3 ms·
Correct...except that there are the same number of points on a line as in a plane. Aleph_0^2 = Aleph_0 Aleph_1^2 = Aleph_1
by paulddraper 4y ago
Correct...except that there are the same number of points on a line as in a plane.
Aleph_0^2 = Aleph_0
Aleph_1^2 = Aleph_1
- yarg 4y agoHow though (genuine question)? I can see space filling curves through I^I, but I can't see them covering R^I. How does a space-filling curve cover a plane without being filled with infinitesimal discontinuities?
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agoHilbert curves
- yarg 4y agoYes, I've got that part - but that only gets me as far as R * I ^ (d - 1), not R ^ d. (d being the dimensionality of the curve.) As I think about this there's an unfilled infinitesimal R ^ (d - 1) space orthogonal to every point on the curve. I don't see how it is that that does not manifest as discontinuities in the filled space.
- Skeime 4y agoYou can get from R^d to I^d (with I the open unit interval) easily by applying x -> (arctan(x) + pi/2)/pi and y -> tan(pi * y - pi/2) to each coordinate. There are also ways to go from R to the closed unit interval. You can then combine this with space-filling curves for I^d.
- yarg 4y agoYou can even go from R to I^d. The problem that I'm having is in getting from R to R^d, which I still don't think is possible - look at the comment where I mention "surjections" and "bijections".
- Skeime 4y agoBy applying the map from I^d to R^d (using the tan-arctan-construction above in each coordinate) after the map from R to R^d, you get a map from R to R^d.
- ginnungagap 4y agoWhether |R|=aleph_1 is independent of ZFC (but of course there are bijections both between R and R^2 and between aleph_1 and aleph_1^2, or between X and X^2 for any infinite set)
- yarg 4y agohttps://mathoverflow.net/questions/126069/bijection-from-mathbbr-to-mathbbr2 https://mathoverflow.net/questions/126069/bijection-from-mat... https://mathoverflow.net/questions/240249/continuous-map-from-mathbb-r2-to-mathbb-r https://mathoverflow.net/questions/240249/continuous-map-fro... https://mathoverflow.net/questions/34232/injective-maps-mathbbrn-to-mathbbrm https://mathoverflow.net/questions/34232/injective-maps-math... The second link says that there's a continuous surjection from R -> R^2, but no such bijection. (Which, after some googling looks in line with what I was imagining.) If there's no bijection, how can the cardinalities be the same?
- ginnungagap 4y agoFirst of all the first link explicitely constructs (in a very strong sense) an explicit bijection R->R^2 so I don't know how why you seem to think otherwise. It is true that there is no continuous bijection R -> R^2. It is also true that this has nothing to with cardinality, which is only about the existence of bijections (and indeed is defined for arbitrary sets with no topological structure for which continuity makes no sense)
- yarg 4y agoI don't think that it's actually formulating a bijection across the reals - the generator function looks to me to be generating the complete set of rationals. > Represent each real number x∈[0,1) as a sequence of DIGITS, where each DIGIT is either in {0,…,8} or is of the form 10∗(10k−1)+i with k≥1 and i∈{0,…,8} (i.e., in {90,…,98;990,…,998;9990,…,9998;…}. He's iterating to infinity, that sure as shit sounds countable to me. Anyway, the conclusion that I've come to is that you can map R onto a subset of R^n such that for all values {r[1] ... r[n]} in R^n there is a value in the R -> R^n mapping within all finite bounds. So as long as you stay away from infinitesimals (not all of them), the domains are equivalent. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infinitesimal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infinitesimal > In mathematics, an infinitesimal number is a quantity that is closer to zero than any standard real number, but that is not zero. But as far as I can tell, the reverse mapping has an R^(n - 1) orthogonal that is completely unaccounted for, within those finite bounds. (And breaking infinitesimals might cause some trouble for calculus.)