5 ms·
Somebody please chip in an informed opinion on how much legal exposure a US entity has to EU litigation. Especially if said US entity doesn't really have any pa
by actionfromafar 4y ago
Somebody please chip in an informed opinion on how much legal exposure a US entity has to EU litigation. Especially if said US entity doesn't really have any paying EU customers.
- alpaca128 4y agoIANAL but the EU's GDPR also applies to companies providing services "even in the absence of commercial transactions"[0]. I've seen quite a few US news sites that simply refuse to show me any content. If the EU stays consistent with this stance - and the US sites refusing to deliver content aren't just being overly cautious - then I could see providing a download may already count as providing a service in the most pessimistic interpretation. [0] https://termly.io/resources/articles/gdpr-in-the-us/ https://termly.io/resources/articles/gdpr-in-the-us/
- harvey9 4y agoI'd like to think these things are treated differently. Browsing to a web page and getting cookied is different from actively choosing to run some software. Gets more complicated with web apps, but I'm personally willing to accept a disclaimer from sites and software I'm not directly paying for.
- RobotToaster 4y agoI've wondered, how enforceable is a EU court ruling on a company with no assets in the EU? If they can't enforce it, then does it matter if they fine you a centillion euros?
- traceroute66 4y ago> I've wondered, how enforceable is a EU court ruling on a company with no assets in the EU? Article 27 GDPR. If you are not established in the EU, you must designate, in writing, a representative in the EU: The representative shall be mandated by the controller or processor to be addressed in addition to or instead of the controller or the processor by, in particular, supervisory authorities and data subjects, on all issues related to processing, for the purposes of ensuring compliance with this Regulation.
- w4ffl35 4y agothis is a good point.
- tonyedgecombe 4y agoUntil you want to holiday in Europe.
- w4ffl35 4y agonever have never will. i strangely have no desire.
- em-bee 4y agothey can enforce it when you travel to the EU
- traceroute66 4y ago> Especially if said US entity doesn't really have any paying EU customers. Aah the good old US mentality, everything must revolve around money. :) My friend, "paying" doesn't come into it. It's all about PII, "Personally Identifiable Information". To paraphrase Dean Martin.... Got EU people on your mailing list ? That's GDPR. Silently harvesting telemetry, IP addresses, setting cookies etc. ? That's GDPR. etc. etc. etc.
- tzs 4y agoYou are correct that money doesn't enter into it (at least directly). The Dean Martin paraphrase however is not quit correct. Having EU people on your mailing list does not necessarily make you subject to GDPR. It depends on where you are, and possibly on your intent. The territorial rules for GDPR are: 1. It applies if you are in the Union, regardless of where the people on your mailing list are and regardless of whether processing their data takes place in the Union or not. 2. If you are not in the Union, GDPR applies to the processing of data of people in the Union where the processing activities are related to ... 2a. ... the offering of goods or services (regardless of whether payment is required or not) to people in the Union, or 2b. ... the monitoring of the behavior as far as their behavior takes place within the Union. Whether or not you are offering goods or services to people in the Union depends on whether you envisage to do so. The mere accessibility of your website from the Union is not sufficient. For example if you were running a mailing list for your small city's chess club and someone in the EU found your site and signed up, you probably would not have any GDPR obligations to them. If your chess club site also sold chess equipment that still probably wouldn't be enough unless you did something to indicate that you were actually trying to include EU. For example if your site had localization for all major EU languages, gave pricing in both dollars and Euros, and included VAT you would be covered by GDPR. But if the site is only in English (and maybe Spanish), gives pricing in dollars and only accepts dollars, only collects US sales taxes, only ships via USPS, and doesn't have anything that indicates you might be catering to EU people, you are probably in the clear.