4 ms·
CRT places black people in the center of the political universe in the same way that Marxism places the proletariat at the center of the political universe. (I’
by rayiner 4y ago
CRT places black people in the center of the political universe in the same way that Marxism places the proletariat at the center of the political universe. (I’m not using the comparison to Marxism pejoratively, it’s simply apt.) That’s the whole point. It is by design a framework for criticizing the failure of traditional liberal principles to remediate the disadvantages facing black people in America. When CRT purports to address other non-white races, it does so only by treating them as another kind of black person. Hence the term “people of color,” which is just a way to project how the CRT framework conceptualists black people onto all non-whites. (And on the front it’s wrong. It’s central premise that racism is a structural problem requiring a structural solution is wrong as applied to Latinos and Asians just as it did not apply to Italians.)
That focus carries through to the “pop” version of CRT manifested by folks such as Ibram Kendi and Nikole Hannah-Jones. In “how to be an anti-racist” Kendi doesn’t grapple with any of the implications of his ideas beyond the hoped-for effect on black people. In the quote from Hannah-Jones, she reduces “nearly everything truly exceptional about America” to slavery.
It also manifests in how ordinary liberals today talk about political theory. For example, despite the obvious advantages of federalism for a multi-ethnic democracy (which is why India has a federal structure) it’s impossible to get ordinary liberals to approach federalism except from the perspective of how it was used to uphold segregation. Similarly, critiques of the Senate invariably mention that it empowers primarily white states as if people’s skin color is the problem.
This is of course not a critique of CRT. It’s an analytical framework designed to analyze and solve the challenges facing the specific group that created it. But when it’s adopted as a generalized political theory, it leads to the antagonism noted above.
- tptacek 4y agoCritical race theory isn't critical theory, as you know. Critical race theory qua critical race theory is a legal theory that explores the ways in which critical legal studies --- itself a separate concept from critical theory --- fails to account for the varied ways in which the US legal system fucks over Black people. It is not, in fact, a general theory of why white people are evil. In fact, some of the earliest/most influential critical race theory papers try, in a sense, to ask critical legal theorists to dial it back a little bit. You should read Crenshaw; those papers aren't the caricature subliterate culture warriors want them to be. Critical race theory qua "CRT" is a meaningless culture war slur/valediction, and a strong signal that whoever's non-ironically using it (whether from the left or the right) isn't operating in good faith. The problem with the way you operate in these discussions is that it's very clear that you want "liberals" to occupy luridly stupid positions, like "the true purpose of all US institutions, which we as liberals support wholeheartedly, is to suppress white people". And, if you go looking for people to hold those positions, you'll find them (often because, like DiAngelo, they're looking to make a buck off it). There are people occupying every lurid position. We contain multitudes. That's no way to have a curious conversation. Late edit I wrote "critical legal theory" where I meant "critical legal studies". Might as well get the names right myself.
- rayiner 4y agoYou just restated what I said: CRT is a theory centered on black people. Which it is, by design, the same way Marxism, as a political and economic theory, is centered on the proletariat. Insofar as it doesn’t ignore the needs of other groups, such as poor whites, it leads to incorrect and actively harmful conclusions, such as for Asians and Latinos. However, CRT, like Marxism, is designed to undergird a political movement, not just an academic theory. The repurposing of terms like “white supremacy” to describe things other than KKK members, or “racism” to describe things other than prejudice, is advocacy, by design. And that political movement, which I refer to as “wokeness” above, is antagonistic to white people (and often Asians and Latinos) in the same way that Marxism as a political movement is often antagonistic to rich people. There is a direct line from CRT to Alison Collins. I’m not criticizing liberals for anything other than failing to defend (little “l”) liberal ideals, and relatedly for uncritically adopting an analytical framework developed for black people onto other non-whites, in ways that are harmful to those groups.[1] That’s a sufficient indictment. No need to resort to caricature. [1] For example: insofar as Latinos and Asians face prejudice and not structural racism, making society more conscious of race in an effort to change existing structures is almost certainly bad for them. Likewise, insofar as those groups are assimilating into the majority society like prior immigrant groups did, it’s probably a bad idea to teach Latino and Asian kids about historical racism against their groups, for the same reason we don’t teach Italian kids about the same.
- tptacek 4y agoMarxism is defined in part by a totalizing focus on class struggle in virtually all aspects of politics, policy, law, and economics (critical theory is an extension of that idea to culture). Critical race theory draws on (and pushes back on) critical legal studies --- which is a weird counterculture fringe movement that happened to have been au courant when the critical race theorists were getting started. Both of those movements are ways of looking specifically at the law and the way the law is studied and interrogated. Intersectionality comes from observations of things like cases where Black women were denied standing because either their Black heritage or their gender were escape hatches for judges (they either couldn't represent all women, or couldn't represent all Black people). Structural or implicit bias, another big critical race theory idea, is an idea you yourself repeatedly endorsed and explained: after operating for decades (centuries) on a program of overt discrimination, simply ending the discriminatory rules isn't enough to eliminate the bias; the system is in a steady state primed, powerfully, to exclude (women, Black people, whatever). These are straightforward ideas. Importantly: they are, in context, legal ideas, and specific ones. They are not assertions that white people should move to the back of the grocery store line to make way for Black people. There's a Nelson Muntzian element to the argument that critical race theory is somehow as risible as classical Marxism. Critical race theory is literally the legal field's attempt to work through the implications of the segregation that continued into the 1980s. It's as obviously a legitimate focus of study as virology is for a biologist, or compilers are to a computer scientist. It strikes me as profoundly disingenuous to attempt to disqualify it by suggesting, as its critics seem to, that any study of structural racism in the law must be diluted, or else be just another flavor of Marxism. I read things like this and think of Berny Belvedere's quip in response to this argument: "new Marxisms just dropped! Chipotle raising their prices is burrito Marxism! Daylight savings time is temporal Marxism! Alarm clock ringing is snooze Marxism!"