4 ms·
There's kind of a fun brain teaser related to this. Imagine you're speaking to an entirely alien species in another dimension. And you're trying to describe "le
by somenameforme 4y ago
There's kind of a fun brain teaser related to this. Imagine you're speaking to an entirely alien species in another dimension. And you're trying to describe "left" to them. It's impossible.
I say it's a brain teaser only because this sounds highly improbable at first. Forwards and backwards can be described, and even up/down if we assume basic fundamental rules remain the same. Yet left and right? It seems impossible for it to be impossible.
- junon 4y agoNot sure I understand. Directions are relative. I'd describe "left" how I describe every other direction.
- smusamashah 4y agoImagine they use word 'right' for 'left' but you don't know about it. How will you describe true left/right to them?
- perlgeek 4y agoHow would you describe it? One approach would be: you're moving along a straight line, perpendicular to a large body that attracts you through gravity. Now "down" is towards the gravity, "up" is the opposite direction, and "left" and "right" are perpendicular, but which one is left and right, if you cannot rely on handedness?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- meschi 4y agoI think this is due to the bilateral symmetry of most animals. But imagine being non-symmetric yourself (or the alien race being non-symmetric). The concepts of left and right seem to become much more communicable now.
- codingdave 4y agoIt isn't impossible, it is just arbitrary. The whole reason we can have this huge thread about different names for directions is that they is just arbitrary labels, with groups of people having a consensus on what word to use. BTW, If you really must explain it without just saying it is arbitrary, you can talk about clockwise vs. counterclockwise... which came from sundials, which came from the direction our shadows move as the sun moves. In a similar vein, Left goes against the shadows, Right follows the shadows.
- somenameforme 4y agoThat's entirely relative to the direction that a body is orbiting about another.
- codingdave 4y agoShadows come from the rotation of the earth, not its orbit. But you are still correct - if the earth suddenly started having inconsistency in the direction it spins, that explanation would fall apart.
- dguest 4y agoIt turns out you can define it from looking at radioactive decay (or any other interaction governed by the weak force). Feynman famously had a short description that ended with the punch line > Suppose, after lots of communication you finally can go into space and meet your alien counterpart. If, as you approach one another, the alien extends its left hand to shake, watch out! He’s made of antimatter! because even the physics of weak decays of will invert in an antimatter universe.
- cubefox 4y agoThat claim needs to be substantiated.
- qubidt 4y agoThe assertion that it is possible or the attribution to Feynman? Scientific American [1] references Feynman's 4th Messenger lecture at Cornell: "Symmetry in Physical Law" (1964) [2] [3] [1] https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/degrees-of-freedom/galactic-challenge-part-ii-the-richard-feynman-files/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/degrees-of-freedom/gala... [2] https://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/messenger.html https://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/messenger.html [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W7K1kXeK-tY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W7K1kXeK-tY
- cubefox 4y agoSorry, I meant a hypothetical definition of "left".
- dguest 4y agoWhich claim? The full transcript of the Feynman story is available online [1], you can search for "martian" to get right to the story. It's presented in the context of explaining CP symmetry, which says that physics is conserved under a parity (mirror reflection) plus charge inversion (matter -> antimatter) transformation. Of course it's only approximate [2]. I got the quote slightly differently from what is recorded on the caltech sight, the one they have is > So if our Martian is made of antimatter and we give him instructions to make this “right” handed model like us, it will, of course, come out the other way around. What would happen when, after much conversation back and forth, we each have taught the other to make space ships and we meet halfway in empty space? We have instructed each other on our traditions, and so forth, and the two of us come rushing out to shake hands. Well, if he puts out his left hand, watch out! [1]: https://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/I_52.html https://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/I_52.html [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CP_violation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CP_violation
- pgorczak 4y agoYeah the handedness of a 3D coordinate system is a pretty arbitrary low level choice. You don’t even need to talk to aliens, just try implementing some geometric algorithm in Unity which uses a left-handed system.