4 ms·
Avoiding food waste confusion
- jl6 4y ago> The shift in our industrial systems to climate resilience is a huge opportunity. It creates efficiencies and shifts our focus away from dead-end consumption. Counterpoint: efficiency and resiliency are usually tradeoffs. A perfectly efficient food supply system has no wastage, but also no buffers or contingency or reserves. By all means, end the most egregious food waste scenarios (buffet restaurants spring to mind), but given how critical food is to human survival, let’s not optimize ourselves into a corner.
- simple-thoughts 4y agoIt’s posts like these that show the fallacious thinking behind most climate change policy. He’s taking the position of an overbearing parent telling the child to clean their plate, then explaining that it’s not enough “we need to do more.” No mentions of the relative climate impacts of food wastage. No mentions of the economic drivers behind food wastage - obviously producers would rather sell food than waste it and have a strong profit incentive. So food wastage must be caused by either subsidies (necessary for security reasons) or production ones (for instance it may be that processes creating some amount of spoilage consume fewer resources - and even less greenhouse gases- than ones that don’t). I cannot take the author seriously.
- morsch 4y agoIt's 8-10% of global emissions, so pretty significant - even a tenth of that is a lot. And relatively little food is wasted during production (though it's the part with the most uncertainty), most food is lost at the end of the chain, with the consumer. At least in Germany, and probably other wealthy countries. Why? Why not, food is cheap, though not as dirt cheap as it used to be. Germans spend about a tenth of their income on food, Africans 70%. There's little incentive for people here not to waste it beyond moral obligations. https://food.ec.europa.eu/horizontal-topics/farm-fork-strategy/food-loss-and-waste-prevention_en https://food.ec.europa.eu/horizontal-topics/farm-fork-strate...
- grvdrm 4y ago> Clean your plate? An anecdote that I'm sure some here know well: you serve food of any amount to your kids and they eat some? Maybe a bite? Sometimes nothing. It's not clear why. So as a parent, you get used to gathering up that food and eating much of what's left as a way of reducing waste, but also maybe you're hungry too. Welcome to every evening in my house! > The cultural dynamic in many places of serving more food than your guests can possibly eat–as a form of status or generosity–is persistent and wasteful. But it’s just a small part of a system that needs fixing. I'm curious. How often do folks get served much more than they can eat? I rarely get served plates of food that overwhelm me at first glance. Maybe I have a big appetite. Instead, is this issue better phrased as "ordering or asking for more than you can eat" - that's what I see happen all the time.
- Swizec 4y ago> How often do folks get served much more than they can eat? In Slovenia it is customary to feed guests until they can physically eat no more. Saying you’re full is met with “Oh but there's so much more! Eat eat. How about another X? Maybe a Z?”. You then have to sit back, grab your belly, look up with a sigh, and say “I’m so full I could burst”. This satisfies the social custom and the host can stop encouraging you to eat more. Then the dessert comes out. edit: I believe this is common in societies with a history of recent-ish food insecurity. You see Chinese and Spanish people doing similar. Large family feasts with a focus on the host showing off that they can not only feed everyone, but have food left over even after everyone’s full. As opposed to, say, France where the food is much less abundant and the custom is that you clean your plate and that’s it. Having my French girlfriend meet my Slovenian grandparents was very entertaining. They kept feeding her and she kept cleaning the plate and it was like a battle of who gives up first. I almost died laughing
- WrtCdEvrydy 4y ago> Having my French girlfriend meet my Slovenian grandparents was very entertaining. They kept feeding her and she kept cleaning the plate and it was like a battle of who gives up first. I almost died laughing South Korean Professor invites 4 hispanics PhD students to his house. His wife keeps putting food on our plate, we keep slamming it down. It's a great disrespect to leave anything on the plate... while it's a great disrespect to get an empty plate (it means you didn't feed your guests). I had to pull him aside and be like "get her to stop, please"
- fortran77 4y ago60% of Americans are obsese or overweight. People who consume more resources than they need seems like a large source of unnecessary carbon emissions. (Plus the extra energy it takes to transport overweight or obese people, to heat and cool them, extra material for clothing, etc.)
- ravenstine 4y agoObesity doesn't have as much to do with overeating as many think. It's an illness that results from the human body responding hormonally to the forms of mass it's taking in. Consume lots of carbohydrates, and especially carbs and fats at the same time, and you put yourself at risk of obesity. If climate change encourages us to collectively move away from the Standard Western Diet, I'd be all for it, however. Though that doesn't mean that an individual not being obese is any less impactful on the climate, necessarily. Obese people are in a condition where mass is sequestered substantially more than in those whose with a different hormone profile brought forth by food composition.
- arberx 4y ago> Obesity doesn't have as much to do with overeating as many think. uhm actually, it has everything to do with it. Calories in, calories out.
- tristor 4y ago> uhm actually, it has everything to do with it. Calories in, calories out. Uhm actually, CICO has two variables, and you and others only concentrate on the first one, when the research is pretty conclusive that hormonal changes affect the latter one. How do you think PCOS causes obesity and semaglutide helps with weight loss? How do you think stimulants help with weight loss, for that matter? The over-focus on the first variable is because it's the variable which individuals have the most self-control over (e.g. they can simply eat less). Even that is starting to be disproven, because hormonal shifts can drive hunger and hunger pangs are subconscious. That's why appetite suppressants are also an important way to treat obesity. So "uhm actually", it's not just the calories in that matter, it's also the calories out, and there are many factors you are dismissing to calories in.
- ravenstine 4y agoFood scraps are not a major driver of climate change. When climate activists enter the territory of putting carbon in the same category as lead and heavy metals, or any amount of carbon being bad, they lose me.
- morsch 4y ago8-10% of global emissions. https://food.ec.europa.eu/horizontal-topics/farm-fork-strategy/food-loss-and-waste-prevention_en https://food.ec.europa.eu/horizontal-topics/farm-fork-strate...
- throwaway22032 4y agoI don't understand people who go through life picking apart literally everything from the perspective of "climate impact". It feels like an eating disorder. Yes, everyone should manage their diet to a reasonable extent and be healthy. But just like anorexia, where nothing is enough and where the target is simply "the minimum possible/less than yesterday", it just seems obsessive and unhealthy.
- morsch 4y agoThey're the anorexics in societies mostly consisting of morbidly obese people. Figuratively, and often literally.
- chaostheory 4y agoEventually, all the droughts will make overall system efficiency higher due to the coming massively increased cost of water
- eternityforest 4y ago"Waste" is a confusing word. The climate impacts are on the production side. People talk about cleaning your plate to not waste food, but it's already wasted the moment you are served more than you need, and if you then eat it, you might be actively harming your health depending on the volume involved, and we all know that eating twice as much today won't make you half as hungry tomorrow. We mostly have refrigeration now. Leftovers can go in the fridge. Storing energy reserves is the fridges job, we don't need to store body fat for the winter as long as we've got food preservation. If you aren't hungry and have all your nutritional needs already met, any additional food served, eaten or not, is pretty much waste. And a lot of the food is pretty much always wasted, because it's as good as straight up poison.
- slothtrop 4y agoAgreed that waste is overwhelmingly owing to the supply chain, grocery stores for instance.
- morsch 4y agoThat's not really what they said. It's certainly not true for Germany, where 59% of food waste is generated at home, vs. 7% in grocery stores (and production 2%, food processing 15%, restaurants 17%). And it's probably not true for where you are. https://www.bmel.de/DE/themen/ernaehrung/lebensmittelverschwendung/studie-lebensmittelabfaelle-deutschland.html https://www.bmel.de/DE/themen/ernaehrung/lebensmittelverschw...
- slothtrop 4y ago"about one third of the edible food that is wasted globally comes before the farm gate and about one fifth comes from people’s plates and refrigerators. This means that just under half of all edible food that becomes waste does so during manufacturing, distribution and retail. " -- https://theconversation.com/enormous-amounts-of-food-are-wasted-during-manufacturing-heres-where-it-occurs-102310 https://theconversation.com/enormous-amounts-of-food-are-was... Good for Germany I guess. I'll take the 59% number at it's word.