15 ms·
Hundreds of years after the first try, we can finally read a Ptolemy text
- NKosmatos 4y agoIt would be nice if the article had a couple of photos of the manuscript or even better a link to the recovered text.
- AstixAndBelix 4y agoFor some reason most online publications still think we're in the era of paper journals and stubbornly refuse to corredate their articles with references as if they had strict space constraints
- Someone 4y agoNo, they think they’re in the 21st century and think it brings in more money when site visitors click on links that stay on their site than when they click on outgoing links. The publication is open access and has images. See https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00407-022-00302-w https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00407-022-00302-w
- azepoi 4y agoThanks for the source paper. Interesting use of imagery, with 13 frequency bands from near infrared to UV. https://lumiere-technology.com/technique-multispectrale/ https://lumiere-technology.com/technique-multispectrale/ https://lumiere-technology.com/imagerie-multispectrale/ https://lumiere-technology.com/imagerie-multispectrale/
- yesco 4y ago> it brings in more money when site visitors click on links that stay on their site than when they click on outgoing links As trust in journalism declines, I wonder if/when we will start to see a reversal of this? Providing sources, and bragging about providing sources when other news orgs do not, seems like it would be a great selling point to a lot of people. At the same time, I would also bet that the vast majority of people would never check/click the sources if provided, especially if structured like a bibliography and pushed off to the side. Just the comfort of believing the sources are available would be enough to keep people coming back, meaning journalists would get to have their cake and eat it too.
- eru 4y agoMany blogs already do this, and I've even seen it on youtube. Not sure if you call bloggers and youtubers 'journalists', though?
- yesco 4y agoI think you could technically refer to them as journalists too but I meant the traditional non-independent kind. Honestly the rise of bloggers + youtubers providing higher quality well sourced content than the mainstream is partially why I think this might become a de-facto requirement to compete in the future.
- eru 4y agoI'm not so sure. Because those alternatives exist, people who care about that kind of sourcing will select themselves out of the audience of traditional journalism. That will leave that audience with less demand for such rigor. (At least that's an alternative story you can spin. So we can't say a priori whether your narrative or mine would prevail, at least not without leaving our armchairs.)
- local_crmdgeon 4y agoI'd consider any group of people that cite sources and report stories to be journalists. It's a useful heuristic because in this case, it excludes Ars. Those go into the less prestigious category, "journoids"
- eru 4y agoYou can make up your own definitions of words, but talking to other people is gonna get confusing really fast.
- eru 4y agoI'm mildly impressed that this Springer site let me just view the article and its pdf without jumping through any hoops. I usually recoil whenever I find myself on a Springer site and their paywalls.
- spacebanana7 4y agoGoogle could solve this problem. A new ranking boost for high reputation outbound links similar to the current boost for high reputation inbound links would encourage citations because editors would encourage the practice from journalists. Some check might be necessary to make sure the citation fits the context of the article, however current NLP tech can manage that fairly well - and again I vaguely remember that Google has a some kind context check for outbound links too.
- Eric_WVGG 4y agoThat’s already how Google works. The publishers either aren’t aware of that, or think captive readers are more valuable than SEO.
- spacebanana7 4y agoThanks for the correction, I didn't know that
- sp332 4y agoThis article was written by a "contributor". Most Ars Technica articles are full of links.
- rnk 4y agoGood article. There must be thousands of other damaged or erased scripts to recover like the Herculaneum scrolls. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/buried-ash-vesuvius-scrolls-are-being-read-new-xray-technique-180969358/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/buried-ash-vesuvius-s...
- robga 4y agoThere are efforts with prizes underway right now for the scrolls. https://scrollprize.org/ https://scrollprize.org/
- Etrnl_President 4y agoThe ancient scrolls, written in the first year of Vectron, by Vectron Himself?
- thom 4y agoI’m doing a course on Alexander the Great at the moment and for a couple of seconds I thought we’d uncovered surviving versions of Ptolemy I Soter’s account (which Arrian used as a primary source). Nevertheless, that Ptolemy was a patron of Euclid, whose work on optics the later Ptolemy built upon. Small world, but with so many things lost to time.
- rurban 4y agoThis is about his astronomical Meteoroscope instrument, which is not that interesting. Most of his astronomical texts are horrible and set back the advance of science only similar to Aristoteles' completely wrong mechanics. His geographical texts also (mostly stolen and wrong), only his mathematical texts are worthwhile. His german wikipedia is esp. damning: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claudius_Ptolem%C3%A4us#Kritik https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claudius_Ptolem%C3%A4us#Kritik
- chongli 4y agoIt’s still interesting to study Ptolemy because of the role he played in the history of science and the scientific method. Rigorous scientific practice isn’t something we walked out of the jungle having mastered, it took centuries to develop after many missteps such as Ptolemy’s. Furthermore, one of the lessons we learned from the bad assumptions of Ptolemy (geocentrism) is to never assume that we occupy a special position from which we make observations. This holds value even in modern cosmology, since it appears that we’re at the “centre” of the universe due to the cosmic microwave background’s extreme uniformity in every direction. Cosmologists thus assume that we’re not special, so we are unlikely to be at the centre of anything, which leads to the term “observable universe” and the potential for the universe to be much larger than this region from which all light has reached us.
- rurban 4y agoThe criticism by several well known astronomists: Tycho Brahe called out betrayal 1600. Jean-Baptiste Joseph Delambre 1817 called it fake and fabricated observations, preconceptions, lies and plagiarism. The US astronom Robert Russell Newton confirmed it 1985. B. L. van der Waerden confirmed it 1988. It was about the non-scientific methods, not the absurd results, given that the heliocentric view was known long before Ptolemy.
- chongli 4y agoThis is getting too far into the weeds on judging Ptolemy's intentions and motivations. It also applies more modern standards of scientific rigour to work that was done before they existed. This is a common anachronism (and fallacy) people make throughout history. the heliocentric view was known long before Ptolemy I am aware that Aristarchus of Samos put forth a heliocentric view. Unfortunately for him, it wouldn't be until the development of Kepler's Laws (ca. 1609-1619) that a heliocentric model could be made to yield better predictions (in all cases) than the Ptolemaic model. Yes, even though Copernicus developed the more modern heliocentric theory (before 1543) he could not reduce the errors in his predictions because he held onto the assumption of perfect circular orbits dating back to Plato. Few astronomers at the time accepted his theory, and even Tycho Brahe (who you cite) constructed his own model which was mathematically equivalent to Copernicus's but placed the Earth at the centre of the system.
- garciansmith 4y agoNeither the Ars Technica nor the original article really talk about the staining process, reagents often made from oak galls there were brushed on the parchment. I remember when I first saw the same kind of brown stains on a medieval manuscript and had no clue what they were: since the ink was so sloppily applied I first assumed some kind of heat or fire damage (too bad the book I was looking at wasn't written by anyone famous, so it'll probably never be imaged). The idea of permanently causing damage to a manuscript in the hopes that you can temporarily make out the text seems kind of crazy (and certainly is not a proper archival practice today!), but it happened with some frequency in the mid-nineteenth century. It seems that it actually did make certain inks more visible for a brief time, though for others it didn't work. And of course this was all at the cost of permanently marring the parchment. Here's a good article on that subject that helped me understand what was going on, which even mentions the same Cardinal Mai who applied reagents to the Ptolemy ms: http://palimpsest.stmarytx.edu/AmbrosianaArchive/ResourceDocuments/RLE_reagent_papers/chemical_treatment_palimpsests/2011_Albrecht_Tinctures.pdf http://palimpsest.stmarytx.edu/AmbrosianaArchive/ResourceDoc...
- twic 4y agoNot only manuscripts. Arthur Evans uncovered the palace-city of Knossos, perhaps the oldest settlement in Europe, excavated it, then had a go at repairing it, with reinforced concrete: https://cromwell-intl.com/travel/greece/crete/knossos/ https://cromwell-intl.com/travel/greece/crete/knossos/
- vrglvrglvrgl 4y ago[dead]