4 ms·
Seems one could use GPS for less granular positioning and then use visual landmarks like the soil/crop edge from the prior pass or row locations to align for th
by giantg2 4y ago
Seems one could use GPS for less granular positioning and then use visual landmarks like the soil/crop edge from the prior pass or row locations to align for the next pass.
- bluGill 4y agoThe point is to be accurate to within 2cm across the whole field, for the entire year. You cannot do that with landmarks and human driving.
- Groxx 4y agoIt's probably something that pays for itself reasonably quickly too. Minor human wobbling means more difficulty and damage when harvesting, probably a wasted row or three per field, etc. Add that up over a decade and many, MANY acres of fields and it's probably a lot of money. Precision enables a lot of savings.
- HeyLaughingBoy 4y agoOn /r/farming yesterday someone was showing how he uses John Deere's AIG (Active Implement Guidance) to come back after seeds have germinated and basically put "pockets" in the ground to allow water to pool around the seedlings. The accuracy that it requires to do that without damaging the plants is amazing.
- giantg2 4y agoI'm talking about computer vision using the visual landmarks for the fine tuning.
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoI am designing an autonomous farming robot. You're not wrong that this is possible, except in a large field, crop rows would move over time if you were using them as a visual reference, and it could be non-obvious which row you are in from visual features alone. The bigger problem is that computer vision is hard and expensive, while doing differential GPS is less expensive and much easier. I made our robot fully autonomous for development using only differential GPS, and we are working now on adding a vision system. A couple of GPS receivers and some very simple code is just easier to manage.
- carapace 4y agoHey, I just got some land in N. California and I was wondering about building a robot like yours to work it. It looks like I might not be able to get up there personally for a bit (family obligations) so a tele-operated robot might be the way to go. (Also, I'm a hobbyist robot maker, so... yeah. Robots!) - - - - edit to add: I just saw your comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35637541 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35637541 and yeah we are on the same page. Let's do this thing. The land I just got is for a mutual-benefit non-profit corp I started (Ariadne Systems) to do pretty much exactly what you describe! > ...you can ensure that everyone gets fed etc without paying for it by building an economy where everyone is part owner of the productive machinery they depend upon. Then no one is poor. Creating an economy where a preponderance of the firms are cooperatives is a good start. So this can be done in a traditionally libertarian way, without high taxes or strong government intervention. The corp I started is just such a cooperative firm (well, it will be once I find some people to cooperate with, eh?) to co-own the productive machinery and ecologically-harmoniously agriculturally-productive farm land, and provide goods and services (and eventually homes) to the members.
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoThat is so wonderful to hear! We’re working steadily towards a system that would be perfect for you! I suppose you have found this? https://community.twistedfields.com/t/join-the-solar-farming-revolution-support-acorn-and-empower-farmers-worldwide/370 https://community.twistedfields.com/t/join-the-solar-farming...
- carapace 4y agoOh wow. We are soooooo on the same page. I'll be in touch. Probably be one of your first customers, eh?
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoAwesome! We would love to have your support on Open Collective in the meantime!
- defrost 4y agoVisual surveying within and over Australia is hard (source: a few decades of Australian geophysical surveying practice) .. wide area ground shots from 80m altitude (low altitude aircraft) look extremely similar across large areas making feature picking for location improvement difficult. In an agricultural setting Western Australian grain fields are hundreds of acres in size across relatively flat landscapes .. it's a sea of waving grain to the horizon in all directions from tractor height. While there are locations that have distinct visual features it's no universal panecea and won't offer the cm accuracy desired.
- bluGill 4y agoHow will you handle this case (which while not common exists). Farmer goes in and buries irrigation pipes with underground emitters - these pipes are expected to last for 5 year or so (I don't know what the actual lifespan is - I know they are replaced every few years, but I don't know the actual schedule). Each season the farmer smooths the grounds, and plants each row exactly above the pipes in the ground. Can your visual navigation system figure out where those pipes are each year to within 2 cm? visual geographic features are going to change a lot over the years - the local ground is smoothed out every year, trees (if any) will grow or die, fence posts will be replaced...
- giantg2 4y agoAssuming equal spacing, you only need landmarks (survey spikes) on the first row. Then use the implement impressions from the first pass. But I see your point.