3 ms·
Online is just offline with extreme latency for any new data fetch/processing (an http roundtrip or more for each interaction with your data) someone else bei
by coldtea 4y ago
Online is just offline with
extreme latency for any new data fetch/processing (an http roundtrip or more for each interaction with your data)
someone else being in control of the programs you use, forcing changes and updates whenever they like, renting them as a service,
your data hostage, snooped at, sold to advertisers
a limited UI experience based on the DOM and browser APIs
crappy OS integration
(often) ads
- goodpoint 4y ago...and more surveillance.
- govolckurself 4y agoWhoa now. Don't go after the cash cow! It's so much harder to rent-seek when people just run regular programs that don't require 10 gigs of RAM and internet access. But where's the career promotion in that?
- JadeNB 4y ago> (often) ads This one doesn't have much to do with online vs. offline except that you have to be online to see the "latest and greatest" ads. Stale ads can perfectly well be shown offline.
- coldtea 4y agoTraditionally they weren't on offline software though. It's an online-era thing, and it thrives on online-ness, both for getting the "new" ads and for sending impressions and telemetry back. Even on modern offline-software-with-ads it's usually a glorified web view.
- alpaca128 4y ago> Stale ads can perfectly well be shown offline. They can, but an Android app I use regularly simply won't show any ads if it cannot access the internet - I get its premium version for free just by pressing a button. Meanwhile I've seen the user-hostile version of that on an iPad years ago, where an app simply locked itself until it was able to download ads.
- titzer 4y ago> (often) ads This is a much bigger problem than people realize. Instead of working on improving user experience, we've got people explicitly working against user experience by injecting ads into it, for the simple reason that they have your attention and can then sell it. It's the attention economy, and it sucks. Fuck ads.
- charcircuit 4y agoThere would be no user experience if there were no ads. Working on ads can improve the user experience by making them more relevant.
- alasarmas 4y agoI think people are really only interested in commercial messages when they come at a much lower frequency than they do these days. Other than that, it’s just noise that we suffer through in order to get the information or content that we want.
- kapp_in_life 4y ago>Other than that, it’s just noise that we suffer through in order to get the information or content that we want. The trailing part that's left off is "for free". If you want all the content we receive for free today, someone has to pay for it. So either people pay with their attention or their wallet, and consumers have by and large made their choice of ad supported services over paid alternatives.
- mehlmao 4y agoI pay for software and the developers force in ads later. It's not either or, it's just racing to the bottom, forever.
- yamazakiwi 4y agoUser Experience exists in many spaces that lack ads. Ads don't inherently improve UX, nor are they required for a good experience.
- jrm4 4y agoRight. There's a great deal of technically unnecessary complexity that many people here handwave away because "that's just how it is." It's kind of funny how, e.g. above, the emphasis is on "UI," when that's not it at all. It's the underlying infrastructure that's often encrusted layers of unnecessary (but profitable) stupid.
- akhayam 4y agoThis ^ Anyone who thinks UI is where the latency and complexity resides should do a 3-mo residency at a cloud provider running actual infrastructure--not VMs and the like, but the actual routers, backbone links, service provider peering, and servers. It'll change your perspective on complexity for sure.