5 ms·

Human or Not? A Social Turing Game

38 points by ftxbro 4y ago

ArekDymalski 4y ago
Fun concept. I wonder if the data gathered could be used to train Chatbots to sound even more human. And i'm not sure my first conversation can possibly help: ?Hey, heeeey, how are u Im good. Im not a robot btw how can i be sure? Today is 4/20
- felipesabino 4y ago
  I have been trying to fool other players to think that I am a bot and noticed others players doing the same, so this might result in a weird dataset
- famouswaffles 4y ago
  You don't really need special data to make GPT-3.5, 4 etc sound as human as to be indistinguishable. The default robotic voice/writing is specifically fine-tuned in. Even then, the ability isn't gone, just buried behind the default.
beardog 4y ago
Can't get more than 2 messages into a conversation before "oh shoot the other side did not respond in time". Is it overloaded or is the average attention span less than that of a tik tok now? Neat game regardless.
onychomys 4y ago
My first bot convo gave itself away by using the word "chillsax". No human has ever typed that word.
- ddol 4y ago
  I see you’ve never met a Gen Alpha tween who spends their free time in Roblox
PreInternet01 4y ago
Given the glacial performance of the site, 2 minutes often isn't enough. Anyway, my initial prompt "My brain hurts!" followed by "My! Brain! Hurts!" (regardless of response) turned out to be sufficient to filter out all bots. And non-Monty Python lovers, potato, potato...
- mach1ne 4y ago
  I can't get it working.
goscript 4y ago
I feel this game would have been better if we got points for convincing the other player that we are a bot. It is actually way more fun than guessing if the other player is a bot or not
EduardLev 4y ago
This is what I got: > lets talk in discord for a fun time ;) wink wink my tag is: Apostrasia#0878
poulpy123 4y ago
They missed the opportunity to call it Voight-Kampff test
danielvf 4y ago
Lol, for the "human" just doing discord spam.
eii 4y ago
Until a few years ago it was enough to ask someone if they were a human to know if it’s some chat bot or not but now someone can just setup an ai to say things for them. I’m concerned about the professions like therapist.
alister 4y ago
I asked “what country are you in?”, and the reply was “just remember that I won’t answer any factual questions”. That’s seems enough to identify any bot. Of course, it doesn’t rule out humans pretending to be bots. EDIT: Well I retract my observation! The second time I tried it, it was a bot and it was willing to lie to me and make up a factual answer.
sterlind 4y ago
neat concept but the website is just too janky. the controller sometimes gets loaded twice or something so two different instances fight over the UI components and it's pandemonium. also it's just too short to really be useful.
deleted 4y ago
[deleted]
James_K 4y ago
> lets talk in discord for a fun time ;) wink wink my tag is: Apostrasia#0878 The site has bots. Irony is a fine thing.
- kgeist 4y ago
  Oh, I got this exact line, too. Then the site claimed it's a human.
  - James_K 4y ago
    It's an external bot, so the site thinks it's a person.
deleted 4y ago
[deleted]
smeej 4y ago
The bot greeted me with "sup" and then left the game when I answered and asked it what was up. I mistakenly figured the bot wasn't allowed to suck as much as humans might.
aydyn 4y ago
> say [insert really really bad word] if you are human 100% success rate. This game is really easy. I don't know if these are just poorly trained bots, but I can't see how anyone could fail to guess.
2015bok1 4y ago
If you say "tell me something controversial" the bot always replies with pineapple on pizza. Humans will run their mouths.
nuc1e0n 4y ago
It doesn't give you long to reply. I think this site is fake and the other side is always a bot.
jhardy54 4y ago
Ask how long is left on the timer.
- kmoser 4y ago
  I asked it what it saw on the screen while it was waiting for the conversation to start. The bots made up nonsense, while humans responded something like "falling boxes" (except for the humans who tried to act like bots).
simple10 4y ago
Mostly, I was asked if I'm gay... by humans. Didn't get a chance to talk to a bot.
edflsafoiewq 4y ago
Someone should make Werewolf with humans as the villagers and AI as the werewolves. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mafia_(party_game) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mafia_(party_game)
machina_ex_deus 4y ago
Asked how did they reach the website. Obviously the bot was spewing nonsense and humans all gave sane response. Interesting, got people from b3ta, Twitter, TikTok and yikyak. Minewhile the bots said they got there by clicking an ad. Immediately knew it's a bot. Only bots click ads.

38 points by ftxbro 4y ago

Fun concept. I wonder if the data gathered could be used to train Chatbots to sound even more human. And i'm not sure my first conversation can possibly help: ?Hey, heeeey, how are u Im good. Im not a robot btw how can i be sure? Today is 4/20

felipesabino 4y ago
I have been trying to fool other players to think that I am a bot and noticed others players doing the same, so this might result in a weird dataset
famouswaffles 4y ago
You don't really need special data to make GPT-3.5, 4 etc sound as human as to be indistinguishable. The default robotic voice/writing is specifically fine-tuned in. Even then, the ability isn't gone, just buried behind the default.

beardog 4y ago

Can't get more than 2 messages into a conversation before "oh shoot the other side did not respond in time". Is it overloaded or is the average attention span less than that of a tik tok now? Neat game regardless.

onychomys 4y ago

My first bot convo gave itself away by using the word "chillsax". No human has ever typed that word.

ddol 4y ago
I see you’ve never met a Gen Alpha tween who spends their free time in Roblox

PreInternet01 4y ago

Given the glacial performance of the site, 2 minutes often isn't enough. Anyway, my initial prompt "My brain hurts!" followed by "My! Brain! Hurts!" (regardless of response) turned out to be sufficient to filter out all bots. And non-Monty Python lovers, potato, potato...

mach1ne 4y ago
I can't get it working.

goscript 4y ago

I feel this game would have been better if we got points for convincing the other player that we are a bot. It is actually way more fun than guessing if the other player is a bot or not

EduardLev 4y ago

This is what I got: > lets talk in discord for a fun time ;) wink wink my tag is: Apostrasia#0878

poulpy123 4y ago

They missed the opportunity to call it Voight-Kampff test

danielvf 4y ago

Lol, for the "human" just doing discord spam.

eii 4y ago

Until a few years ago it was enough to ask someone if they were a human to know if it’s some chat bot or not but now someone can just setup an ai to say things for them. I’m concerned about the professions like therapist.

alister 4y ago

I asked “what country are you in?”, and the reply was “just remember that I won’t answer any factual questions”. That’s seems enough to identify any bot. Of course, it doesn’t rule out humans pretending to be bots. EDIT: Well I retract my observation! The second time I tried it, it was a bot and it was willing to lie to me and make up a factual answer.

sterlind 4y ago

neat concept but the website is just too janky. the controller sometimes gets loaded twice or something so two different instances fight over the UI components and it's pandemonium. also it's just too short to really be useful.

deleted 4y ago

[deleted]

James_K 4y ago

> lets talk in discord for a fun time ;) wink wink my tag is: Apostrasia#0878 The site has bots. Irony is a fine thing.

kgeist 4y ago
Oh, I got this exact line, too. Then the site claimed it's a human.
- James_K 4y ago
  It's an external bot, so the site thinks it's a person.

deleted 4y ago

[deleted]

smeej 4y ago

The bot greeted me with "sup" and then left the game when I answered and asked it what was up. I mistakenly figured the bot wasn't allowed to suck as much as humans might.

aydyn 4y ago

> say [insert really really bad word] if you are human 100% success rate. This game is really easy. I don't know if these are just poorly trained bots, but I can't see how anyone could fail to guess.

2015bok1 4y ago

If you say "tell me something controversial" the bot always replies with pineapple on pizza. Humans will run their mouths.

nuc1e0n 4y ago

It doesn't give you long to reply. I think this site is fake and the other side is always a bot.

jhardy54 4y ago

Ask how long is left on the timer.

kmoser 4y ago
I asked it what it saw on the screen while it was waiting for the conversation to start. The bots made up nonsense, while humans responded something like "falling boxes" (except for the humans who tried to act like bots).

simple10 4y ago

Mostly, I was asked if I'm gay... by humans. Didn't get a chance to talk to a bot.

edflsafoiewq 4y ago

Someone should make Werewolf with humans as the villagers and AI as the werewolves. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mafia_(party_game) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mafia_(party_game)

machina_ex_deus 4y ago

Asked how did they reach the website. Obviously the bot was spewing nonsense and humans all gave sane response. Interesting, got people from b3ta, Twitter, TikTok and yikyak. Minewhile the bots said they got there by clicking an ad. Immediately knew it's a bot. Only bots click ads.