25 ms·
Building telescopes on the Moon could transform astronomy
- freeqaz 4y agoMan, this really excites me! I hadn't even thought about this before, but it seems super obvious now. Especially the bit in the article about putting a telescope at one of the poles inside of a crater (to shield from sunlight). I'm surprised this proposal hasn't been tried sooner. Is this because the cost per pound to send something into space has gotten cheaper? Why now?
- enlyth 4y agoAlso, Earth's sky will eventually get polluted by things like SpaceX satellites, so this would solve that issue as well.
- BurningFrog 4y agoPutting telescopes in higher orbits should handle most of that.
- oh_sigh 4y agoIf there were a million satellites(which there won't be), and they averaged 100 square meters each (which they don't), and they were all very close to earth in LEO(like starlink, which they aren't), they would take up 0.0000166% of the night sky. I think we will be okay.
- govolckurself 4y agoIt's not their size that's an issue. But astronomers have already voiced their concerns in great detail. It might be worth exploring the specifics.
- googlryas 4y agoSome astronomers have voiced their concerns. Others have voiced their lack of concern. It's not an open and shut issue, but I do suspect a lot of hubbub is about who is launching the satellites, not the fact that they are there.
- Rebelgecko 4y agoOnce Starlink builds up the capacity around the moon to handle all the new telescopes' data, won't they have the same problem?
- bryanlarsen 4y agoWe can maintain continuous internet connection from anywhere on the surface of the moon to Earth using 2 lunar satellites. Using more won't provide any advantages until its using a lot of bandwidth.
- Rebelgecko 4y agoHow would you do that? Land based (or whatever the term is for "terrestrial" on the moon) relays?
- Cyphase 4y agoGroundside.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- schiffern 4y ago>polluted by things like SpaceX satellites I know the media likes to hyper-focus on SpaceX, but it should be noted that Starlink is one of the best large constellations in this regard. SpaceX goes far above and beyond the (inadequate IMO) legal requirements for radio/IR/visible emanations, at substantial engineering expense to themselves. https://youtu.be/MNc5yCYth5E?t=1717 https://youtu.be/MNc5yCYth5E?t=1717 https://cps.iau.org/news/nsf-and-spacex-sign-agreement-to-mitigate-impact-of-starlink-satellites-on-ground-based-astronomy/ https://cps.iau.org/news/nsf-and-spacex-sign-agreement-to-mi... If you really want to get mad about badly-designed satellites impacting astronomy, look up AST SpaceMobile.
- Maursault 4y agoDiscussion began here 9 hours ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35627234 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35627234 Why is HN taking after reddit so much lately with duplicates?
- dabluecaboose 4y agoredditors fleeing the eternal september on their site and unintentionally causing one on HN
- double2helix 4y agoThe catch-22 is the influx of lunar traffic will create some noise interference on the "dark side" of the moon. Still less than that on earth though.
- jrussino 4y agoThis was my first thought when reading the article. > The lunar far side is permanently shielded from the radio signals generated by humans on Earth. During the lunar night, it is also protected from the Sun. These characteristics make it probably the most “radio-quiet” location in the whole solar system as no other planet or moon has a side that permanently faces away from the Earth. It is therefore ideally suited for radio astronomy. Maybe we need to treat this as a "pristine natural resource" and put some treaties in place now where we agree to limit how much we "pollute" this area with RF signals, before it's too late?
- joering2 4y agodefine "too late" ?
- samstave 4y agohttps://youtu.be/5drjr9PmTMA https://youtu.be/5drjr9PmTMA
- httpz 4y agoChina already has a rover on the far side of the moon so my hopes aren't high.
- DennisP 4y agoI don't think we're likely to build telescopes on the far side of the moon without sending some rovers there first.
- quickthrower2 4y agoMaybe have RF curfews, 6pm to 6am GMT every day.
- csours 4y agoNo mention of dust. The lunar astronauts complained about the stuff. There's some weird stuff due to electrical charges not being able to dissipate. I do hope we try it though, speaking from my inner 12 year old.
- psychphysic 4y agoThe charge that causes the issue can also be used to fix it https://science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2006/19apr_dustbuster https://science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2006/1... It would be pretty sweet to have a decent scope on the far side of the moon.
- Teever 4y agoI can't find it right now but I read a paper that said that even moderate exploration activity on the moon, let alone colonization and industrialization will kick up a moderate amount of dust that will linger for thousands of years. I don't know if this will affect moon based telescopes in a way that can't be mitigated tough.
- narag 4y agoSounds very weird. Without atmosphere the dust... just falls. No dust in the wind there, because no wind. And in the surface there is already plenty of it.
- wumms 4y agoNot supporting the "thousands of years" part of your parent's comment, but the moon gets hit by solar wind; "electrostatic charging caused the dust to levitate" [0]. Quote from "Moon Storms" [1]: "To everyone's surprise," says Olhoeft, "LEAM saw a large number of particles every morning, mostly coming from the east or west--rather than above or below--and mostly slower than speeds expected for lunar ejecta." What could cause this? Stubbs has an idea: "The dayside of the moon is positively charged; the nightside is negatively charged." At the interface between night and day, he explains, "electrostatically charged dust would be pushed across the terminator sideways," by horizontal electric fields. [0] "Moon Fountains" https://web.archive.org/web/20100319112529/http://science.nasa.gov/headlines/y2005/30mar_moonfountains.htm https://web.archive.org/web/20100319112529/http://science.na... [1] "Moon Storms" https://web.archive.org/web/20100106144102/http://science.nasa.gov/headlines/y2005/07dec_moonstorms.htm https://web.archive.org/web/20100106144102/http://science.na...
- hiccuphippo 4y agoWhat are the chances of meteorites being a threat? Without an atmosphere it is easier for them to reach the ground and cause damage.
- joering2 4y agoAs my understanding goes, Moon is very big and meteors are very small and aim/crash rarely. You can look at its surface and assume there is activity all the time but because of lack of atmosphere anything that touches the surface leaves footprints for thousands of years. Armstrong footprint is still there.
- cdot2 4y agoMore like millions of years
- lamontcg 4y agomore or less the same problem JWST or anything else in space faces.
- rkwasny 4y agoWhat? we have a telescope in L2 point(the second Lagrangian point)! it is soo much better there compared to the moon
- autokad 4y agoif we could manufacture the telescopes on the moon, we could build massive ones (and size matters). And, why not have both?
- post-it 4y agoCouldn't we manufacture more massive ones in orbit around the moon, since they won't collapse under their own weight? We'd need extra fuel to get resources or parts off the surface of the moon, but that's nothing in comparison to the fuel needed to get off the Earth. Edit: I forgot the moon has a much lower gravity than Earth. It might still be worthwhile to build in orbit, but we can build a lot bigger on the moon than on Earth.
- sandworm101 4y agoMoon orbits are very unstable. Maintaining anything so large there for an extended period would be difficult.
- shagie 4y ago(on the unstable lunar orbits...) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_orbit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_orbit > Gravitational anomalies slightly distorting the orbits of some Lunar Orbiters led to the discovery of mass concentrations (dubbed mascons) beneath the lunar surface caused by large impacting bodies at some remote time in the past. These anomalies are of sufficient magnitude to cause a lunar orbit to change significantly over the course of several days. They can cause a plumb bob to hang about a third of a degree off vertical, pointing toward the mascon, and increase the force of gravity by one-half percent. > ... > Study of the mascons' effect on lunar spacecraft led to the discovery in 2001 of "frozen orbits" occurring at four orbital inclinations: 27°, 50°, 76°, and 86°, in which a spacecraft can stay in a low orbit indefinitely. Consider that - there are only four inclinations where you an orbit the moon without needing to do constant adjustments. Whereas with the Earth basically all the inclinations are available. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frozen_orbit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frozen_orbit and https://science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2006/06nov_loworbit/ https://science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2006/0... for more on this.
- cyberax 4y ago[flagged]
- RajT88 4y agoThey should try boycotting NASA. They'll have similar results, and it'll be a lot less effort.
- kristianp 4y agoThey mention NASAs Artemis program, but the real enabler of larger payloads to the moon may be SpaceX Starship, not SLS, which is too expensive and can't be launched often enough to be used for any additional missions to those already scheduled.
- SECProto 4y ago> They mention NASAs Artemis program, but the real enabler of larger payloads to the moon may be SpaceX Starship, not SLS Note that the two aren't mutually exclusive: Artemis 3 uses [1] Starship as a major component, and it's likely that Starship will take over other parts of the works for the reason you note. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artemis_3 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artemis_3
- m3kw9 4y agoThey need some spaced based weapons when exploring the far side of the moon, you never know
- samstave 4y agototally stupid question: Could one theoretically point the hubble at the james webb mirrors and see anything?
- CalChris 4y agoNo. The JWST is about a million miles away from earth. It is only 6.5 meters wide. tan = 6.5 meters / 1M miles = 4.03891275 × 10-9 2.31×10^-7 degrees The Hubble can resolve 1/10th of an arc second or 2.78×10^-5 degrees So it's roughly 100 times too small for the Hubble to see.
- samstave 4y agothank you
- kristopolous 4y agoThere's more. The triangulations would provide some really great confirmation and precision on a number of things. The unanswered question is if this is blocked out from earth communication, what are you doing for earth communication? Moon satellites? Optical relays? Would it go to the Mars satellites? These things get booked so far ahead of time, you can probably pretty easily schedule the dark times when it couldn't talk to Mars especially if you send it up with modern storage tech. I guess there's also Venus satellites coming around soon as well.
- gumby 4y agoWhy not put relay satellites that orbit the moon? Actually I think this is already being planned anyway, unrelated to a telescope.
- pixl97 4y agoThe moon is insanely hard to orbit because it's gravity is very lumpy https://www.nasa.gov/feature/does-anything-orbit-the-moon-we-asked-a-nasa-technologist https://www.nasa.gov/feature/does-anything-orbit-the-moon-we...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- asdfman123 4y agoFor close orbits, and far orbits are difficult because Earth’s gravity interferes—-to save others a click.
- dylan604 4y agowhat about some sort of Lagrange point orbit rather than orbiting the moon itself?
- asdfman123 4y ago
- httpz 4y agoSo you're telling me instead of the fragile and complicated shield on the James Webb Telescope, we could've used the entire moon as a shield?
- asdfman123 4y agoAre you a software developer? If so, I’m sure you understand the perils of a solution that sounds easy.
- micromacrofoot 4y agomoons a much more dense target
- sega_sai 4y agoYou know that the other side of the moon gets exposed to the Sun, right?
- jjtheblunt 4y agoReally ignorant question: some comments mention huge telescopes: can a moon be used via gravitational lens-ing to effect a huge telescope?
- sandworm101 4y agoNo. The focal point would be so far away, as in way bigger that the moon's orbit, that the entire arrangement would be wildly impractical. Imagine hanging out around pluto's orbit while trying to aim at earths moon as it spins around the earth. Using the earth would be easier. Using jupiter would be easier. It is possible to build a refracting telescope in space that uses earths atmosphere as a lens. This is far more practical (ie smaller) than any gravity telescope.
- tadfisher 4y agoThe sun's focal point is 542 AU, about 11 times Pluto's orbit. It's safe to say we won't be using Jupiter or Earth as lenses anytime soon.
- sandworm101 4y agoNot as gravity lenses, but as both planets have atmospheres they can be used as refracting lenses at much shorter focal points at orbits, if using earth, just beyond the moon. https://www.science20.com/tommaso_dorigo/the_terrascope_using_earth_as_a_lens-240567 https://www.science20.com/tommaso_dorigo/the_terrascope_usin...
- flangola7 4y agoCould we start with Earth and scale up to the sun?
- tadfisher 4y agoThe lens effect from something less massive than a star is too weak. The Sun has a focal point 542 AU away from its center; our moon would have a focal point some orders of magnitude beyond that, and the angular resolution wouldn't be nearly as good. In short, it's far easier and more effective to use the Sun for this effect. Radio interferometry would be a better use for Moon-based observatories, if we felt like building several of them.
- supernova87a 4y agoI hate to say it (as someone formerly from this field), but -- Astronomers can justify any amount of spending you ask them to, based on whatever incremental learning a telescope of a new type can be built for, based on: -- size of telescope -- new sensors -- background noise reduction, sensitivity -- frequency domain, spectroscopic resolution -- it goes on and on Who provides the external check of whether the latest improvement is worth spending the money? Because astronomers will always say it's worth it on some dimension. How do we decide whether that dimension is worth the money? Is pushing the discovery of some metal content in an early galaxy by one more unit of redshift worth $10B? Study of dust obscuration of some nebula really pushing the boundaries of our understanding like it was 50 years ago? (or similar esoteric questions) What $ / unit scientific discovery is worth it? Edit to add: and yes there are things like the decadal survey and the “industry” has to justify itself to Congress (in the US at least). And yes, I generally do think the finding of this is (at these levels) probably going to bring some net positive multiplier benefit even if hard to quantify. And is more value per money than sending it to war to use an extreme comparison. But I wish there were a more defensible bar for knowing, other than public opinion or “at least we’re not as much a waste as <xyz>”. Just lucky for astronomy that at least they produce pet pictures for the public to support. But sad for other important fields that don’t have this luxury.
- xchip 4y agoPhysicist here, I agree with you 100%
- travisporter 4y agoSo scientists want better instruments to work with. Why is that a crime? Even CERN may be a huge expense. Idk even now I think Michelson and Morley’s ether experiment was worth it.
- aaron695 4y ago[dead]
- brutusborn 4y agoI remember listening to a talk where the presenter suggested the history of radio telescopes development was driven by the need for intelligence gathering. The telescopes could be used for spying but were justified on a scientific basis. I imagine a lot of space development is similar. The real reason for the huge investment is for defence applications, but it is more acceptable to justify it by the scientific ‘value’ of the projects. If you asked someone if they wanted $1billion to go to health research or space research the answer would be obvious.
- 8bitsrule 4y agoI've noticed that 'water' is often discovered in places where people want to spend money to scrutinize/get to. (For a variety of reasons.) E.g. sometimes vast internal 'oceans' are somehow implied by water vapor escaping from the surface of a moon. For the sake of visiting astronauts, I hope some of this 'water' turns out to be real. (Wherever the water in the Earth's oceans really came from is at least, finally, being questioned.)
- bee_rider 4y agoThis comment confuses me. Why is water in scare-quotes? Is the implication that it is something other than water? Is there a supposed meaning behind this tendency to look for water in places? I assume any sufficiently large celestial body gets a bit of eyeball time, and the ones that have water are bumped into the “interesting” bin because if we hypothetically ever hope to go there, that’s one necessary thing for survival off the list. What is the last parenthetical about? The water on Earth was at some point in space, after all, there’s no alternative…
- causality0 4y agoAfter JWST ran thousands of percent over budget and decades behind schedule I'm tempted to suspect any new telescope project of being a grift. If they get Congressional approval for a fifteen billion dollar lunar telescope it's going to end up costing fifty billion and somehow that won't result in anybody going to prison.
- dylan604 4y agoJWST was being built with the knowledge that there would be no way we could ever get to it to make repairs. A telescope on the moon would be something we could send the Maytag repair guy to make a house call. The risk is much smaller
- midoridensha 4y agoExactly: once we have a Moon base, it won't be hard to send technicians to the dark side to repair the radio telescope there. They'll be sending people to the dark side anyway to deal with the nuclear waste dump there. Unfortunately, we'll lose both when an accident at the dump turns it into a giant rocket and propels the Moon out of the solar system.
- whatshisface 4y agoBy "maytag repair guy" do you mean a billion dollar manned lunar program? ;)
- XorNot 4y agoDepending on the outcome of a SpaceX launch later today/early tomorrow, that number could start shrinking considerably (the SLS works, but I don't think anyone at NASA is particularly happy about building it overall - initial designs definitely didn't want to be using solid fuel boosters, but here we are).
- jeanlou 4y ago"Alleged dark" matter he should have said. He haven't been able to detect it up to now.
- Out_of_Characte 4y agoDark matter has a very simple and literal explanation, matter affected by gravity (thus below the speed of light) that we arent able to detect. This could be almost entirely mundane things like planets of asteroids that are impossible to see at lightyears if they dont pass in front of a star. Dark energy is the odd one that is part observation, part speculation
- z3phyr 4y agoIn our Solar System, planets, dwarf planets, asteroids, space dust together hold 0.15% mass. The rest of the 99.85% mass is held by the Sun. I think this mass distribution is uniformly true for other stellar systems as well, where majority of the mass is held by the stars (singular, binary, collapsed) and very small amount by other objects in the system. Given the above, why is there so much postulated "dark matter"?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ggm 4y agoIf you want to watch a fight, Get Astronomers into the room with "manned space in LEO is important because..." people and say "robots work in space" Actually you can probably get the same outcome by putting land optical scope astro people up against space optical or RF people. "all that launch cost spent on active optics here on the ground could.."
- DiogenesKynikos 4y agoThere's not really a conflict between land- and space-based telescopes. They have very different capabilities. There are things you can only do from space, and things you can only do from the ground. To give you an example, using adaptive optics, you can get higher resolution on small fields of view from the ground. That's because you can build much larger telescopes on the ground, which therefore have a smaller diffraction limit, and you can use adaptive optics to correct for the atmosphere in a small field of view. However, if you want high resolution over a large field of view, you have to go to space. Other advantages of space: extremely stable calibration (because you can control conditions more precisely, and because there's no atmosphere) and ability to view parts of the spectrum that are unavailable from the ground. Other advantages of ground-based telescopes: larger and heavier instruments, ability to do repairs and upgrades. Robots vs. manned spaceflight is much simpler. Robots will almost always give you more science return for the same price. I still think manned spaceflight should be pursued, but for other reasons (it's cool, and we should be pushing the envelope of what's possible).
- moi2388 4y agoRight. I suggest astrophysicists first start using Einstein instead of Newtons theory of gravity, and actually use Pi instead of 3, etc. Before they ever have the right to complain about wanting more accurate devices :p
- boffinAudio 4y agoThere already are 'telescopes' on the moon .. in the form of the Hasselblad [1] cameras that were left on the rover passenger seats, pointed up into the cosmos, for future retrieval .. No doubt some physicists of the future are going to be very interested in the contents of those lenses. Kind of the "pitch drop experiment" of astrophysics, I suppose. [1] - https://www.hasselblad.com/about/history/hasselblad-in-space/ https://www.hasselblad.com/about/history/hasselblad-in-space...