4 ms·
The topic has been beaten to death in the comments, but it comes down to sematics around success and goals. They didn't meet every goal hopeped for, but how mu
by s1artibartfast 4y ago
The topic has been beaten to death in the comments, but it comes down to sematics around success and goals.
They didn't meet every goal hopeped for, but how much or which constitutes sucess? This will be in the eye of the beholder. SpaceX said they would consider it sucessfull if it leaves the launch pad/site.
I might call it a failure because it didn't land a human on the moon, and it doesn't matter if that was not the expectation or intent of SpaceX today.
It is ultimately subjective. You might be happy with your life, but I might call it a falure. Is one of us right, both?
- stephc_int13 4y agoNah, it was programmed for stages separation and some flight before reentry, and also the return maneuver for the booster stage. The separation malfunctioned, that was not planned, this is not subjective. What is subjective is defining if this is a 25%, 50% or 90% success (can't be 100%).
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoSuccessful test, not a successful launch. Different metrics.
- baq 4y agoSuccess is defined by meeting objectives. Primary objective was to not blow up the vehicle on the pad. Great success here. Secondary objectives indeed aren’t met. I think everybody realizes by now that the big hole where the pad used to be is a bigger problem that it seemed initially. Any solutions are expensive and time consuming.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> everybody realizes by now that the big hole where the pad used to be is a bigger problem that it seemed initially I'm seeing a lot of speculation and little engineering on this. Is there a good post hoc take on why it's a big problem? Counterfactuals: it wasn't a production pad. It was designed to be expendable. That's why you don't put a bunch of expensive kit like deluge equipment on and around it; there's a meaningful chance you never clear the tower.
- baq 4y agoThe problem isn’t that it didn’t survive, the problem is the style it went out with: how much of it didn’t survive, how far the rocks were flung (far!), how far dust settled (very far!) and the amount of engineering needed to build a flame diverter which can be called any sort of reusable. Also the amount of fresh water needed for the deluge will be simply epic.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoSo you seem to be defining "success" in terms of completing pre-planned flight events, which is fine. However, this is not the only metric by which one can define and assess success. Surely you must agree it depends on the objective. We might as well be arguing over if the launch was "good" or "bad", -it is subjective. One objective question you can ask is "Did the test complete the pre-specified criteria which SpaceX said they would consider a success?", which it did. We could then debate if they have a dumb criteria for Success, and what we think is a better one.