2 ms·
> For instance, the two sets {1,2,3,4} and {A,B,C} are such that none is equal to a proper subset of the other. Are you suggesting these be treated as "the same
by cubefox 4y ago
> For instance, the two sets {1,2,3,4} and {A,B,C} are such that none is equal to a proper subset of the other. Are you suggesting these be treated as "the same size as" one another?
No. The paradox is that intuitively
1. If there is bijection between F and G, they are the same size.
2. If F is a proper subset of G, F and G are not the same size.
For finite numbers, these principles are compatible, but for infinities, it can happen that they contradict each other.
- ComplexSystems 4y agoOk. So are you suggesting a notion of "size" such that A is a smaller "size" than B if and only if A is extensionally equal to a proper subset of B? This would lead to a partial order on all sets. As a result, the perfect squares would smaller than the naturals, but also it would make many sets incomparable in size, including the natural numbers and the set {A}. Or if this is not what you are suggesting, what are you suggesting?
- cubefox 4y agoI find Galileo's conclusion plausible that neither principle holds for infinite sets.