4 ms·
To be honest, I don't like any of these "examples" at all because they attempt to map "intuitive" concepts, which are things like "size", "more than" and "fewer
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
To be honest, I don't like any of these "examples" at all because they attempt to map "intuitive" concepts, which are things like "size", "more than" and "fewer than" when applied to something that is finite, to something where that intuition doesn't even make sense in the infinite realm.
I mean, in your example, how can the first "infinite bus" ever empty in the first place to fill up the infinite hotel? After all, if it's an infinite bus, people will always keep streaming out of it. When you ask the guests to move from door x to 2x, that request never finishes, so you never are able to stop and then ask for guests from the other infinite bus to access the odd rooms.
What actually helped me understand the concept of the cardinality of infinite sets is to get rid of the whole notions of "size", "more than", "fewer than", etc. and instead just stick to the concept of mapping: is there a single, deterministic function that can output a unique value Y, where Y exists in some particular set, for every input value X, where X comes from another set.
Honestly, I think trying to use the same words like "size of" when talking about infinite sets was a mistake.
- hinkley 4y agoIf it breaks your brain less, you can think of it as the tour guide comes off bus 1 comes in and ask if there is enough room. The clerk says yes and the people start filing off the bus. Eventually they all will get a room. Then an hour later a second bus shows up and asks the same. Now the clerk isn’t sure. Of course you can’t have an infinite hotel. The construction time would be murder and you can only manage so many people so you have an infinite number of cleaning staff reporting to an infinite number of middle managers. And it takes you forever to do pay stubs. But that’s why it’s a thought experiment.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y ago> But that’s why it’s a thought experiment. My point is I think it's a bad thought experiment. In my opinion just using the actual "mapping" concept directly is much less confusing than clumsily reusing the definition of "size" and other concepts that are really irrelevant in an infinite world.
- yeellow 4y ago"I mean, in your example, how can the first "infinite bus" ever empty in the first place to fill up the infinite hotel?" This is easy, you need to shout at the people so each person leaves the bus twice as fast as the previous one. For example the frst person needs 1 minute to leave the bus, the second 0.5 minute, etc. In 2 minutes the bus is empty :)