4 ms·
Endless cheap entertainment for the masses is IMHO one of the best outcomes of AI; it's a field where minor mistakes are tolerable (or even add to the entertain
by userbinator 4y ago
Endless cheap entertainment for the masses is IMHO one of the best outcomes of AI; it's a field where minor mistakes are tolerable (or even add to the entertainment value), as opposed to using AI for the more critical decisions of society. On the other hand, it may also make real human interaction far more valuable.
- 52-6F-62 4y ago“Endless cheap entertainment”… How depressing that’s sounds. Kind of like cheap cattle feed or something. Are you only here to be entertained? I’d like to contribute that music is not just entertainment. One of the best, and accessible, books on the subject was recently The Philosophy of Modern Song by Bob Dylan. What ever happened to automating the boring things? Instead we’re hearing thousands of software developers celebrating what they perceive as the end of art (it’s not, sorry, just mass noise being injected into human communication). If only it was done with a little more discourse and less blind superiority then we might have something to talk about. This is the saddest trend in some time. Let’s go back to automating our taxes. Leave playing and writing music for all the time we create for ourselves instead. That was once the promise.
- HDThoreaun 4y ago> Are you only here to be entertained? Personally, yes. I'm counting down the days until we have the movie from Infinite Jest.
- 1attice 4y ago'The Entertainment' from IJ is approximately as powerful as one FB-installed smartphone. We've been past that for more than a decade. And yes, absolutely, I know people who would cut off parts of themselves (or others) to get to their phone, after a period of deprivation.
- somedude895 4y ago> How depressing that’s sounds. Kind of like cheap cattle feed or something. Are you only here to be entertained? GP said "for the masses." Popular media is just that: Cattle feed. It doesn't really matter if the next Marvel movie or the next Drake song is AI generated as long as it has its intended effect.
- 52-6F-62 4y ago"The masses"— and what separate you or them from "the masses"? Do we need unrestrained, automated more of that? Or should we leave art to do what it does best: nurture the soul and wake people from their sedated dream-like lives and into lives more conscious and more fully-lived? Drowning art in noise is going to have resounding effects on society. Cutting people off even further from their own souls is heinous. Doing so wittingly is nothing short of evil.
- cageface 4y agoIn a world where you have all the musical masterpieces of history available to you with one tap why would you waste time listening to algorithmically generated mediocrity?
- pjc50 4y agoIn a world where you can have algorithmically generated personally targeted stuff fed to you, why would you bother with the past? Why not instead live in an eternal ephemeral present? (same idea as https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35632879 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35632879 )
- Infinitesimus 4y agoHa, there is no music that eveyrone agrees is a masterpiece already. People will what their ears like regardless of someone's opinion of the "quality". AI increasing the music in the world and lowering the bar to creation will mean it can both generate music specific to a few people's tastes and guaranteed top 100 hits in some regions. Much like many human artists can do today.
- thanatropism 4y agoTastes vary, but the best music that exists is invariably an "acquired taste". In other words: it takes listening to a lot of good music to be able to appreciate good music.
- imgabe 4y agoSometimes you just want infinitely variable background noise while you're focusing on something else.
- jxramos 4y agovery interesting intersection there, the unrepeatable song, like AI riffing never to be heard again. Pulling the digital into the realm of the ephemeral, almost like a live performance. What a combination of thoughts married up there.
- nextworddev 4y agoNot sure if it's a good thing in the sense that it will lead us straight into the Matrix and trap us in it
- crabkin 4y agowe've been in the matrix since at least the time of the ancient Egyptians/Mesopotamia
- Syonyk 4y agoHow are you defining "in the matrix" such that it applies for the past couple thousand years of recorded human history? That seems rather at odds with how I would define it, "The computers create a customized compelling reality for each person to keep them from considering anything interesting."
- crabkin 4y agoSociety, culture, this hierarchal and quasi-performative game we play, where we take on roles and portend certain things which cycle on and off, is a matrix. Any situation I would think where there is a center and then merchants and then banks and then institutions suddenly starts by the constellation of these things generating a thing we call reality, a thing we call time. I sound schizo, but I am speaking about something I am not parroting, it is a realization. Try living in the desert for a few days or the some wilderness in general and then come back to suburbs and the city.
- joquarky 4y agoI agree with your perspective on our social/cultural "matrix". It's amazing how much we take for granted and how deeply ingrained these constructs are in our everyday lives. I used to gloss over the words representing "constructs" as I had used in my last sentence. I finally groked what was being referred to while listening to some lectures by Alan Watts during my recent sabbatical from burnout. He was able to explain the differences between eastern and western philosophy in a way that made me see things in a completely different light. It was like waking up from the matrix. Since then, I've been constantly aware of the constructed nature of reality and have had to re-evaluate many of my assumptions. For example, just learning that words are just abstractions and don't always accurately reflect reality was something I had never considered before. Now I try to be more careful with my word selection, but nobody's prefect :)
- beachy 4y agoAgreed, AI will indeed shine in situations where mistakes are tolerable and entertainment is a huge area like this. For example, currently playing a golf simulator is a little like the movie 28 days later. The simulation is amazing, but the vibe is an empty barren world. AI could generate crowd chatter and interaction, just as if one was playing in front of a real crowd of opiniated, semi-informed and possible semi-drunk patrons.
- fijiaarone 4y agoHappy Gilmore AI?
- p1necone 4y agoOne think I'd love to be able to do is revive dead MMOs locally. Imagine running a server for Ultima Online or Everquest or something locally, and having a bunch of AI players that act like humans, can group up for group content, make their own guilds etc. You can rope friends in too, but it would be amazing to only need a couple of friends to play with but still feel like the whole world was populated.
- edrxty 4y agoI really miss the golden age of MMOs, this would be truly amazing. What would be used as the training set though? All that player input is long gone.
- astrange 4y agoWhat happens if you power the NPCs with Bing Sydney and it gives them all depression?
- soganess 4y agoI know you are "kidding", but that seems like it would be a one of a kind experience I'd be interest in trying. The space of possible interesting videogame experiences, even involving old videogames, just expanded.
- astrange 4y agoI wasn't really kidding. I think if you wrote the characters' instructions wrong like "I'm trapped in a video game" it'd be easy to get strange and dark responses. Or even "don't leave the town or you'll be attacked by bears" or "your job is to stand in this building and let the player character shoot you with a gun".
- thewizardofaus 4y agoThis concept does already exist to a certain degree. Single Player Project (SPP) for World of Warcraft is one example.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- m463 4y ago> Endless cheap entertainment for the masses I wonder if article titles will never again be factual or even correlate with the article text
- InCityDreams 4y ago>On the other hand, it may also make real human interaction far more valuable. Not at Ticketmaster prices.
- Gigachad 4y agoImagine playing the Skyrim equivalent in 10 years and the tavern music guy makes up a new song on the spot based on your gameplay or interactions. Future if entertainment is going to be wild.
- em-bee 4y agorelated, i am looking forward to improvements in procedurally generated worlds