2 ms·
He said "just" a renaming, which suggests just the names change while the meaning stays the same, which isn't the case. Maybe he meant it in some different "HoT
by cubefox 4y ago
He said "just" a renaming, which suggests just the names change while the meaning stays the same, which isn't the case. Maybe he meant it in some different "HoTT" sense, but he clearly said
> Given that a one-to-one correspondence is just a renaming, and renaming things doesn't change how many there are, this seems sound.
which would only be the case for renaming salva veritate -- or by begging the question in favor of one-to-one correspondence being sufficient for something being the "same size" and against proper subsethood being sufficient for something being not the same size. But that's exactly the question when arguing for or against Hume's Principle, not something which can be assumed.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> He said "just" a renaming, which suggests just the names change while the meaning stays the same, which isn't the case. Huh? That's exactly what's happening. If you rename 1, 2, and 3 to one, two, and three, the names have changed and the meanings haven't. As you note, this is what "renaming" means. It used to be true that 1 + 2 = 3, but now that's gibberish and one + two = three instead. Nothing about that changes if you instead rename 1, 2, and 3 to 88, 89, and 90. It will still be true that 88 + 88 = 89. You don't get to reinterpret what the name means after you assign it.
- cubefox 4y agoWell, then the squares are still a proper subset of the natural numbers, while still being in a one-to-one correspondence, so Galileo's Paradox remains. Then renaming didn't change anything.