3 ms·
But how can there be more integers than the are even integers when for each and every even integer there exists a corresponding integer? And how can there be mo
by tsimionescu 4y ago
But how can there be more integers than the are even integers when for each and every even integer there exists a corresponding integer? And how can there be more rationals, when we can find an integer for every rational number?
You are thinking in terms of very large sets, but literally infinite sets are simply not the same as very large finite sets. And they are not even the same as the limits of cardinality N sets as N grows to infinity.
For example, if we take the set of all integers less than N and the set of all even integers less than N, we can show that no mapping can exist between the two, even as N grows to infinity - so, one is indeed larger than the other. And yet, a mapping appears if N is literally infinite.
- hinkley 4y agoThe problem with these discussions is some of the same problem we have in public discourse. One or both parties are using 2 definitions of the same word and trying to make them equivalent. Are there integers that do not exist in the set of all even integers? Yes. The set of all even integers is incomplete, with respect to the set of all integers. They unfortunately also have the same number of elements. So there are not 'more' elements in one set than the other, and yet there are elements missing from one of the sets. When we are assembling something and find that it's missing bits, we tend to compare it unfavorably to other things. It's 'less' than they are. But if you substitute other things to make up the difference, it's not less or more it's just different.