4 ms·
I'm not american and I don't like this ruling. Google shouldn't be responsible for censoring the internet. If there is a site out there then Google should be al
by account42 4y ago
I'm not american and I don't like this ruling. Google shouldn't be responsible for censoring the internet. If there is a site out there then Google should be allowed to link to it.
- mdrzn 4y agoYour argument seems to be that Google should not be held responsible for removing links from their platform, regardless of their content. However, it is important to consider the potential harm caused by certain links, such as revenge pornography, which can be extremely damaging to individuals. Should Google be allowed to link to such content? If you are against the ruling in this case, are you also opposed to DMCA takedowns?
- perihelions 4y ago- "If you are against the ruling in this case, are you also opposed to DMCA takedowns?" Yes, and yes; and triply-yes if it's a DMCA theory that alleges that linking to a page containing allegedly infringing material also constitutes infringement.
- randomdata 4y ago> it is important to consider the potential harm caused by certain links, such as revenge pornography, which can be extremely damaging to individuals. Information does not cause damage, people do. Surely the onus must be on the people who use the information to cause damage? For example, those in the article who chose to not do business with the Montrealer because of the invalid information they leveraged. They caused the damage claimed in court. Why is Google responsible for their poor judgement? > are you also opposed to DMCA takedowns? If you stand by takedowns, why prefer removal of a link over the source material? Surely once the actual content goes away so too will the link? If the content is still out there, it will still be found, if not by Google, by some other means.
- mdrzn 4y agoIt's important to recognize the role that platforms like Google can play in facilitating that harm. What if the website containing harmful content is hosted on a Russian server that ignores DMCA takedowns and there is no way to remove it? What if the majority of traffic to that website comes from Google, should Google not take any responsibility for promoting that content? Or should Google take proactive measures to prevent harm, even if they are not the source of the content?
- randomdata 4y ago> Or should Google take proactive measures to prevent harm Meaning, should Google babysit people with occasional poor judgement? After all, if people always acted rationally with a clear head information would be completely innocuous. But, indeed, there will always be some crazies out there. In a similar vein, does a hammer manufacturer have the responsibility to babysit the occasional person who will use a hammer to bludgeon another to death? I say no. The is no intent by the manufacturer to see bludgeoning carried out. If the user of a tool uses poor judgement, that's on them. We don't go after the Ford Motor Company every time someone gets a speeding ticket while driving a Ford, so what is special about Google?
- danaris 4y ago> Meaning, should Google babysit people with occasional poor judgement? How does person X defaming person Y indicate that person Y has poor judgement? Do you think that no one ever posts lies on the internet?
- randomdata 4y agoI'm not sure I follow. We are talking about the party who caused the harm. The harm isn't caused when a lie is posted on the internet. The harm isn't caused when the lie is repeated on the internet. The lie itself can cause no harm. It is just information, and information cannot harm. Irrational people can, and do, reach for a lie and, out of poor judgement, create harm. But the poor judgement is the problem, not the lie, hammer, or car. The latter three do not act. If people were infallible the existence of the lie would mean nothing as it could not possibly lead to harm. Of course, people are not infallible and harm will be created. The onus being placed on the party causing harm, not those who made commonly used tools available to the party at fault is recognized everywhere else. What is special about Google?
- boring_twenties 4y agoEvery reasonable person should be opposed to DMCA takedowns, they are not only stupid in the first place, but actually massively abused.
- Retric 4y agoIt’s not about should Google police the internet, but instead should they follow the laws of the countries they are operating in. If Google failed to follow a DMCA takedown request on YouTube videos you bet they would get into legal trouble in the US, why should things be different if a different country is involved. Google didn’t need to identify the link that needed to be removed, they where ordered to remove it and then restored it.
- Eric_WVGG 4y agoGoogle isn’t able to censor the Internet. They could remove all links to anything Microsoft, MS would still be on the Internet. If you truly believe that delisting someone is “censoring the Internet” then they’re also censoring me when they don’t list my homepage on queries for “very cool dudes.”
- hiatus 4y agoTake it a step further. If your DNS is seized, your site is still accessible as it would still be on the internet. It's pretty similar to deleting a link to your site as only previous users with the IP could access it, much the same like users navigating directly to microsoft.com if Google removed all links in search. Is DNS seizure censorship? I'm not equating the two, but I want to understand your view that deleting or restricting information is not censorship.
- Eric_WVGG 4y agoI would say yes, but it sort of depends on how. If it was the gov't directing a registrar to seize a domain name, that's pretty clearly a violation of the first amendment. If a registrar seized a domain name, that wouldn't be a first amendment per se, but it would probably be a breach of contract and should be illegal one way or another. And then there's some grey areas with copyright that I think have been hammered out in courts… IANAL
- dahwolf 4y agoFalse, they should be responsible and they already are. Google does not link to pirated content. If and when they do, they take it down when it's reported. As they are legally required to do. Google may remove personal information as part of the "right to forget" EU directive. Death threats. Calls to violence. Revenge porn. As they are legally required to do. Google will remove CP/underage harmful content as they are legally required to do. Google may take down insults to the king, gambling sites, drug traffic sites, and all kinds of local legislation. Besides strictly illegal content, Google also censures content that might be technically legal yet considered distasteful or widely recognized as harmful: porn, terrorist propaganda, gore, etc. Google is not above the law, it can't do whatever it wants. Should it censor your political speech? No. But that's not what this is about.
- icegreentea2 4y agoYou may want Google to not be responsible for censoring the internet, and you might not like a Canadian court telling what Google to do on google.ca, but this is what Google has to say: https://www.blog.google/products/search/when-and-why-we-remove-content-google-search-results/ https://www.blog.google/products/search/when-and-why-we-remo... Quoting: > For many issues, such as privacy or defamation, our legal obligations may vary country by country, as different jurisdictions have come to different conclusions about how to deal with these complex topics. > Beyond removing content as required by law, we also have a set of policies that go beyond what’s legally required, mostly focused on highly personal content appearing on the open web.
- bacchusracine 4y ago>Google shouldn't be responsible for censoring the internet. Then maybe they shouldn't have started doing so to begin with? As the joke goes, 'we've settled that, now we're negotiating on price.' This is nothing more than an acknowledgement of what has already been happening.