4 ms·
This is not remotely a gender thing. The pitchfork brigade do not march solely on women. Neither is it an Apple thing. The headline would be more accurate as
by Terretta 15y ago
This is not remotely a gender thing. The pitchfork brigade do not march solely on women.
Neither is it an Apple thing. The headline would be more accurate as "The fanboy problem". One has only to spend a few days on Reddit to witness this clearly.
Violet Blue has an interestingly divergent point of view, and I appreciate her pieces. I think she's dead on right in calling out Internet lynch mob volatility and tendency for full on assault before all facts are known. She's also right to call out bloggers for publishing less than buttoned-up "journalism".
But referencing Apple here is the same as the NY Times piece on Foxconn, failing to point out the suicide pact was Xbox workers, for example.
Yes, Apple has a responsibility to review suppliers[1], and Gruber has a responsibility to check facts. But these lynching have been going on continually and from tribal camps of all stripes.
Her conclusion ("It is an aspect of Apple’s legacy from an older era - one that needs to go away.") ends well, but it's not Apple's legacy causing this.
1. http://www.apple.com/supplierresponsibility/ http://www.apple.com/supplierresponsibility/
- jonnathanson 15y agoCouldn't agree more. First, I do not follow Violet's leap that this is tangibly, even subtly, about gender. Just because the object of an ugly and vicious attack happens to be female does not make sexism the conscious or subconscious motivation behind the attack. It's highly likely that the same lynch mob would have gone after a man who aroused their fanboy ire, and with the same level of zeal and fanaticism. Playing the gender card here does no favors to Violet's otherwise interesting and provocative analysis. Second, I don't understand what Apple is meant to do about this. If one is to accuse Apple, even indirectly, of inspiring this behavior among its fanbase, then one bears at least some burden for suggesting how Apple might address the issue. As it stands, I don't understand a) how this behavior is unique to Apple's fanboys versus, say, everyone else's fanboys, and b) what Apple should -- or even can -- do about it. Finally, I agree with you that this is more a sad phenomenon of internet fanboyism in general, and less a phenomenon of Apple fanboyism in specific. That Apple fanboyism happens to stand out from the pack is probably a matter of sample size. There are more Apple fanboys out there, among the general population, than there are other types of fanboys. But anyone who's ever browsed an online message board, Reddit topic, etc., about any fanboy-generating topic (video games, movies, comic books, you name it) will see the same sort of craziness that was seen here. That doesn't excuse the craziness by any means; it's obnoxious, ugly, and counterproductive everywhere that it exists. But it does put the craziness of Apple fanboyism into its proper context and perspective.
- ugh 15y agoThis is a gender thing. It is, however, only a gender thing and has nothing to do specifically with Apple. Women are treated markedly different than men. It’s quite disgusting, really.
- wonderzombie 15y agoYes. The casual misogyny women on the Internet is arguably one of the most underreported, widespread, systemic problems on the Internet. The grandparent here suggests that the Internet mob doesn't march solely on women. Uh, who said they do? There is a drastic difference in the tenor of attacks on men and women when this happens, however. There's something substantially more ugly in the character of the mob's reaction, but fortunately we have a word for it: misogyny. Actually, it's a fairly regular occurrence on the Internet even when it's not provoked by these controversies. I don't have one good source for information about this stuff, but here's something that looks fairly comprehensive, in that it collects the experiences from a variety of female bloggers: http://www.newstatesman.com/blogs/helen-lewis-hasteley/2011/11/comments-rape-abuse-women http://www.newstatesman.com/blogs/helen-lewis-hasteley/2011/....