them, they'd harm us. Keeping them imprisoned and unable to do as they please, go where they want, and be with the people they love is punishment enough but that's what is needed to keep the rest of us safe. If we had some means to "fix" people broken in the way he is so that they wouldn't go around murdering a bunch of people we wouldn't even need to do that. I'm not at all interested in torturing or murdering people out of a desire for revenge. It's a tragedy that he murdered all those people, and it's another tragedy he'll have to spend his life locked away from the world because of it.
- claudiawerner 4y agoThat's fine with me, so long as they don't get a PS3 or newer.
- wwarner 4y agoGary Ridgeway confessed to killings in exchange for a life sentence.
- poulsbohemian 4y agoI am not a lawyer, but... realistically sentiment has been moving away from the death penalty in Washington State since the 1990s such that even someone like Ridgeway was unlikely to be executed. I don't recall the last execution (I think I was a teen...) but even in those last few the appeals went on for years.
- runarberg 4y agoLast person executed was Cal Coburn Brown in 2010 for murdering Holly Washa in 1997. He and James Homer Elledge are the only two people executed by the state of Washington this century, Elledge was lethally injected in 2001, for murdering Eloise Jane Fitzner in 1998. Gov. Inslee set a moratorium when he came to power in 2014, and the state supreme court found the punishment to be racist and hence unconstitutional in 2018. It has been illegal ever since. This law basically just removes an unconstitutional law from the legal code. There is 0% chance that Gary Ridgway would ever have been executed by the state. There is also high chance that he would have given the names of his victims regardless of the plea bargain.
- KyeRussell 4y agoThis reasoning unfortunately just invites the same sort of silly American exceptionalism that we see everywhere else.
- philwelch 4y ago> Civilized countries outlawed the death penalty for murder a long time ago What do you have against Japan? I would consider Japan arguably the most civilized country.
- rayiner 4y agoAnd Singapore, Taiwan, and South Korea. And while India isn’t as developed as those countries, it’s the world’s largest functional democracy and I’d argue at least meets the threshold of “civilized.” I’d probably concede that China is also “civilized.”
- decafninja 4y agoFrom the perspective of crime, as much as I love visiting Europe I was disappointed at the amount of petty crime that goes ignored there. Such crime is virtually nonexistent in most of the Asian countries listed above.
- xyzzyz 4y agoIf you think petty crime is bad in Europe, don’t even think about visiting Americas. US cities are so much worse than almost of Europe it’s pretty shocking.
- philwelch 4y agoBut then again, we're already starting from the assumption that the US isn't a civilized country.
- decafninja 4y agoI disagree. The US has an entirely different level of crime issues (see guns), but I feel safer about petty crime (pickpocketing, scammers, etc) walking about a typical American city downtown than most European capitals. Case in point: I have designer brand backpack I frequently carry during traveling. I carry it without a second thought through the US and Asia. I don’t bring it with me to Europe because it’s likely to be a pickpocket magnet.