3 ms·
In practice C++ Concepts don't do what you're suggesting. The C++ 20 Standard Library provides numerous concepts which have a very different semantic requireme
by tialaramex 4y ago
In practice C++ Concepts don't do what you're suggesting.
The C++ 20 Standard Library provides numerous concepts which have a very different semantic requirement than the syntax they're checking. If you violate the syntactic requirement of course that'll earn you a compiler error, but if you violate the semantic requirements that's silently an ill-formed C++ program, it has no meaning whatsoever and might do absolutely anything if run.
If these were nominal, we could say, well, nobody should have deliberately implemented this inappropriate Concept, similar to an unsafe Rust trait, the act of implementation is a promise to others. But C++ Concepts aren't nominal and so there was no opportunity to do that and so in practice such deviations are likely very common despite the potentially drastic consequences.
- gpderetta 4y agoI have been programming in C++ for almost 20 years [1] and I don't remember ever being bitten by accidental concept conformance. So I object to the "likely very common" description. Implicit conformance was very much an explicit design goal. [1] yes, concepts as an explicit language feature are new, but C++ has had de-facto concepts since Stepanov work on the original STL in the 90s.
- tialaramex 4y agoSince I know better than to suggests C++ programmers might be more capable of making mistakes than they realise, lets try a different question: How do you spot this mistake when reviewing other people's code? Do you memorise a list of all the semantic requirements of each concept so that you can mentally check that the concept's requirements are satisfied appropriately by what was written each time ?
- gpderetta 4y agoI expect other people to write tests (including compile time tests).
- tialaramex 4y agoIf you were worried about behavioural problems, including UB, tests would help. But alas the problem here is IFNDR [Ill-formed No Diagnostic Required] so the compiler can't help you. All semantic constraints are your problem as the programmer, C++ decided that it's not the compiler's concern whether the program meets semantic constraints. Testing doesn't necessarily help at all, which is probably surprising.
- plorkyeran 4y agoThis isn't something I look for in code reviews because it's just not something I've ever see be the source of a bug. There are a million bugs that I've eventually tracked down to some subtle C++ thing, but I've never had one come down to a type which appears to conform to one of the standard library's concepts but actually doesn't.