22 ms·
MRI brain images become 64M times sharper
- floxy 4y agoSeems likely the 64e6 time sharper really means that the resolution increased by a factor of 400 (400^3 = 64e6).
- 1letterunixname 4y agoMarketing lies, now in 3-D! I'd call that 2.5 orders-of-magnitude sharper given how 4 is close to the middle of the log10 range between 1 and 10.
- smeagull 4y ago8.644, why base 10?
- 1letterunixname 4y agoLog scale is usually log10 because that's what humans use.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- blakesterz 4y agoI didn't expect this one would be one of those "IN MICE" things... In a decades-long technical tour de force led by Duke’s Center for In Vivo Microscopy with colleagues at the University of Tennessee Health Science Center, University of Pennsylvania, University of Pittsburgh and Indiana University, researchers took up the gauntlet and improved the resolution of MRI leading to the sharpest images ever captured of a mouse brain.
- recycledmatt 4y agoThey took the existing components and supercharged them. This thing is exponentially more expensive per cubic inch.
- robwwilliams 4y agoCo-author here: No this is actually becoming a less expense acquisition protocol at the cost per voxel per unit of scan time. Of course not intended for clinical application but rather to understand the basic biology and genetics of Alzheimer’s, Huntington’s And Parkinson’s diseases, addiction, and aging. Does anyone think we understand AD and how best to intervene? This technology is already proving useful. Stay tuned—-this is the tech paper but the application papers are in the wirks.
- nullc 4y agoIt's not just "in mice", it's "in dead mice" AFAICT, as they must open the mouse to use LSM. Mice tend to not work after you open them. It also is difficult to get high resolution images of samples disturbed by sources of noise such as blood flow. I had an uninformed perspective that for a given field strength the resolution is limited by how long the subject can stay still. This is obviously a lot longer for one that isn't alive and is screwed to the platform. I assume the 9.4T magnet is a very small bore and couldn't take a human. (E.g. https://www.monash.edu/researchinfrastructure/mbi/facilities/pre-clinical/9.4t-mri https://www.monash.edu/researchinfrastructure/mbi/facilities...). Of course, lots of important research will benefit from improved scanning resolution on dead subjects -- one might get mislead by the headline, especially if one isn't a research scientist mostly concerned with scanning things you've poisoned or genetically programmed to die in interesting ways.
- numbasys 4y agoYes, several hours per image. This resolution is still an achievement. But in vivo images (alive) are much more useful as they enable longitudinal studies, but obviously far more challenging to get anything close to good resolution in a mouse. More like 150 micron in alive, sedated mouse brains, even from 9.4T.
- westurner 4y agoOther thread from earlier today: "Brain images just got 64 million times sharper" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35615778 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35615778
- sempron64 4y agoIs this enough to reconstruct the brain for simulation?
- throwaway4aday 4y agoThe only interesting question in here so far and also the only one that got a downvote from someone. 4 microns is about the size of the cell body of the smallest neurons so this technique could potentially give you the position of every neuron in the brain but isn't going to pick up the dendrites and synapses. You'd need resolution closer to 10 nanometers for that. 1 micrometer (micron) = 1000 nanometers
- mattkrause 4y agoNo, not even close. We have a complete map of C. elegans, a small worm with 302(ish) neurons. We have a complete wiring diagram of the adult worm’s neurons as well as a “fate map” showing how those connections form during development. Nevertheless, it’s fairly hard to simulate. Neuromodulators cause all sorts of “spooky action at (synaptic) distance” that the wiring diagram can’t explain, for example.
- quickthrower2 4y agoWould it require simulating subatomic particles that make the atoms that make the molecules etc.? Might need a quantum computer?
- ramraj07 4y agoLikely not. It’s more about knowing the connection strengths and the myriad list of neurotransmitters that combine to form complex networks.
- andbberger 4y agoto pile on, most impressive "complete mapping" so far is without a doubt the hemibrain connectome which took months and cost ~$50M, for a not quite good enough resolution image of a microscopic brain that was quite dead.
- pealco 4y agoCool, but as described, this wouldn't work on humans. The light sheet microscopy technique that the suped-up MRI data is paired with to create these images requires tissue to be "cleared" (or made transparent) with solvents, which obviously you can't do with a living human brain. To be honest, I don't quite understand how light sheet microscopy works with living _mouse_ brains.
- BenFranklin100 4y agoIt doesn’t. The brain must be cleared which generally involves removing lipids so the tissue has a homogeneous index of refraction throughout. Given lipids are an extremely important component of the brain (for instance myelin is a lipid rich material that surrounds axons) even if one were able to clear the brain without excising it from the skull, the clearing process essentially destroys the brain by preventing it from function properly.
- robwwilliams 4y agoCorrect. But that is where the lightsheet adds sufficient resolution. MRI for the “mesopic” scale, lightsheet for for microscopic scale to 0.2 microns, and selective elecron microscopy down as low as tissue quality will allow.
- BenFranklin100 4y agoYou’re not even responding to the original questions, which is is lightsheet microscopy capable of imaging entire living brains? Pay attention.
- kevviiinn 4y agoCan you use light microscopy on a living brain? No
- BenFranklin100 4y agoTwo and three photon microscopy works on living brains down to depth of approximately 1.5 mm. A company even sells head mounted miniature microscopes for mice. Try to refrain from commenting on topics outside your expertise.
- MPSimmons 4y agoI have a heart stent that is only rated to 3T, so I'm kind of sad that I can't make use of the newer MRI technologies (granted, this particular MRI imaging doesn't seem to be a thing for humans yet). I'm wondering if, at some point, I'll be able to have it replaced with a newer material that isn't ferromagnetic (or wouldn't be affected like mine is)
- KennyBlanken 4y agoYour stent is only rated to 3T because that's about the absolute maximum field strength used by human clinical MRI systems, with the vast majority being half to a quarter that. As you noted, this imaging was done at much higher field strengths, ~10T. That sort of field strength is practical at the scale of a system sized for a mouse. For a human, it's likely to never be practical for a whole slew of reasons related to the energy needed, forces on the machine, the increase field size and strength affecting room construction, safety thresholds, etc.
- hansvm 4y ago1.5T and 3T are very common, and 4-7T are definitely used in a number of hospitals. UMN has a 10.5T magnet they've shoved humans into. Their stent is rated to 3T for a variety of reasons including: 1. That's all they've tested (as you alluded to). 2. It might actually fail at higher fields. 3. Stents act as antennas and can focus RF into unwanted places like cooking the middle of the brain, and it's a lot more likely that the stent is rated for exactly 3T than up to 3T since the relevant frequencies are proportional to field strength, and the associated wavelengths can coincide more or less with the length of the stent (kind of like how the Tacoma Narrows bridge could have experienced a lot more wind, but that particular set of factors was problematic). It _might_ be certified for 0-3T, but that takes additional research to actually do. 4. Any number of other reasons. High fields have a variety of counter-intuitive properties.
- MPSimmons 4y agoFor what it's worth, most of the concern seems to be migration (movement of the stent) and temperature increase, and there's also a passive optical artifact introduced by the stent in the image itself. The manufacturer docs are here: https://www.cardiovascular.abbott/int/en/hcp/products/percutaneous-coronary-intervention/xience-family/freqently-asked-questions.html https://www.cardiovascular.abbott/int/en/hcp/products/percut... Nonclinical testing has shown that the XIENCE Sierra™ Stent, in single and in overlapped configurations up to 71 mm in length, are MR conditional. A patient with this device can be scanned in an MR system under the following conditions:\* Static magnetic field of 1.5 or 3 Tesla Maximum spatial gradient field of 3000 Gauss/cm or less Maximum MR system reported whole-body-averaged specific absorption rate (SAR) of 2.0 W/kg (normal operating mode) Under the scan conditions defined above, XIENCE Sierra™ Stents are expected to produce a maximum temperature rise of of less than 4.5°C after 15 minutes of continuous scanning. The XIENCE Sierra™ Stent should not migrate in this MRI environment. MRI at 1.5 or 3 Tesla may be performed immediately post-implantation. In non-clinical testing, the image artifact caused by the device extends approximately 6 mm from the XIENCE Sierra™ Stent when imaged with a gradient echo or spin echo pulse sequence and a 3T MRI system. It may be necessary to optimize the MRI parameters to account for the presence of XIENCE Sierra™ Stents.
- m3kw9 4y ago64M? Looks more like 6.4x
- samch 4y agoI was curious about the machine itself. There is a description and picture on their lab page[1]: “The vertical bore 9.4T Agilent MRI has been specially constructed for the microscopic imaging of fixed specimens. A bespoke gradient system, one of only two such systems in the world, provides encoding gradients up to 2500 mT/m, more than 50 times that of a clinical MRI. The system has been tightly integrated to a high performance cluster computer to enable compressed sensing” [1]: https://www.civm.duhs.duke.edu/duke-CIVM-DIIL-equipment https://www.civm.duhs.duke.edu/duke-CIVM-DIIL-equipment
- qgin 4y agoSide question: are there any interesting brand new medical imaging modalities being worked on these days or is all work focused on improving existing ones?
- robwwilliams 4y agoYes, lots of innovative new algorithms to process the diffusion tensor metrics and images. That is how we got down to nominal resolution of 5 microns for the tractography. The effective resolution is closer to 10 microns.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Robotbeat 4y agoStill not good enough to resolve Axon terminals (0.25 microns vs their scanner at 5 microns per voxel length). But very impressive still.
- inasio 4y agoIn my opinion [0] a much more interesting track to pursue than super high-T scans that only work on mice (dead mice at that) is low field MRI scanning. MRI is amazing, but incredibly bulky and slow. In Canada you have to live for 6 months with a knee injury before surgery just because of the wait to access an MRI. Companies like Hyperfine (not affiliated) and Deepspin (just learned of them) make low power portable machines (I believe NFL teams were early costumers). A single MRI image is not super helpful, still more art than science, the real benefit comes from having periodic scans against a baseline. Boutique health clinics offer yearly scans to high net-worth individuals, rolling this out to a larger population could have a huge impact. [0] educated opinion, I also collaborated on a PNAS MRI paper
- xtracto 4y agoIn Mexico you can buy a (private) head MRI scan with contrast for around $300 USD. It's really cheap. So theoretically you could do one every couple of months.
- riceart 4y agoDoes that include the radiologist read?
- xtracto 4y agoYes
- harikb 4y agoRelated - https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/08/well/medical-tourism-mexico-kidnapping.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/08/well/medical-tourism-mexi...
- inasio 4y agoNot that cheap for Mexican people, median salary is $600 USD/month
- realitysballs 4y ago
- sheepscreek 4y agoA bit misleading (or underwhelming). It’s like citing a supercomputer and saying “math computation just got 64M times faster”. Sure. But at scale? No. Maybe the likes of Bill Gates can access this tech for treatment today. For the likes of us, I am guessing another 10-15 years?
- flangola7 4y agoBill Gates probably does not want to have his brain removed either. Either way, we still celebrate the Wright brothers even if their invention was not immediately useful or scalable.
- m463 4y agoStrange that a lot of the comments here basically say "who needs this?" But I remember when TVs were 640x480-ish and 1920x1080 was amazing. And 4k. Maybe this won't be for knees in live patients. Maybe it won't be for MRIs in the far-flung corners of the world. But what if it was for researchers to find elusive parts of the brain? What if the high quantity of data led to better algorithms for current MRIs to make them faster (which probably means cheaper). I think of pure science and how it doesn't immediately teach us something, but later it answers (or provokes) questions and moves the needle. Just saying. That doesn't mean I don't groan at some advances - like any advance that "adds value" to some product by collecting more data without your consent. :)
- robwwilliams 4y agoYes, unfortunate PR title that we the co-authors do not control. This generates some adverse gut response—-even for us. Headline writing is tricky in terms of the balance between reality and README.
- cat_plus_plus 4y agoOk but have brains become 64K times sharper, or are we getting ahead of ourselves?
- modzu 4y agocan we make them 64M times cheaper please?
- eimrine 4y agoAbility to use a giant peace of copper (coil) plus time of medical personnel plus some supa cool leet haxor medical software plus extremely expensive legal medical terrorism-preventing licensing - seems like a recipe of an expensive treatment which will never become significantly cheaper.
- coppsilgold 4y agoThere were plans to significantly shorten MRI scanning times with compressed sensing. It seems there is some progress: <https://www.usa.philips.com/healthcare/education-resources/publications/fieldstrength/how-compressed-sense-makes-mri-faster https://www.usa.philips.com/healthcare/education-resources/p...>
- lostlogin 4y agoWe do this. It’s rather old hat now and the Philips offerings are destroyed by the likes of Siemens Deep Resolve. It applies deep learning to the raw data (more signal!) and to the final image (more resolution). It’s compatible with the likes of SMS, Grappa and various other acceleration techniques. It’s fast and it’s good. https://www.siemens-healthineers.com/magnetic-resonance-imaging/technologies-and-innovations/deep-resolve https://www.siemens-healthineers.com/magnetic-resonance-imag...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- scotty79 4y agoIs this a single neuron level? Can we map mouse brain down to a single neuron and connection right now?
- BadOakOx 4y agoPrevious conversation: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35615778 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35615778
- Nevermark 4y agoIt occurs to me that a scan that only works on dead brains isn’t nearly as much of a problem if it scan in enough detail to extract an algorithmic continuation of the mind involved. 5 microns might not be there yet, but it’s quite a leap in that direction.
- robwwilliams 4y agoHave a look at the paper and the PR video. MRI superresolution is at 5 microns today.
- lelag 4y agoThis news makes me think about the qntm short story Lena: https://qntm.org/mmacevedo https://qntm.org/mmacevedo
- timlod 4y agoThis is a very clickbaity title. Over 6 years ago I worked as a student on reconstruction of 50 micron human brain (part, occipital lobe) MRI images, also captured in 9.4T. Obviously a 10x higher resolution is still impressive, but it’s a mouse brain, and it’s certainly nowhere close to 64M times the resolution of comparable prior work…
- robwwilliams 4y agoCo-author here. Recommend reading the paper itself. The resolution comparison is to clinical MRI, not previous state of the art. Improvement compared to previous state of the art is substantial in terms of both resolution AND throughput. This work is a genuine game-changer for our neurogenetics team. We can generate 100s of very high resolution MRI dataset and get great global estimates of volumes and connectivity. We are using these methods in combination with “humanized” Alzheimer’s disease mice.
- throwawaySalmon 4y agoCan it tell if a salmon is dead? https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/scicurious-brain/ignobel-prize-in-neuroscience-the-dead-salmon-study/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/scicurious-brain/ignobe...
- eddyzh 4y agoThe mouse is dead. And they cut it up to cross-reference the data form slices. What does this have to do with MRI on a living human?