3 ms·
>This seems like a wild misrepresentation of what being a writer is. Writers communicate ideas. That's kind of irrelevant. People paying others for writing gig
by coldtea 4y ago
>This seems like a wild misrepresentation of what being a writer is. Writers communicate ideas.
That's kind of irrelevant. People paying others for writing gigs just care about words on a page, covering a certain topic. Doesn't have to be artistic or to contain novel ideas.
So, regardless if some writers make it, hundreds of thousands of people currently making a living writing copy can (and will be/are) replaced by AI text. If it gets a little better at creatively rewriting news agency feeds, many journalists will too (that's like what a huge number of journalists do, and not original reporting).
At best they will be reduced, for less and more precarious pay, to glorified prompt writers and checkers.
>If you’re really a writer
Yes, and real true Scotsmen will be fine too. The rest, less real Scotsmen, not so much.
- chrisco255 4y agoThe people that could be theoretically replaced by AI text could already have been replaced by Fiverr contractors or Mechanical Turk workers, but by and large we don't see it. If someone is able to delegate a task to a $5 worker or a 50 cent API call, and produce meaningful output, fine. But we have no such examples of tasks being able to be magically delegated in such a way that creates a cohesive, meaningful, broad whole publishing company and product together. Nobody has used Fiverr to replace the NYT editorial staff with a paper that's just as successful. And I don't think NYT would find value in delegating their article creation to ChatGPT either. Context, collaboration, high level planning, fact checking, deep understanding of market mechanics and sentiment, raw talent, etc, matter for writing news. I'm not even a fan of NYT or most modern journalism (I hate yellow journalism), but I don't think you can automate away an institution with a couple of GPT bots. I know everyone is breathlessly assuming that's the case today, but nobody is producing anything compelling. "Genius is one percent inspiration and ninety-nine percent perspiration" as the saying goes. But for some reason GPT heads think that equation has been flipped. I don't buy it.
- coldtea 4y ago>The people that could be theoretically replaced by AI text could already have been replaced by Fiverr contractors or Mechanical Turk workers, but by and large we don't see it. Tons of writers and graphic designers and such are already replaced by Fiverr contractors and other similar cheapo gig workers. >Nobody has used Fiverr to replace the NYT editorial staff with a paper that's just as successful. That would be like the last holdout. A good 90% of websites don't have such quality consraints or reservations. It's like someone say "AI will replace graphic designers" and someone replying that David Carson wont have a problem. Duh, but most jobs don't go to the handful of David Carson's of the trade (or even anybody 1/100th as famous)...
- chrisco255 4y ago> Tons of writers and graphic designers and such are already replaced by Fiverr contractors and other similar cheapo gig workers. Really? NYT is employing this? What organization is doing this (outsourcing their core competency) and succeeding bigly? > That would be like the last holdout. A good 90% of websites don't have such quality consraints or reservations. A good 99.99% of websites don't even matter, are just private personal sites with no product or business attached to them, so I'm not even sure what the assertion is there. Of course there's a power law for quality, impact, profitability, etc among websites just as there is for anything. If someone uses GPT on their personal blog site, that 3 people a year actually read, I'm not sure that's proving anything. > It's like someone say "AI will replace graphic designers" and someone replying that David Carson wont have a problem. Duh, but most jobs don't go to the handful of David Carson's of the trade (or even anybody 1/100th as famous)... I don't think AI, even at present capabilities, is capable of replacing graphic designers at any business where graphic design is the core competency. A skilled graphic designer is just going to have their productivity enhanced by having access to AI, and they're going to still be able to perform at far higher and consistent quality than "a prompt engineer". Consequently, however, demand for custom imagery will increase as people realize they can do more than simply add a stock image to an ad campaign. But just as "stock photo libraries" didn't kill the photography profession, nor did even putting a HD camera in everyone's pocket with amazing filter and stabilization effects...I predict that AI graphic tools will not replace graphic designers.
- coldtea 4y ago>Really? NYT is employing this? What organization is doing this (outsourcing their core competency) and succeeding bigly? What's with NYT again? I already wrote NYT will be the last holdout, i.e. NOT using this, but that means nothing, because 99% of news and content websites are not the NYT or have the same constraints and reputation to uphold. >A good 99.99% of websites don't even matter, are just private personal sites with no product or business attached to them, so I'm not even sure what the assertion is there. I'm not talking about personal websites. This is in the context of news and content websites, not personal homepages. We were talking about websites currently employing journalists and writers, and the danger AI would be to their jobs, remember? >I don't think AI, even at present capabilities, is capable of replacing graphic designers at any business where graphic design is the core competency. Which is irrelevant. It can still replace them where graphic design is not the core competency, but still provides a livelihood for hundreds of thousands of people - small time web designers, logo makers, etc. working for small businesses, individuals, and so on. Dismissingt this as "where graphic design is the core competency", is more or less again like saying "David Carson and big design brands will do fine". >But just as "stock photo libraries" didn't kill the photography profession, nor did even putting a HD camera in everyone's pocket with amazing filter and stabilization effects... You'd be very surprised. Photography as a profession is near ly dead. The vast majority of professional news photographers, whole teams, have been fired from all major and minor newspapers that used to have them, and the profession in general has depreciated greatly. If you mean "there are people who still do it as a profession", sure, it wasn't killed. People still offer horse carriage rides too, at least photography fares considerably better than that.