2 ms·
A definition like "F and G are the same size if there is a one-to-one correspondence, except when F is a proper subset of G, then F is smaller" wouldn't work, b
by cubefox 4y ago
A definition like "F and G are the same size if there is a one-to-one correspondence, except when F is a proper subset of G, then F is smaller" wouldn't work, because that isn't an equivalence relation. While "is the same size" seems in fact to be such an equivalence relation. For example, there might be a set H, such that H would be "the same size as" F and as G (due to one-to-one correspondence), but F would be smaller than G (due to proper subsethood). This would violate transitivity.
- dllthomas 4y agoI'm not saying there's a definition that works down that path (I don't know); I'm saying that "we only have multiple infinities because of this definition, which people objected to because it didn't give us enough infinities" seems a little muddled.
- cubefox 4y agoThe argument seems to be rather that intuitions for size and subsethood and bijection aren't compatible anymore, which is a reductio argument against assuming that size comparisons make any sense for infinities at all.